hii’m jennifer bradley i’m the director ofthe center for urban innovationat the aspen institute thank you so muchfor joining us today for this discussionon admitting understanding and learningfrom failure in local governmentthe question of failure and the moreimportant question of what happensafter failure has been something of anobsession of minesince i started the center for urbaninnovation about five years agoeverything i was learning aboutinnovation said that failurewas an important part of the innovationprocessbut at the same time i heard as so manyof you have heardthat local governments have zerotolerance for failureand we all know that can’t be true i ama die-hard champion of local governmentand have the greatest and most enduringrespectfor the people who devote their energyintelligencepatience and drive to making ourcountiescities states and towns places ofopportunity and delight but i seeand we all see large and small examplesof local governments falling shortparticularly now in the era of covet 19and increased calls for racial justiceso the question is not whether wetolerate or don’t tolerate failureas i said the question is what happensnexthow can local governments acknowledgefailure and use it to learnand do better as many of you know ontuesdaythe center for public impact and thecenter for urban innovationreleased a report on this subject whichis the culmination ofin-depth research and six intensiveworkshopswhich we call failure foundries withcities and counties around the countryand we’ll drop a link to this report inthe comment windowit’s been an absolute pleasure to workwith the cpi teamand with people in local government whobrought an enormous amount of courageand honesty to our workshopsto engage in a really scary topicum we had hoped that mayor quentin lucasthe mayor of kansas city missouri wouldbe able to join us today to give someinsights into what it feels likehe is joining us and he has joined usthis is extraordinary umthis is why on a web on a webinar aboutfailureyou can expect uh it to go anywayso mayor lucas we are so glad you couldjoin us uh we had the honor of workingwiththree kansas city departments at one ofour earliest failure foundriesmayor lucas is a lifelong kansas citiana professorat the university of kansas school oflaw and a formalformer city council member for thehistoric 18th and vine jazz districtthe mayor took office on august 1st 2019so his first year as mayor has beenquite intense mr mayor thank you so muchfor takingthe time to be with us todaythank you and it is such an honorto work with you all again uh i lookforward to the time when we can spendsome time together in personum and have a chance to have greatfollow-ups andall of that interaction we miss but uhwe will get through it welltoday and now um a few things that iwanted to mention first of alli am just about at my one yearanniversaryas mayor of kansas city andmy gosh it has been interesting everystep of the wayi thought that the super bowl victoryfor my kansas city chiefswould kind of be the one big first yearthing that i had to remembercelebrate and discuss and then we sawthe world changebefore our eyes and roughly only about amonth lateras we dealt with a coveted pandemic thenwe moved on toprotesting in our streets policingissues real questionsthat are fundamental about whatgovernment does what’s the role of lawenforcementand we’ve addressed those and we’retrying to deal with them all the whilewe also have the day-to-day ranging frompotholes to a city manager hiringto all the things you would expect of abig city mayorand so i’ll look at some of those thingsin our discussion today i usually speakwithout notes but because this was animportant groupand it’s hard to talk about failuresometimesi had to actually write something downon it because you’re used toin your speeches saying all these thingsthat we’ve done wellum but moments for reflection i thinkare so essential at least to how i getby each day and certainly how many of usdo so i’ll start kind of with some ofthe failuresthat we’ve had when i was running formayor more than a year agomy big position was to make our citysaferkansas city like chicago like baltimorest louis a number ofothers faces an epidemic of gun violenceand particularly gun violence in ourblack communitylast year 150 people were killedby firearm in comparison i believe thecity of new york was about 244their 8 million people we’re 505 000it is a very significant challenge foruswe also and in an almost heartbreakingway right we looked atum homicides but non-fatal shootingswere roughly 500 people oran amazingly high number of kansascitieswere actually just shot last year it’s achallengeso when i was running i said my goal isto get the homicide rate in kansas citybelow100 this year we’re already at 111and it’s august 6th we won’t hit thatdeadlinethat goal the question for me is whywon’t we now in a world you can have alot of excuses and i can say covet 19has ended so much of our programming andand we it’s been difficult working withthe trump department of justice and billbarr which is true and more on that in amomentbut really to me the answer is thatno we were unsuccessful in reallyrolling out new initiativesand getting to the root of what is ourviolent crime challengewell we’re not unique in american citiesin doing thatwe have to make sure we’re not lettingthe excuses perpetuate the cycle ofviolence that we see in our citiesthe reason mayoral candidate quentinlucas said we’re going to get below 100wasn’t because i was sure if it happenedbut it was because i was sure thatmayors need to change what the rhetoricis we can’t just be ribbon cutting folkswe can’t just celebrate sports teams wecan’t just celebrate if you’re inbaltimore the inner harborif you’re in st louis the gateway archif you’re in my city barbecuewe have to also make sure that we’resaying how do we address these long-termconcernsthat make it so difficult to live in theamerican city sometimesand so with that i hope in our next yearnot necessarily that we just change thenumbersbut instead we actually change what ourfocus isi referenced a moment ago in our list ofour discussion of failures working withthe white house and the attorneygeneral’s office and recently we hada not insignificant amount of ag on ourfacein connection with a federal operationby the name of operationlegend that’s an operation that has beenrolled out already in chicagokansas city and albuquerque but itstarted in our cityand the way it started speaks to in someways a failure of administrativeleadership in my own officeso um we’ve been busy of late i had ameeting withpolice hierarchy a big police commissionmeetingwhere we were talking about a number ofreforms and i largely told my staff thatdon’tbother me with anything so during thetime that they’re not bothering methe united states attorney for thisdistrict text messagesa member of my office and says hey wehave a new dojoperation would you like to be a part wedon’t get many detailsum but my general counsel she writes upa letterwe send it back to the u.s attorney’soffice which gets to the attorneygeneral which gets to the white houseand then the next day at the white housepress briefingit is announced by white house presssecretary kelly mcinanny that due to arequest from the mayorand the governor there will be a newfederal operation where they’re sendinghundreds of forcesto help us fight violent crop and ofcourse as a mayor you would saygood god right at the timeand still there were significantquestions about federal involvement inending protests in portlandthere are always discussions aboutfederal involvement interms of are you respecting localauthorities or notand so it seemed like a mission that wasto take over a control of an americancity and it fit with the president’srhetoricof there are deadly