good evening everyoneand welcome uh my name is betsy cooperand iam the director and the founder of theaspen tech policyhub it is super wonderful to have somany of you here with us todayfor those of you who are new to us theaspen tech policy hub is a policyincubator that trains technologists inthe policy processthrough fellowship and executiveeducation programsi’m thrilled to welcome you all today toour last demonstration day eventof the second cohort of the techexecutive leadership initiativealso known as telly the tele program isa joint initiative of the aspen techpolicy huband the tech talent project it’s a10-week skills building initiative toprepareexperienced technology leaders to engageeffectively with public sectorchallengesthe program provides senior technologyprofessionals with a unique leadershipopportunity to build skills throughreal-world engagement with governmentandpolicy the hub and tech talent projectcame together this spring to run thesecond cohort of this initiativeevery week from january to mid april wemet with our cohort of tele leaders toprepare themfor experiencing government and policyworkthis afternoon we’ll be introducing thelast group of our leaders theirculminating project asked them to takeall the lessons learned from their sixweeksand devise a solution to a real techpolicy problem that governments arefacingover the last couple of weeks wepresented our first two sets of projectsfocused on improving technology projectapproval processes at the state ofcaliforniaand on considering the merits of coca-19vaccine credentialsthis week we’ll be presenting our lastset of projects on a problem that manycity governments are grappling withhow to make covet 19 relief easier forsmall businesses to access and moreequitablesmall businesses have sufferedtremendously during the covet 19 crisiswhile cities have tried to providerelief opportunities to help smallbusinesses stay afloatthese efforts are often uncoordinatedamong city departmentsand usually require businesses to submitseparate length applicationsto multiple agencies small businessesare also not always aware of the reliefopportunities available to themresulting in socioeconomic and racialdisparities in house business owners aretaking up reliefopportunities our leaders were taskedwith the following questionhow can cities better make covet 19relief efforts available to smallbusinessesfor this project they were asked to giverecommendations to the cityfictional city of foggington the leaderswere split into three teams for thisproject and as such we’ll have threeteams presenting their own uniquesolutionsto be clear these teams only had a fewweeks to both understand the problemand propose a solution to this verytricky and complicated issue that waschanging in real timeas you’ll see they came up with someoutstanding work in this limited timewhich just goes to showthe power that this type of creativethinking can have to improve policy andgovernment servicessome brief logistical announcementsafter all the presentations we willintroduce our fabulous keynote speakertara lynn gray from the director of theoffice of small business advocate forthe state of californiaplease check out the links in the chatbox so that you can follow along in realtime withthe products as we release them and lastwe’ll save a few minutes for q a at theendso please submit your questions in the qa box below and we’ll have the teammembers either answer the questions liveor via the box so with that i’m thrilledto introduce the five tele leaders onthe first team for this afternoonthis first team includes trish gray anengineering leader who is currently headof capacity engineering and cloudarchitecture at pinterestlaudrina chern a digital forensicexaminer andprincipal security advocate at cyberreason harry max a product design leaderwho is a former board director at trustassurance networkandrea flores an experienced health techand operations leaderwho is currently an i.t businessrelationship director for the la carehealth planand benjamin hirsch a staff interactiondesigner at google’s workplace studiofor this presentation we’ll have trishgray presenting over to you trishthank you betsy and thank you all forbeing here todayuh this is a very complex very largeproblem to solveand very crucial that we solve it in atimely manner somy teammates and i would like toinvite you to think about this problemin justa slightly different wayif we can find data onsmall businesses in the city offoggington available data whether thatbe public datadata within city agencies or you knowdatabasesuh within the government about theirneedsand who they are then can we prioritizeapproaches that are streamlined andinclusiveto help them not just navigate thecoca-19 relief process butalso other needs that they may have evenbeyond the pandemicwe think they canand excuse mewe think they can and uh in order to dosowe believe that if we can get the rightcoordination from agenciesconsolidate the publicly available smallbusiness data that we haveand match that up with consolidated formdata modelsthen we can do three things here we canpersonalize an outreach campaign tothose small businesseswe can actually match those smallbusinesses tothe eligible relief that’s out therethat they’re already eligible forand then we can create a universalapplication process that is much moresimplifiedand easier for those small businesses tonavigateso in order to help guide you throughthis recommendation that we havei’m going to go through a few of theartifacts that we have in the playbookthat we are providingthat will take you through