policies by deadlypoliticiansand so many were asking lucas did you dothisto which i had to say well not reallyand thus then leads to another longconvoluted discussionwhere i got an editorial actually myhometown newspaper where they said myfirst name was quentinin case you’re wondering where theheadline wasis quintonian too clintonianand i got an unfavorable piece althoughoftennice to be compared to presidentsometimes uhbut uh the piece said you know our mayorreminds usof bill clinton saying it matters whatthe definition ofis is and so you look at that situationyou say well what did we do wrongand there were a number of things onewas a pure office organizational issueright if you don’t give your office andyour staff the ability to look tosituations at which things should beelevated then you run into situationslike thisanother was a longer protocol type ofthing of what do we look to when we’rehaving communications with the federalgovernment in whateverlevel it’s represented and then theother is how do we actually respond in away that is clearyou know so often in life and i think aswe think about failuresthis is something we all have to speakto umwe want to defend ourselves we want todefendour rhetoric because we do think we didthe right thingi just had and part of the reason for myroughly 90-second delayon getting on was that i just had a citycouncil member in my officeshe is a white woman in her 60s andrecently gotaccused of making a racist remark fromthe floor of our city council chambersshe did not see race in it the blackcouncilwoman whom she was addressingdoesand now there are a number of communitygroups that are calling for herresignationi was letting her know that she neededto apologize but she was sayingi don’t have a racist bone in my bodywhy would anyone attack me like thisyou didn’t say anything mayor when thisother white council member saidsomething preposteroussix months ago or a year ago and we hadto just tell herthat’s not what it’s about it’s aboutowning up to our own failures and ourown concernswhile i was trying to rationalize thereason my office would send a letter foran operation we didn’t supporti had to sit back and say wait does itmatterdoes it actually matter or instead canyou actually tell peoplewell look these are the steps i’m doingto make sure it doesn’t becomeportland these are steps i’m making surei’m taking to make sure that we don’tsee something like that happen againand fundamentally these are the stepsi’m taking to make kansas city saferwhich is really the core issue thateveryone was trying to addressand so those are the things that i’velearned from thatissue in the middle of still dealingwith a pandemicand policing issues and violence andprotestsright you have to keep adjusting theother thing that i think is importantfor all of uswho are busy human beings which iimagine most of you areis that being busy is no excuseright we try to sometimes say oh my goshthechildren are the issue or so many othersbut we still have a job to do and a jobto perform and part of that jobis saying when we were wrong and how wecan do betterand i’ll use another example and thatrelates to the pandemic itselfone example is kind of funny andhumorous another exampleis more grave and so themore humorous one is this i umhave issued a mask order and i issued aa requirement that masks be worn insideum everywhere in kansas citymy state still has not issued a massorder even though our cases areincreasing rapidlythe state next to me kansas also umthe governor tried to issue a statewidemass order the legislaturereversed her decision and so we werekind of thisshining star in middle america of theimportance of mass quarters and issuingthem earlyall was good well after a few weeks ofprotests and other challenges i had afriend who invited me out on their boati’m starting to sound like i have akennedy scandal i promise it isn’t thatbadbut um so i go out on the boat and i’mtalking to a friend and all of thatand then i get off and i’m on the docki’m just standingand waiting but without a mask and it’sfine because no one’s therebut then about seven womenspot me and they say oh my gosh it’s themayor of kansas cityit’s the mayor and they say oh my goshcan we have a picturei can’t find a mask because i was juston a boatbut i am a politician after all right soyou’realways used to the picture with the kidsor the nice ladies and these women wereprobablyabout 20 to 25 years my senior and so isaid surei’m outside after all there’s no issueso i take a pictureand then on sunday night everythingblows upthen there’s a newspaper storytelevision images because i did theworst thing possible in politicswhich is you have an image of youscrewing upand so once again i had the chance tosayinstead of and this is a sign oflearning right instead of rationalizinginstead of saying i was on a dock or i’moni was just getting off a boat i’m stillwet i said you know whati screwed up and i should have had mymask onand in some ways similar to the councilwoman i was just talking about i wantedto say wellmy governor actually just aggressivelydoesn’t wear masks nor do my senatorsand all these othersbut you know actually the message i wantwas it’s importantand i should have had it and i didn’tand how do we move on to make sure otherpeople doand how do we move on to say that peoplearen’t perfectand i think uh if there’s anythingthat i have learned whether it bepretty much the daily challenge of beinga mayor i will tell yousomeone who was a city council member ayear and a half agoit is very different i’ve been in publicoffice but nobody cared what i didbeforefor the most part whereas now rightyou’re you’re seensometimes you’re on television i’ve hada few national television hits i was inarecent interview on cnn but the moreinteresting one was on fox news withchris wallacewhere we had an interesting battle aboutthe administrationbut i have to realize that yes i have adifferent platform nowand rather than using the platform to insome ways build a cult of identity anddefensivenessand there have been mayors that havebeen bedeviled by for those of you whoare in washington you’llremember the travails of marion barrywhoeven though right he might have had anumber of interesting ideas for thepeople of washington andhe was largely doomed not just by hisown personal demons but by his ownneed to justify and rationalize whatwerein some ways largely objectively flawedbehaviorsi think it’s important for many of us toactually sayokay what am i trying to accomplish eachday an accomplishment isn’t justhow do i make mayor lucas look good orfeel good or defend myselfbut instead how do i make my communitysafer how do i make my communityhealthierhow do i make sure that we’re doingright by our cityand the amazing thing that i’ve seen inmy just year of officeis how much positive attention will comeyour way if you focus on thoseright i my my national tv hitsor interviews have nothing to do with mebeing able to say hey everybody loves mei have a 95approval rating which i do not it’s insand in fact it drops precipitously bythe day it’s amazing when you do thingsa lotthen the criticism certainly comes yourway but instead that attention comesfrom somebody who’s tryingsomebody who’s working hard somebodywho’s showing a streak of independencesomebody who’s working across the aisleat a time when it isn’t necessarilypopularand that’s what i think all of us needto focus on morei said i had another pandemic exampleand i doand this related to when we werereopeningand i remember thatwe were reopening far too soon and inthe midwest and the southwestfor those of you who are in these partsof the country you’re seeing thatexample umand to me the challenge has been welluh how do we continue to make sure thatwe’re bringing other peopleon board aboard of our our effortsand so when we were reopening we saidwe’re only going to allow reopen it at10capacity for no more than 10 persons andif you stayed somewhere for 10 minutesyou had to sign inand make sure things were easier forcontact tracingwe stood by that issue while people weresaying that lucas is a nazi which was anattack and i received a lot of hate mailwe said this is to help stem the tide ofthe pandemicthose efforts have continued to makekansas city healthier than a number ofcities near us other midwestern citiesand it’s something i’m proud of and sosometimesrecognizing failure is recognizingwhen you have to just kind of say what’sright and wrongand other times it’s actually standingup for what you believe inevery step of the way we’ve tried to dothat and we’ve tried to get a lot of thepolitics and the marketing out of itand that’s what i think all of us needto do as we look to survive a pandemicas we look to survive a moment of racialreconciliationas we look to see what the american cityand frankly what our country will belikelong after this moment is over with thati say thank you so muchand i’ve enjoyed the opportunity tovisit with youthank you so much mayor lucas for thatextraordinarystory of candor andintegrity on some of the most hot buttonissuesof our day in just a few minutes weheardstories about the biggest issues thatwe’re facingrace policing and covid19and i hope that everyone watchingappreciates this exampleof facing failure being honest and as wesay asking what’s nextand continuing to do what needs to bedonefor constituents in the country as awhole so we are extremely gratefulfor the time that you were able to sharewith usthank you now we have a superbpanel to talk about the creatinga culture of constructive failure inlocal governmentuh we’re going to drop their their biosin the chat so that we can spend moretime talking amongst ourselves and lesstime talking about ourselvesso i’m going to start with a questionfor tina walla whois the chief innovation officer in thecity of seattlethe city of seattle as all of you knowtina as you know all too welluh seattle was once the epicenter ofcovid19how did that change the context forexperimentation failure and innovationin your city governmentthanks jennifer and uh thanks to cpi andaspen institute for hosting thisimportant conversationgreat question um and i’ll start bysaying that when in local government wethink about innovation it’s because wewant to be the firstwe want to be able to say that we arethe first city to do somethingthat was not the case in this situationumbeing the initial epicenter of covet 19in the united states wasextremely challenging but it did it alsounleashed an opportunity to innovatethat did not allow for hesitationum just to take you back you may recallthat in early marchwhen the seattle area was seeing ourcounts go up and our deaths goup there wasn’t a lot of knowledge orevidence base in the global healthcommunity for us to tap intoand so what we had to do was take theinformation we did haveand make the best decisions we could andand take actionbecause from our perspective failure totake actionand and too much sort of overthinkingliterally could lead to lives being lostso for us we had to accept that failurewas a potential outcomebut we knew that um sort of followingthe spirit of experimentation if i cansaythat was the name of the game tryingthings outiterating changing course if thingsdidn’t workbut we we very clearly got directionfrom from our mayor mayor jenny jerkinin seattleto try anything and um and to continueiterating because at the end of the daywe had residents who we were reallyconcerned aboutum i’ll end thatgreat thanks so much um jessicajessica picardo is a partner at bostonconsulting groupwho has throughout the course of hercareer worked with many levelsof government jessica i’m wonderingare the changes that are that werebrought by covidum so tina’s point that you know there’sa there’s afinding that right point betweenthinking too much and doing too littledo you have you seen changes that youthink will persistand become structural in localgovernment and could those either helpinnovationor do you see that there’s a spirit ofconservatism small cnot political that might uhhinder innovation conservatism meaning aresistance to changenothing political in there okay thanksjen for that question and thank you allfor attending and for this great paneluh so let me start stating the obviouswhich is covered 19 disrupthas disrupted the government big time ithink lessobvious is to really umthink about what changes will sticki think i will highlight three keychanges that i’ve seenand i think have the potential tohave a large impact in how governmentsoperate for the longer runso the first one is around um as we’veseen in many many sectors not onlygovernment but this accelerationtowards more digital this takes twoformsone is we see more remote workum but in government it has been um evenmore surprising because there’s somejobs and some tasks that we neverthoughtthat were going to be done online justto give you an example that i knoweveryone is aware of is like the ussupreme courthearing for the first time um you knowwe assume doing hearingsso that was you know first time inhistory that that happenedand many people have said that’simpossible uh six months agoand the second form that digitalacceleration is taking is really aboutmore digital services now being providedonline so there’s more and more we’reseeing states and local governments andeven in the federal levelservices that are being provided onlineto enroll forfor for many things and then have moreinformation that isat the in apps etc the second big changethat i thinkum maybe you know maybe gaining somemomentum is a larger role of governmentand so i think we we see you know withthis unprecedentedum thing that covet wrought aboutthere’s also anunprecedented response from governmentin terms of historiclevels of uh stimulus packages and so onbut this has also shown some cracks inthe system right we see adisproportionate effectan impact on some populations like blackand latins we also seemaybe okay the health care system couldbe better so i think there is potentialmomentumfor the government to maybe address someimbalances andand potentially you know startdelivering services for allmaybe that’s wishful thinking but i’veseen you know some of those trendsand then let me just finish uh with thefact that covet has shown the fragilityof the system on societies and there’smore of a name and an askto think about how to build societiesthat are more resilientso we see governments thinking now aboutsupply chains how come we build supplychains that are more resilientin education you know can we think aboutonlinereally online education really workingand maybe a certaincan hybrid models really work um and wemayi’ve seen very good solutions on upskiing and risk reskillingdisplaced workers so i i’ve seen so ithink overall i’m verypositive and very optimistic even thoughthis is very sad momentsbut i do think there’s an opportunityfor the government to reimagine itselfthanks so much jessica one of the thingsthat i’ve seen in my careeris that process change is neverfully successful unless it’s accompaniedby a culture changeand so for our next question i want toturn tomy good friend neil clayman who is apublic policy professorat new york university and director ofnyu’s wagner innovation labsneil you’ve done an enormous amount ofwork particularly recentlyon local government culture change whatare you learningabout the kinds of culture changes uhthat supportinnovation that either respond to themoment that tina found herself in inearly march or these largerissues that jessica just raised with usand you’re on mute so if you wanted togo off mute we could hear your greatideasperfect all right can you hear me greatso thanks