possiblesolutions to implementthis uh this solution in differentphasesokay and beyond that and even moreimportant than thatuh ways to advocate to your cityagenciesto gain cooperation from them in supportof this processand really the the results that we’retrying to achievehere uh are really huge uh right nowif you’re a small business then chancesareyou’re even to have a tough timefiguring out what it is that you needand then finding the information todetermine what you need can be a longarduous process and you don’t have timefor that you’re running your businessand you’re trying to get it back on itsfeet during covidand then provided that you can evenfigure out what you need identifying theright agencies for that and then findingall the forms that you have to fill outis yet another arduous process and thenthose forms themselves can be very longlengthy painful there can be a lot ofyou knowsupporting documents that are needed andthenthe feedback loop to even figure outwhat you did wrong or what you need tochange in order to get thatcould be just circumvented by not evenbeing eligible forthat relief in the first place and itcould be very frustratingso what we’re trying to do is get rid ofa lot of that processand try to come to a future state wherewe’re reaching out to themwe’re telling them exactly what theyneed to do asking them what their needsarematching them up to those agencies theycan then follow up with next stepsand actually complete applications thatthey’re already eligible forso here’s an example of what we feel isthe most important first stepwhich is getting cooperation fromdifferent agencies and what we’re tryingto achieve hereis agreement on two things one is willthose agencies be willingto share data with other agencies sothat they can consolidate things liketheirform their eligibility requirements andapplication requirementsso that we can create kind of a patternkind of a heuristic modelin that pool of data that we have andthen the second thing isto agree to a set of processesthat will be timely in terms of feedbackreaching out toeligible participants eligiblebusinesses and giving them that feedbackand guiding them through the processand once we’re able to do that here anexample here is an example of how we canutilize that shared dataso say we have a few agencies that agreeto share their data with each other andwe find that they have similar patternsin what they’re looking for foreligibilityand so we can kind of consolidate thosepatterns into a bit of a heuristic modela very simple pattern matching systemand then when a small business comesthroughsay the foggy street cafe we find thatwe already haveseveral pieces of information from themwe know their number of employees wemight know their business type theiraddressand so on and so forth and so we cansend out outreach letters toall kinds of businesses like the fog thefoggy street cafeand send them a message a web addressand a registration code that they cancome back to what we call a cupcake formwhich is just a really really simpleform asking themfor their needs and then take thatform those form answers and the datathat we already haveand based off of that do some patternmatching to match them to say okay thisis a hospitality businessmaybe they will be eligible for one ofthese three agencies relief programsand then based off of that it goes intothe agency’s inboxand then the agency can say wow thisreally is eligible for one of ourprograms i’m going to reach out to themokay and then that’s when the processstarts in a very lightweight fashionhere’s an example of an outreach letterthat we might send to a small businessnow notice the simplicity of thisit says we have relief for youcome find out if you’re eligible here’sa web address here’s a registration codeand the second page is literally thesame messagein several different languages and thisis the inclusivity piece of thisso that these businesses who may have alanguage barrierwon’t have to go and ask others to helpthem translate and to understand whatthis letter means to them they can seeright away and go to the formand then we have the form itself whichas you can see would be assimple and as user-friendly as we canpossibly haveto make sure that we’re understandingthat business needand understanding that they you knowmaking them understand the process thatthey would go throughon the back end we’re just pulling inthe bare minimum of data that we need tosupplement the heuristic model thatwe’ve already createdthrough those uh form inventories thatwe did with the participating agenciesand then as you can see here theimplementation process flow would be assimple for the business as possible asstreamlined for the city departments aspossibleand then the systems behind it would beas lightweight as possible because wehave to get something in the handsof these businesses as soon as possibleexcuse me there is a lagokay finally the importance of a stagedand phasedroll out of these solutions is soimportantuh because of the timeliness of thesolution that businesses need so quicklyso in phase one we really don’t want tomake it so complicated we want tokeep the request routing as man you knowmanual umautomate just the bare minimum of sb uhsmb outreach soum sending out the outreach letters tothe small businessesand then gathering the information fromwhat we receive in terms of engagementfrom those businessesand how they’re working within thosewith those agencies and then based offof that learnings that we go on to thenext phase we fix the problems that weseeand then we create new uh features thatcan help streamline