for that intro and thanks fordoing this reportuh because really if you’re talkingabout embracingfailure learning from failure it’s abouthow organizations work and how they dotheir work and there’s so little doneon that topic so i’m glad that thisreport is out thereand as you said i’ve been doing a lot ofresearch on organizational culturemyself for the last two yearsi have been involved in a project withbloomberg philanthropiesand the harvard city leadershipinitiative and my nyu colleaguealexander sherman song and it’s wrappingup right nowand we learned a ton and one of thereasons we learned so muchis there’s almost nothing written aboutorganizational culture and and we wentinto this assuming that there was a lotout there becausein the business literature and amongstbusiness executives there’s so muchdiscussionof what organizational culture means areyou a caringcollaborative company like a disney orare you a ruthlessdisrupter like an uber uh they’re allthese books out there like who moved mycheese and others and the harvardbusiness review and fast company and onand on and on butalmost nothing about how public sectororganizationsuh can change the work that they do andthis is criticalbecause culture drives everythingit is the unwritten rules that dictatehow workgets done and you can think of it a bitlike the language of anorganization everybody speaks it but noone stops to identifywhat it is and and i learned just howimportant culture was whenbefore the pandemic locked us all up iwould go to different conferenceslike conferences hosted by aspen andothers and i would go around tocolleagues and other aides and saywhat’s the biggest obstacle or barrieryou found in terms of advancinginnovative policy and i heard again andagain and againthat it’s organizational culture or somevariation of that whether that be hr hrrules or work behaviorsso clearly it’s organizational culturethatthat will stop innovation or learningfrom failure right in its tracksand so to address that really has a lotto do with what the report says which ishow do you build trustand building trust is almost synonymouswith uhorganizational culture and improvementand i would just mention three thingsherequickly uh one is and that’s why i’m soglad we had mayor lucas kansas city isone of the places we looked at it reallystarts with leadershipand uh leadership throughout theorganization but certainly at the topso you need leadership that’s crystalclear on the types of changes that areneededand if we’re talking about embracingfailure what exactly does that meanconcretely and having a narrative in alanguage that accompaniesit and then what’s also so important andi think often gets overlookedin the public sector is training andtraining can takemany shapes and sizes and one of thecities we looked atthat was very impressive in this regardis louisville kentuckyand there you had a lot of formaltraining that took placewith the help of organizations liketoyota and humanaand others around six sigma where thereare established principlesaround organizational change includingembracing failurebut louisville also had more informaltraining more peer-to-peer training thatwas ledand took root and helped to spread theideasaround organizational improvement soi’ll stop therethanks neil um our report as youmentioned doeshave uh several markers of kind ofcultural change so i thinkthat we are at an exciting point in thefield where we’re starting to build thisbody so we’ll have something in a fewyears i hope that’s comparable to thebusinessliterature and that’s a great segue toask a question of sarah hunterwho is director of public policy at xthe moonshot factorysarah you know neil mentioned that thebusiness culture hasa lot of storytelling a lot of resourcesa lot of research around failureyou often intersect or work at theintersectionof government and business what’stranslatablefrom the business sector to the publicsector when we talk about failureum thanks for having me uh that’s agreat question i thinkyou know x just as context is a sistercompany to google soyou know when i talk with public sectororganizations there’soften quite a lot of cynicism about theextent to which the innovationculture that we try to instill at xcan be replicated within governmentyou know we we have a lot more money toplay with and we havea lot more risk tolerance um if you likebecause it’s not taxpayer money and allof that is trueum but i also think there’s a lot ofum principles that are absolutelyapplicable in fact probably more soto the public sector than in the privatesector for example the disasterexperiment actually comes out ofa recognition that the status quo isn’tgood enough andthere’s no one who understands thatbetter than the public sector you knowoften withinsilicon valley we rather naively can seethe failures of ofthe existing status quo we don’t reallyunderstand it in the way that the publicsectorum frontline staff do also franklyhaving money doesn’treally help often having a lot of moneymeans you just throwmore peopleso we are having a little bit of alag with sarah’s audio um so i’m goingto turn itokay now you’re back great sorry umwe had a uh a project using deliverydronesand there we weren’t really using theexperiment experimentation mindsetappropriately we were sort of proppingup the demo with peopleand creating circumstances umwhere actually we weren’t learning asmuch as we should whereas when you don’thave a lot ofpeople and money to to prop up umdemos you actually really learn quicklywhat works andand and how to sort of iterate it forthe next next version soi actually think the public sector imean let’s be honest the moonshotwas invented by by the government soit’s not something thatthe private sector owns and frankly ithink more umbig picture uh goals and sort of moonshots should be set by governmentsnow more than ever frankly thanks somuch sarahand now i’ll turn to josh soren who isthe program directorof for city innovation at the center forpublic impactand uh one of the leading forces andminds behindthis report and has been a great partnerto work with throughoutas i was saying josh you facilitatedsome of the failure foundries whichbrought together department directorsmid-level managers and frontline workersto talkabout failure and the culture of theirdepartmentswas there something that surprised youin those conversationsyeah thanks so much jennifer uh thereare several things that surprise mefirst and foremost i think it’s thedegree to which thecultures and structures of governmentwhich ostensibly were created to promoteaccountability and reduce riskhave done basically the exact oppositeover timethis becomes you know readily apparentfrom talking to people that work ingovernment onparticularly on the front lines that bynot having a culture where they canacknowledge failure be honest about itandby not having the structures throughwhich they can shareand communicate about those failuresboth across and within their departmentsit’s created more risk not lessthat risk is just much harder to see andthat’s aproblem for a lot of reasons that arereadily apparent but one of those isthatyou know that that risk when you sweepit under the rugso to speak starts to develop uhaccumulate debt right andbasically what you’re doing is you’retrading acknowledgement ofsmall failures in the short term you’retrading that forlarger failures in the long term andthat’s what leads todisasters so that’s that’s the firstthing i think surprised me was justhow apparent those structures and theculture of government have created thatriski think the second thing that stuck withme and it was probably a thing thatreally stuck with me mostwas just a really intense strain thatthis type of culture of risk aversionhason the human relationships withingovernment itselfnot just between leaders and theirdirect reportsbut between people at the same level wehad a quote in the report where we saiduh 47 percent sorry it was a stat 47particip47 percent of participants said theyrarely discuss mistakes and failureswith their co-workersthat’s pretty shocking right um that youyou don’t work in an environment whereyou can sharewhat’s going wrong with the people thatyou work with you don’t feel like youhave that psychological safety withinyour culturewhere you can be vulnerable and behonest about what’s going on and youknow either commiserate oror share these experiences with yourwith your coworkers and i thinkwe’ve all worked in environments i’mwilling to bet we’ve all worked inenvironments whether it’s in the publicsector or the private sector or thesocial sectorwhere we’ve had um that that type ofenvironment right where we we weren’table to shareuh what was going on with us eitherpositive or negative we had bosses thatyou know were really bringing the hammerdown when there were failures and that’sjust nota positive environment to work in and itdoesn’t bring out the best in peopleand i think if we want to tapinto the really untapped potential ofthe workforce within government itstarts by thinking creating a positivework environmentwhere they can share what’s working andwhat’s notand then on that last point i would justsay to end on a positive notethere’s the thing that i came away mostinspired fromour work was just the tremendousappetiteand hunger for driving change at alllevels within governmentfrom the department leadership to peoplethat work on the front linesthey know that there’s a problem withculture right and they know that itleads tonot the outcomes that they’re lookingfor for the residents that they serveand they want to do something about itthey just need to be working in anenvironment that allows them to flourishand to do those thingsso that’s that’s the thing i would say ii came away with is feeling dauntedsometimes aboutthe challenges that governmentworkforces face but also really inspiredby their ability to drive that changeand their desire to do sothanks so much josh um and i will justadd from my own experiencethere was a sense of almost joy in therooms where weheld the boundaries um almost a sense ofreliefthat people were finally able to kind ofbe who they were andsay what they knew which gives me a lotof hopeand again only adds to the respect ihave for people who are doing this workevery single day now we’re going to openit up fora discussion sort of same questionamongst the panelists uhtina i’ll go back to you you werenodding vigorously at various pointsof the other uh folks conversationshow do we take this culture change thatwe’ve been talking aboutand you know certainly forced by some oftheuh larger shaping changes that jessicamentioned around moving to digitalum greater needs and and the revelationof fragilityhow do we take this culture changearound failureand move it from department todepartment orfrom city to city what might that looklike inseattle um[Music]so i and i i was nodding vigorouslybecausethe panelists have um really touched onsome key things thati see is critical um neil touched ontrustsarah talked about risk tolerance andjosh was talking about the structuresand highlighting one of the key themesin the failing forward report aroundhuman relationshipsin response to your question i’ll saythat one thing that i’m prettypassionate aboutis underscoring the need the criticalneed for management at all levelsin an organization to be open abouttheir own failuresand to embody a growth mindsetfor their for their teams to be able tolead by example and make spacefor reflection candid conversations anddiscussiondoing that in a way that um[Music]really helps staff understand that youknowwe shouldn’t have to wait for one ofthese workshops for people to feel thatsense of release and thatuh to have that opportunity to beopen and candid about talking aboutfailure rightum one thing we do in seattle is weum within my team we have uh quarterlystep backs and we use different uhmodels one is a learning zones modelwhere with each of my colleagues we wetalk through experiences that they’vehad where they were in the comfort zoneexperiences where they’re in thelearning zone and sort of stretchingthemselvesand then when they are in the panic zoneand being able to have thoseconversations openlyand say hey that’s great that you’re inthe comfort zone let’s push you a littlebitlet’s let’s try to lean into areas thatmay be less familiarto allow for that opportunity forinnovationand and recognizing that failure failuremay occurand and that’s okay the one thing i’llsay thatwhen i think about this culture changeacross departments within governmentit’s really key to remember that when wethink about innovationand the possibility of failure we reallyneed to hold equity front centerto think about who is most burdened bythat innovationwho’s most affected by failure and toreally be mindful of that so that we’rebeing thoughtful and intentional abouthow we’rebest sort of pushing the envelope onbetter serving our residentsyeah i i totally agree with you i thinkit’s umit’s it’s from the top down this sort ofculture ofembracing the value of failure comesbut it’s also incredibly hard to do imean you know despite the fact i work anorganization whichtalks a lot about failure which is inthe valley where failure is sort ofalmost a brand of honoryou forget that it goes againsteverything we’ve been taught as childrenwe’ve always been taught to succeed likewe don’t talk about failure with ourfamilies we don’t talk about failurewith anyone we’re sort ofalways talking about how we’re doingbetter right and so actually in ourcompany we have to we do so many thingsto try andsort of try and get people to go againsttheir training ofof decades and it’s really really hardto do and i’ve noticed actuallyone of the things that we forget is thatas leaderswe say like everyone they should beready to fail and we run off we runevents wherewe get people to talk about it we do athing where we get people to write theirfailure resumeso write your resume as if you were sortof you know all the things you failed atbut as leaders were often very reluctantto be vulnerable enough to say this iswhere i failed as welland actually it doesn’t work if theleaders aren’t prepared toadmit to failure and to defend failurein the face of mediacriticism in the face of i mean it’shardbut i do think it’s the only way to doit to be honestneil you uh had a reaction to that umand then we’ll go to joshgreat can you hear yeah excellent soum just two points here and and sarahand tina are exactly right you knowlearning from failure is just it’s veryhard to do so you have to recognize thatbuttwo suggestions i would have especiallyfor leadership is one isyou need to break out of the a team thattypically it’s thoseimmediate aids right around a citymanager mayorother municipal executive that feel asthough they have the luxury to learnfrom failure but nobody else doesright and so one of the ways you can dothis is to create cohorts of managersdeputy managers and frontlineadministratorswithout a doubt who know that they havethe ability to learn from what they’redoing just as much as theexecutive team does too the other thingi would sayis that they’re really and this mighteven be harder than organizationalchangewhich is that budgets need to haveconsequences right so let’s say adepartmentuh takes on this new approach and theylearn from failure but the budget isstill the same year in and year outeverybody else is just going to shrugtheir shoulders and say why should wetrybut the minute you make it clear thatthe budget does have consequences andthe organization is learning from whatit’s doingthen you begin to see that innovationand that approach spreadjosh you had some thoughts and thenjessica