even furtherand then by phase three we’ve actuallygotten to the point where we havestreamlined it to theuh to a very automated stage and can beusedthrough coveted relief and then beyondfor even further servicesand our hope is that small businesseswill have a greater relationship withtheir city agenciesand be healthier in the city ofbogdington so with thatthank you and i’ll hand it back to betsythank you so much trish reallyappreciate uhall of your team’s work advocating for acentralized data enabled formi want to remind you that if you haveany questions for trisha and or otherleaders please put them in the q a boxat the bottom of the screenof the screen we’ll get to questionstowards the end of this webinaralso if you’ll look at the chat you’llsee a link to the playbook that trishwas talking about and all the otherproducts produced by this teamnext i’m thrilled to introduce the fivetele leaders on the second team for thiseveningthis second team includes matt perkins aclean tech industry veteran who is chiefexecutive officerat alaska renewables dan miller a techexecutive dedicated to more equitablehealthoutcomes who is the founder and ceo ofspora healthguna jayasila pandyan an accomplishedtech executive who is currently leadengineer at booz allen hamiltonmaggie klansnick an it leader mostrecentlythe director of enterprise resourceplanning and data managementat nreca an electric cooperative tradeassociationand sridevi joshi a tech and cybersecurity leaderwho is co-founder and cto at foresightresilient strategies and informationsecurity companyfor this presentation we’ll have goonapresenting over to you gunathank you very much betsy and welcome uhto you all and thank you for attendinguh this session um umand time to uh to spare your evening todo thisum let me share my screen for the uhpresentation hereall right so um before we before i startyou know this problem was handed over tous uhyou know in a very broad fashion sensethat hey how do we help thesesmall business owners of foggington uhdo their you know uh apply for theirkobe 19 effortsuh in a more um in a better fashion andand that’s yeah and also be equitablerightum in researching further into this intotheuh a problem itself we when and askingthe question why right why does thishappenuh we found that a lot of theproblems where due to you know thecomplex ui the number of multipleum uh multiple portals and so on so wewe we redefine the problem statementinto more of an experience basedquestion right how do you how do you getthe small business owners and give thema more effective and efficientexperience right so effective in thesense it has to goyou know reach those folks that thatneed their need therelief and efficient in the sense thatif theyare eligible for the relief they theyget the relief really quickly rightum and and overall the experience shouldbe good for the business ownersand also it shouldn’t be a very verycomplex processto actually approve theso having said that right we have two uhtwo areas right one is the businessowners and one of the back end processthat actually helps the business ownerget the permanent reliefright so to bridge this uh our solutionuh you know looks at it from acomprehensive angle right not just fromuh the kobe 19 relief process but whatif there is anotheruh god forbid but still we have to beprepared for anotheruh you know calamity or or uh orcatastrophe right we need to havethe relief efforts really quickly fromwhat we have learned from this uhparticularkobe 19 problem right so so thinkingabout thatour uh you know we researchedthe currentknow you can see this process it’s verycumbersomeit’s it’s a lot the the code 19 reliefpage itself that was given to ushad about like you know a lot of recordslike you know at least 30 or 40 entriesaboutrelief that was you know either pendinguh heading oror it’s not available anymore and if youclick each of those links it takes youto other portals whereuh there’s you know other informationthat that the business owner has toread through and understand and then youknow maybe if they’re eligible then theygo ahead and apply and then each ofthose application processes also requirethem to get someapprovals and other documentation thatthey have to submit and they have towait for this and this is a back andforthprocess that happens on the back end uhand i mean back-endi mean the the approval side right onthe government agency sidethe verification of the data that thethe documentationall that stuff happens and it happens inindividual agencies right so theythey have their own data they have theirown systems they have their ownprocesses to doto do the verification so what happenshere is you have siloed processes dataand systemsand you need manual verification acrossagencies you know sendinga file or physically you know faxing andall that stuff that happens in the backend to actually get the reliefit’s a very very archaic and veryinefficient processto put it right so we wanted to see howwe canyou know disrupt this uh ecosystem atthis point right andhelp build something that is very veryuhyou know resilient and robust for thefuturethat’s our uh that’s keeping in mindthat we have to provide an efficient andyou know experience to the to the enduser right um in doing sowe propose a solutionof a centralized city relationshipmanagement system and what this reallymeansis this one centralized system wherelike i said the business owners interactthe backenduh agencies uh the approvals approversand other government agencies caninteract with this systemand you have a uniform experience andyou have a lot of uh