uh i saw that you wanted to saysomething as welluh you need to go off mute josh thereyou gogreat yeah well just building off ofwhat neil just said i think first theidea of democratizinginnovation within local government iscritically importantum you know oftentimes people feel thatinnovation is just thejob of people that have innovationwithin their titlebut that’s not true you know improvinggovernment should be the role foreveryoneand i think we need to start to seeleaders empowering peopleon the front lines who know the problemsbestto to drive that innovation um so asi love what you said neil about kind ofbreaking out of the aid teamum and then i think going back to acouple things that were said beforeso tina talked about kind of a need forleaders to be vulnerable and engagepeople in conversationand i think i totally agree with that ithink i would add on to that and say butthey also need to demonstrate resultsright and show that they’re acting onthe suggestions that they’re receivingsomething that we heard a lot in thefailure foundries that we did waspeople saying like hey you’re not thefirst person to tell usthat it’s not the first director thatwe’ve worked with who’s told us thatlike we should put forth our ideas andshow us where the problems areand guess what we put forth ideas itgoes into the ether and we never hearfrom it ever againand so like why is this time differentand so i thinkyou know talking about it beingvulnerable leaders doing those things isthe first stepbut then they also tangibly need to acton those things they need to demonstratesome results not notch some early winsto show that change actually is going tohappen because i think peopleparticularly on the front lines ingovernment are are rightly skepticalof people coming in saying hey we’regoing to change things this is like thenew regime we’re going to do thingsbetterum and then the final thing i would sayto what sarah was mentioning and sarah iremember this when weuh interviewed you probably about a yearago for this reportyou know i was asking you how do you howdoes the moonshot factory how does xcreate this culture where people want totake risks and embrace itand you were like yeah i mean we haveartwork on the walls and we you know wewe do failure pizza parties and we havethese conversations with peopleuh and just kind of reinforce this ideaand i remember being struck by thatbecause it was these little changesright there was no silver bullet forcreating the culture it was these littlechanges that are reinforcedover time again and again that reallyarethe keys to kind of building thatculture but it’s not easy work even foruh x and i think we saw that play out inthe workshops a couple of times rightwhereuh people would be almost a little bitdisappointedat times they’d be like wait where’swhere’s the big idea where’s like thething that’s really going to drive thischange it’s like well first of allyou’re the one that has to drive thechange not us but second of all there isno silver bullet it is a lot ofsmall incremental changes reinforcedover timethat create that culture and it’s it’shard work for surejessica what are your thoughts on thisumso i think everyone’s i don’t want toadd a lot i think you all saidmany of the things i’ve seen rightleadership has to come to from the topbudgets matter and the only thing iwould add given my experiencei had an experience in them in a federalgovernment an agency that had been doingwith a team that had been doing the samething the same way for 20 years and whenwe came there and said hey can you do itdifferently can you do it faster theirfirst response was like nowe tried it doesn’t work right so itdidn’t we weren’t thinking about likehuge information but justthinking about different ways of workingi think that did help tactically we hadleadership support we had a budget butstillit was not we were finding someobstacleswhat worked really really well and whatled to people say at the end of theproject likewe i actually enjoy coming to my workright now because it’s somuch fun and i see things changing onewas wecreated work um cross working dreams soso it was not just one agency or oneteam we had like many other agencieslike the customersright so we created teams that had manydifferent people sowhat they thought they knew well theydidn’t really know and they werethey had to find that out by talking sonow the accountability was spreadand it was it really changed the dynamicand what i would say is like we alsorealized that they needed some traininglike one daysuddenly was at all we have to do thingsdifferently now we’re going to do dailyhuddles and you’re going tobe looking at outcomes we actually hadto show themlearning by doing right like we wereworking with them closely and showingthem becauseof course they have been doing the samething for so many years andin time we were changing the wholecontext for them so i thinkthose i would only add those two thingsto all the great things everyone saidgreat um our conversation has been soengaging to me that but we do need to goto qa after this one question and i’m goingto encourage the panelistsyou know it’s coming to answer it in onesentenceso in one sentence this is everybody’sbig tweetable momentwhat is the one thing that you wantpeopleto leave this webinar knowingneil i’ll go to you first i know you’vegot to leave a couple of minutes earlyso i want to make sure we hear from youuh i would say that metrics are notare the means to the end right thatmetrics when you’re looking at failurecan’tbe the end unto itself but it has to bea path to understanding the organizationand failuregreat uh sarah over to youoh i wish there was only one sentence icould haveum i guess at a highest level umyou’re going to be the one person in 10that actually makes a change you’regoing to have to fail nine times to gettherethat was a good sentence joshuh one sentence felt tough okay uh inanycomplex system failure is inevitableit’s just going to happen and i think ifyou take that as a given and understandthat failure is inevitableum the question then becomes what areyou going to do about it right are yougoing to acknowledge it or are you goingto sweep it under the rugi think we as a society and governmentand even in the private sectorneed to get better at acknowledgingthose failures and then doing somethingabout itgreat uh jessicaum so i would just say that i’ve met themost passionate and committed people inthe public sector people who really wantto make a difference sohow can we really leverage that rightit’s a strengthit’s a it’s a superpower so let’s let’smake sure we leverage thatand uh we will close out by hearing fromone of those really committed anddedicatedsuperhero people tinaum so i think particularly withlocal governments uh fiscal currentfiscal situation in mindi want us all to think about whengovernment has to spend that next taxpayer dollarnext dollar when you’re deciding whereit goes we have to do so withstewardshipand equity at the forefront and i thinkthat that is an opportunityfor uh partners like philanthropyand and others to commit to workingtogether to thinking aboutwhere can government take risk and wherewhere might it be welcome for others tohelp us with taking that riskrecognizing we are the social safety netof our most vulnerableresidents and that is key to ensuring anequitablesupport system for residents thanks somuchnow we are moving to audience questionsif you haven’t had a chance todrop questions in the chatplease do now this question is going tobe a hybrid of one that was asked byfrancisco reynosoand one that was asked by darren batesbecause theycome to the same theme about what do youdo ifleadership is not likemayor lucas if leadership is veryresistant to failurethat if they are activelydisincentivizingchange uh jessica in your experience howis there a way that you can come thatyou can intervene in the middle ifleadership is not there orshould you just try to work somewhereelseyou’ll need to unmute yourself that’sthat’s a great question i i wish therewas a simple answer i thinkyou’re starting with it’s not the bestcontext right i think as we all said andand we had the experts the people withexpertise in the ground and thenthe theorists that’s the the worstscenario like leadership starting withleadership supportis kind of a necessary conditionwhat i would say is i think there’s alsoa rethinking of what leadership who isleadership rightthere is potentially one person that isan obstacle or one set ofof um you know disincentivesso i would think about it in terms oflike what are the incentives that weneed to changeright and potentially that can changeleadership and then also saying okay isone leader having an issue howis there other leaders that can we canhave as championsso i will still start thinking about thetop it’s true that we grassroot connectssometimes make change but when we thinkabout organizational changetypically you need to think aboutleadership supportand having champions at the top so yeahhope that helps um so tina here is aquestion for youum from manali who askshow are governments adaptingcommunication strategies to learn moreabout what people needand addressing them to ensure thewell-being of the population and i thinkthis goesright to where you’ve been bringing usback towhich is equity and making sure thatthat when we talk about failure uh we doso with deep respect that there arepeopleuh literally whose lives are at stake umand and so we just have to be thoughtfuland center those folksgreat question um i i know that here inseattle we’ve beenpretty intentional and we have there’salways room for improvement soum lots of opportunity to get better butwe’ve been trying to listen and engagewith those voices that haven’t typicallyhad a seat at the tableand that is disproportionatelycommunities of color right and soi think there’s a lot of ways to do thatwe’ve beenengaging more with like grassroots mediaand and the not mainstream media andhave found that to be a greatopportunityto listen and for us to learn and thento also justengage in dialogue to ensure that thereis aconnection point with uh with ourresidentsi’ll also show that um we’ve been uhemployingsomething that i know the failingforward report mentions it’s a core partof how we work here in seattle which ishuman-centered designto go out and listen um for examplewe’ve been having we had an outbreakin june of covid that was associatedwith the young adultsat the university of washington so rightnow we are in the midst of a designsprint where we’re interviewing thoseyoung adultsto understand what do they need tobetter understand how to navigate thistimewhat supports what are we not givingthem right now that they would benefitfromso i think just as many as manystrategies fitan organization’s needs thatallow you to go out and listen andengage with those voices whotypically aren’t aren’t coming to citycouncil meetings or at hearingsgreat um so this is a question fromjason whitt who has a lot of experienceworking in and around local governmentuh and he asks what are the bestmechanismsfor turning intention into action inurban innovationuh josh what is that what does thatstepwise process look like to youwell i think it starts with mindsets andbeliefs right i think you need toand then we talk about this report youneed to start with building the rightmindsets thatallow you to drive to allow you toacknowledge failures and thenbelieve that you can actually then dosomething about it and we also talkabout the the need for having stronghuman relationships everything thatpeople have talked about before aboutthe need for leaders communicate clearlyand show vulnerability and show thatit’s okay to learn from failurebut to me that that doesn’tdo much unless you have systems andprocesses that can actually underpinthat right so you can saylike hey let’s take some time and let’sreflect and learn from what’s not goingwell and then think about how we can dosomething about itbut most people that work in and arounda local government will describe it asyou know playing like a game ofwhack-a-mole where you’re just kind ofconstantly putting out fires and thereisn’t that time it’sthe mayor lucas talked about it as wellabout you know always being really busybutthat’s not an excuse and i think we needto find ways to build in the time inspace for people to reflectand then have that same time and spacefor them to drive that reflection intoactual action um and then something thatthe neil talked about as well as i thinkchanging the incentive structures aroundthat can actually reward responsiblerisk-taking in this for the sake ofdeveloping solutions in the long termsir i’ll put that question to you aswell what are the best mechanisms forturning intentioninto action in the realm of urbaninnovation yeahi definitely agree with josh thatactually some systemicuh incentives not not just becauseactuallychanging incentives does change behaviorbut because in setting in place newincentivesyou’ve gone through quite a sort of wideconsultation process withinyour organization such that this isgoing to stick it’s not going to beunpicked bythe finance department or you know themayor or someone else likein in putting in place bonuses forpeople who shut down projects forexample which is what we have at xyou have to have some sort of agreementthe other thing i’d suggesti mean this is obviously um somethingthat we do a lot offinding a partner to innovate with isoften a good way to kick-start some ofthat you knowit gives you an ally to go out withinthe public to say look we’re workingwith some experts or some people who’vedone this beforeit also brings with it some bestpractice you want to make sure they’regoing to stick with you you want to makesure thatyou are all aligned in your goals andthey’ve got the appetite forpublic sector innovation um but i oftenthink that’s quite a nice way also toget leaders on site who may be a littlebituncertain you know every reluctantleader loves a moment in the pr sonso it tends to help get them on board aswelland give them confidence they’re notgoing to be out on their own oftenleaders who are reluctant to changethingsare scared and so you need to find waysto bolster their confidence thatalthough there is risk and althoughfailure is going to be part of theprocess there isa win at the end of it that the processitself is going to get themsomething good great um i wish we couldkeep talking about this subjectuh hour upon hour but people do havethings to do and one of the things wetry to do at aspen ishold trust by keeping to time so i willjust saythanks to all of our extraordinarypaneliststhanks enormously to mayor lucas and histeamfor showing up with the best of localgovernment which ishumility vulnerability and honestybecause local government is adeeply human endeavor and the more thatwe recognize our own humanityincluding failure the better we will athe better we will be able to serveum humans who are the end and the reasonwhy local government exists so thanks somuch we’ll have a recording of thisout either later today or tomorrow andyou will all get itwe welcome your tweets and your feedbackat aspen urban innova thanks so muchhave a great day
Local governments everywhere are showing resilience, speed, and innovative spirit in the face of an unprecedented crisis. They are taking risks, failing, and learning as they go. But this spirit of experimentation and learning from failure is all too rare in local government. This expert panel of city leaders, technologists, and innovators discuss why it is usually so hard to learn from failure in government and what governments and their allies can do about it.