synergy in terms ofhow you will do thisum and it provides a more efficient uhinterface foruh for the business owner and there’s alot of automation that could be doneusing this system so think of it likethis right a business owner comes inand they uh they enter their basicinformation into the systemum you know what what the business isand all that maybe thereyeah and other other details the systemthe the crm system takes thatinformation and based onthe data that’s available from the otheragencies automaticallyit it provides eligibility criteria itcalculates all that and thenuh you know gives it back to the to theto the business ownerand for any future uh relief effortsthis could be automated thatyou know automatically you can send thatsend that information over email or youknow even through snail mailright to to the individual businessowner right umand this can be you know more oil it canbeso there’s a multiple channels that youcan access this proposed solutionall right so the future state like isaid that centralized cityuh you know relationship managementsystem sits in this and sits at the coreofof all that all the other processesright so wewe have the business small businessowners that that enter the vitalinformation that theythat they have and then um you know youhave the other agencies also interactingwith the systemuh and then you have the um the leadgovernment agency personal reviewand and follow up for additional datanow there is one aspect of this thati have to really uh stress right whenyou have a centralized system like thisit’s a multi-tenant system and what dowe mean by a multi-tenant systemthis means that you have multipleagencies that can come into the systemright they can add their own modulestheir own workflowtheir own processes but it stays withinthewithin the environment of the cityrelationship management manager systemwhich means that you have uniformity ofair off of a uiyou have uh you know you can share dataacross agencies so the core data thatcan be can be in a common place uh sothis is basically master data right sojust which is basicallythe the the small business ownerinformation that’s been storedand you can also put in code 19 anotherrelief efforts informationthere as eligibility criteria that willbe automatedfor for for their elite efforts sothat’s that’s our future visionfor for uh for the relief effortsall right so next how do we do thisright how do we do this today we are ina you know we are in a situation wherewe have cluttered unfriendly ui we havedata submission that’sthat’s very burdensome there’s also likeyou know manual processes and whatnotrightum there’s no there’s no real formalworkflow and things like that so fromhere you have to go into the uniform uiand you know you have to you have to beyou have to integrate agency data andall that so it isit is it is there is a bridge to crosshere and and as you can see wewe see this as uh as things uh as thingsthat will bear fruit prettyuh pretty quickly as well as for thelong run right um we wanted to make itmore agile like we wouldsee incremental uh you knowprogress in the in the in the roadmapand we want to first you knowconcentrate on processor engineeringthe crm selection the and then the otheryou know the staffing that you need andthe change management which iswhich is required to do these projectsas the first foundational phaseand then we want to transition on fordifferent agencies and different reliefefforts by first implementing an mvpthat would help understand what problemsthere are and help course correct or orrefactorthe changes that require for the for thesystem processes andif required staff as well and thenslowly we start you know training thethe staff for this with this new systemand and have theother um you know advocacy for the forthe business owners to come in andparticipateand uh you know and this process goes onwheremultiple agencies can come on board andand be part of this ecosystemso that’s our proposed roadmap there isa much detailed roadmap that we haveas well um that i’m not going to shareit right now but um butas you can see in this screen we have uhyou know we have these solutionartifacts the current state in thefuture state and then we have theproposed road map on the right you cansee thatuh and then we also want to uh you knowwant togive this as a memo to the uh to thedigital services team toto actually implement it so we have anoperational plan that thatbrings in the people process technologythe different steps that are requiredfrom a dataapplication process data governanceperspectiveall that stuff so that the parkingdigital services team cantake it and then you know change thatinto projectmanagement tasks and and and quicklyimplement itso um you know i in conclusion i wouldsay that this is an overallsolution it’s very long-term solution itdoesn’t shortchange anythinguh just for the sake of uh currentefforts umso thank you so much for uh forlistening to mepatiently here and i will uh revertback to betsythank you thank you so much goona reallyappreciate all your thoughtfulcommentary on the idea of creating acity relationship manager i especiallyappreciate how you’ve taken a productpopular in the private sectorand showing how it could be effectivelyused in the public sectorwe also apologize for a bit of technicaldifficulties with gunas feedi wouldn’t be a tech presentationwithout a bit of a zoom issueso next i’m excited to introduce ourthird and last team for the afternoonthis last team includes anupam dadamanuh sorry dada majumdar a medicaltechnology executive who is head ofglobal research and developmentat bayer medical a provider ofrespiratory care solutionssonia pryor jones an educator andnon-profit executive who is currentlychief implementation officer of the fabfoundationand sue hendrickson an experienced techand business lawyerwho is co-head of arnold and porter’stech and life sciences transactionspracticefor this presentation we’ll have anupamand sonia presenting over to you boththank you betsyall right uh folks can you see thepresentationwe can great thank you hey uh goodevening to theaudience uh on behalf of uh susan soniaanduh i uh we want to wish everyone a goodevening and thanks for taking the timetojoin us we are super excited to be hereto talk to you about our thoughts arounda small businessdigital conciergegiven the challenges that the smallbusinesses have faced in obtainingcovered relief fundsour team decided to focus onimprovementsto the experience for very smallbusinessesin interacting with city government toavail themselves of covert reliefand future disaster relief initiativesnow our solution is for the city todeploya digital small business conciergea virtual chatbot that is tailored toassisting smallbusinesses with accessing city servicesduring covet many state and localgovernmentshave increasingly begun to recognize thebenefits of chatbots forrapidly communicating with andcapturing information from largedistributed audiencesand we believe a chatbot could helporganizeand improve the city’s interactions withsmall business ownerson relief programs nowresearch found that small businessownersspend upwards of 24 percent of theirtimeon administrative tasks which wereespecially challenging during the covet19 shutdownsmany cities have extensive documentationon their websiteshowever the user often needs to navigatemultiple linksmany of which lead to cross-site jumpsas you can seeoften forms need to be downloadedprinted signedand then mailed without confirmation ofreceiptand follow through how can we improvethe experienceof the very small business owners toengage with city hallto access code relief and beyond that’sthe problem that was ahead of usnow chatbots are being extensively usedin the public sector to provide improvedaccessto city county and state governmentdocumentsand have been shown to be effective inimproving citizen satisfaction and heavyquery answer scenarios that are quitetypical in governmental interactionswith small business owners now couplingchatbots withrobotic process automation or rpa fordata extractionand with mobile and social mediaintegrationhelps cities meet the needs of residentsand small business owners with lowfrictionour goal today is to demonstrate or fillone’s use alwaysschema to reduce frictions in using thechatbotit’s important to meet people where theyare providing familiarityand easy launch of the new tool now wehave developedfour such demos uh we are going to nextshow you a mobile versionwe’ll then uh we’ve also builta facebook integrated version of a chatbotand a web app that can be launched fromthe city’s business portalwe are not demoing these two uh demostoday you can see them on the websiteand we’ll finally finish with anexciting ai powered chat botthat gets better with use so we will nowdemonstratea mobile digital small businessconcierge appthat can be used to fill and submitdisaster relief applicationthe app provides multilingual supportto ensure wide access tounderrepresented minoritiesthe app is built for guided workflow asdesigned by the developers of the cityhalloffice of small businessfollowing their responses the user canuse a smartphoneto capture information from documentssuch as business licenserobotic process automation or rpacan then be used to extract the neededinformationand authenticate the user’s informationin the city databases the usercan then fill in the needed informationsuch as the damage descriptionand the claim amount the necessary formscan then get pre-populatedautomatically and upon submission theusergets confirmation of submission rightawayso with that let me hand it over tosoniathank you anapan so as you can seethe chat bot offers an idealtool to support rapid changesthat require very nimble responseson may 3rd the government put outa new program the restaurantrevitalizationfund that really required the same kindof rapid turnaroundas the payroll protection program thatwas released earlierthis particular program really requiredfor businesses toact very quickly and the benefits of theaiuh focus chatbot allowed forcould allow for city to put up theinformation needed for businesses tomove very quicklya chat bot with ai back-end getsbetter use and is ideal for the rapiddeployment necessary for businessesto secure cova recovery quicklythis demonstration in front of you showsyou how quickly a chatbot can be usedand can’t support people through theapplication processit’s posing right now the kinds ofquestions that sba would pose to apotential business owner as they weregoing through the processand the chat bot itself really begins tolearn the processquickly over time as different usersbegin to useitit also takes users to website outsideof itto support it with any additionalinformation that may be neededthe chat bot is also available inmultiple languages to support thethousands of small business owners whodo not speakenglish and the ai backend really allowsfor that natural language to support theinteraction with the bot and the userif the bot can’t figure out an answer toa questionit will escalate the questions so thatthe bot itself can continue to learn theinformation to supportfuture visitors and usersnow the graphical back-end for