Jessica Boccardo, Partner, Boston Consulting Group
Sarah Hunter, Director of Public Policy, X – The Moonshot Factory
Neil Kleiman, Director, Wagner Innovation Labs, NYU
Josh Sorin, Program Director, City Innovation, Centre for Public Impact
Tina Walha, Director of Innovation & Performance, Seattle, WA
Jennifer Bradley, Director, Aspen Institute Center for Urban Innovation
Mayor Quinton Lucas
Kansas City, MO
Quinton Lucas, “Mayor Q,” was sworn in as the 55th mayor of Kansas City on August 1, 2019. Quinton created and chairs the City’s Special Committee on Housing Policy. Born and raised in Kansas City, Quinton has spent most of his life in the city’s urban core. As a child, he moved often and experienced homelessness, sometimes staying with family or friends, or residing in a motel. Despite these challenges, Quinton remained focused on his schoolwork, earning academic scholarships to high school, college and Cornell Law School before returning home to Kansas City. Since 2012, Quinton has been a member of the University of Kansas Law School faculty, where he served as one of the youngest tenure-track law professors in the country. He is active in the Kansas City community and volunteers extensively in area schools and organizations, including providing mentorship in local prisons. Mayor Quinton Lucas lives in the Historic 18th and Vine Jazz District, which he previously represented on the City Council.
Jessica Boccardo
Partner, Boston Consulting Group
Jessica Boccardo is a core member of Boston Consulting Group’s Public Sector and People & Organization practices, and has supported strategic initiatives and large scale organization and agile transformations for a range of government, non-profit, and private sector clients in different geographies. Jessica focuses on clients in the public sector, and the education and health sectors, and works with them on issues related to strategy, change management, leadership development, agile and major transformation. Recently, Jessica led an agile transformation for a large health care federal agency covering process improvement and change management as well as HR strategy. She also led a strategic and organizational transformation of a global higher-education company and defined the strategy and action plan for disaster relief for a US local branch of government. Before joining the firm in 2013, Jessica worked at the World Bank and the Inter-American Development Bank on developing and implementing strategies for private sector development, growth, and export competitiveness.
Sarah Hunter
Director of Public Policy, X – The Moonshot Factory
Sarah Hunter is the Director of Global Public Policy at X, the Moonshot Factory, part of Alphabet. X – formerly Google X – is a diverse group of inventors and entrepreneurs who build and launch technologies that aim to improve the lives of millions of people. X works across a wide range of technologies and sectors, from self driving cars to life sciences and drones. Sarah joined X in 2013 and lived in California for five years, running a team that translates between the engineers and scientists at X and the policy makers and regulators in Government. She now works globally, based in the UK, on policy and technology issues that affect X across the world. Prior to joining X, Sarah ran the UK Public Policy team for Google for four years, leading the company’s work around internet policy issues such as copyright and start-up innovation. From 2000-2005, Sarah worked in frontline British politics as a Senior Policy Adviser to Prime Minister Tony Blair on Culture, Media and Sport, working on the London2012 Olympic bid and the BBC’s Charter renewal. Prior to government Sarah held senior roles at both the BBC and C4, advising on broadcasting, media and technology policy. Sarah is a part time lecturer at Stanford Univerity and a Board member of doteveryone, the responsible technology think tank. In real life, Sarah loves making bread, running trails and hanging out with her three children, rabbits, cats and dogs at home in Bath.
Neil Kleiman
Director, Wagner Innovation Labs, NY
Neil Kleiman has a joint appointment at the Wagner School of Public Service and the Center for Urban Science + Progress. He is a Senior Fellow at The GovLab and an Affiliated Scholar at the Marron Institute of Urban Management. In 2017, he published a book with Stephen Goldsmith on urban governance reform entitled A New City O/S: The Power of Open, Collaborative and Distributed Governance on Brookings Institution press. Kleiman serves as the MS Program Director at CUSP and as Director of the NYU Wagner Innovation Labs. He is also Director of Policy and Evaluation for the National Resource Network. Kleiman holds a Ph.D. in Political Science from the Graduate Center of the City University of New York. In addition to teaching at NYU, he has also taught urban policy at Barnard College, John Jay College-CUNY, Tulane, Universidad de los Andes (Bogota) and has been a visiting fellow at Williams College. Kleiman is on the board of Next City and Civic Consulting USA.
Josh Sorin
Program Director, City Innovation, Centre for Public Impact
Josh Sorin leads CPI’s City Innovation work in North America, where the team incubates new ideas about how innovation can be used to create more effective and legitimate governments, and then puts those ideas into action by collaborating with cities and their partners to design, prototype, and implement solutions to their most pressing problems. Prior to joining CPI, Josh managed projects in KPMG’s Public Sector Advisory Practice, where he supported state and local governments in transforming programs, policies, and processes to improve outcomes for underserved communities. Josh also co-founded an education startup and a non-profit supporting the third-largest public health & hospital system in the U.S.
Tina Walha
Director of Innovation & Performance, Seattle, WA
Tina Walha serves as Director of Innovation & Performance, leading a talented and committed team of professionals that work closely with City departments to solve problems. Her past experience includes serving as a policy advisor to Mayor Mike Bloomberg in New York City and as a management consultant to government and nonprofit leaders at the city, county, state, Federal, and international levels to create actionable enterprise strategic plans and explore innovative financing mechanisms. She holds degrees in Economics and International Studies from UNC-Chapel Hill and a Master of Public Affairs degree from Princeton University.
Jennifer Bradley
Director, Aspen Institute Center for Urban Innovation
THE BEST OF ASPEN DIGITAL, RIGHT IN YOUR INBOX.
Sign up for our email list to stay current on our work.