thechatbot can also help to facilitaterapid developmentand it provides you with additionalthings on the back end like standardquestionsgrouping questions and it also builds acatalogthat supports multiple languages for allkinds ofusers the user flowcan be designed without depending ondecision trees and dialogflows but instead designed graphicallyand one of the most useful benefits ofthe chat botare the analytics right at yourfingertips you can have information likechat by duration timeresponse time the types of messagesuh that people are using back and forthin the botas well as location and all of thisinformationis available through a dashboardconstantly offering youinsight on use and needas you can see from our demonstrationthis eveningthe chatbot really offers a wide range atotal laundry list if you will ofbenefits to both the cityand the small business users everythingfrom efficiencyand user-friendly ways of conveying verycomplex and largepieces of information easier navigationacross several websites that typicallyare hard for small businesses to takethe time to findand after months of being closed or atminimum capacitythe ability to shift a small businessowner’s timefrom working on administrative tasks toreally focusing on their core businessso they can build back better if youwillis extremely valuable what we’ve alsofoundis that the multiple languagecapabilities are also really importantwith the chatbotand they really also support the abilityfor it to be deployedon mobile platforms as well as use andintegration across social mediathose kinds of things really do allowyou to reach the hard to reachpopulations and underserved populationsthat anapal mentioned earlierin addition to all of these key benefitsthe chat pot the chat box technologydeployment aloneis not going to do all the work you needa very thoughtful advocacy planand one of my favorite quotes that ihear people in community developmentuh mention all the time is that peoplesupport what they co-createso advocacy and outreach early on istruly essentialand in the advocacy and outreach planthinking about things liketesting your case and those statedobjectives with all the key stakeholdersbuilding overall awareness and makingsure that you formally build in aprocess for continuous improvementif you take a look at our policy memoyou will also see the kinds ofpublic sector uh use cases already ineffectwhere chat bots are really supportingcity services across the countrywe want to take this moment to pause andacknowledge all of those who have helpedus with this projectwe want to say a special thank you tothe teams at wind wireand gamelon and we also want to thankuh miss rebecca ottinger and dr philmarshall for their supportand we appreciate having thisopportunity to share our solution withyou this eveningnow we like to turn it back over tobetsythank you so much team a reallyexcellent presentation and i reallyappreciateuh how much detail you’ve gone intoabout howcreatively you could deploy chat bots tohelp small businesses navigate throughtheir applicationsso next i’m thrilled to announce thekeynote speaker for our eventtara lynn gray tara is currentlydirector of the office of small businessadvocate at the state of californiaa politically appointed position whereshe serves as the voice of smallbusinesses for the stateprior to this appointment she was theceo of the fresno metro black chamber ofcommerceand has more generally spent her careersupporting small businessesentrepreneurs and startups in californiatara thank you so much for being herewith us and sharing your thoughts onthese projectsand we’re generally talking about theimportance of bringing tech viewpointsinto solving issues like the ones we’veheard todayover to you tara thank you somuch betsy um good afternooneveryone my name is carolyn gray i amthe directorof the california office of the smallbusinessadvocate um the office isled by the advocate alsothe director myself and operates withinthe governor’soffice of business and economicdevelopmentper government statute cal osbaas we call it serves as the principaladvocate in the state of californiaon behalf of small businessesrepresenting their views and interestsdisseminating information to them andadvising them on state programs andregulationsour mission is to support economicgrowth and innovation in california byworking to ensurethat california’s small businesses andentrepreneurs have the resources theyneed to start upconnect to capital connect to marketsand growtheir businesses uh we are focused oncreatingan inclusive entrepreneurial and smallbusiness ecosystemto eliminate opportunity gaps acrosszip codes race and genderwe have three primary objectiveson aligned to achieve our mission andthe first is providingresources as i mentioned providingaccessum to information training consultingtools for small businesses entrepreneursum to to start up connect to capitaland um to get whatever technicalassistance that they needto grow second areaum and strategic objective for usis really serving as the voice of smallbusiness andentrepreneurship across the stateconvening experts toaddress barriers um which sometimesshow up in policy barriers toaccessing resources barriers toaccessingnetworks barriers to partnering withprivate sectorfor solutions um some like the solutionswe’ve seentoday um our third objectiveis really advancing on californiaresilienceon and expanding business resilience andsupportingdisaster and economic recoveryas betsy said prior to my appointment bythe governori was the chief executive officer of thefresno metro black chamber of commerceand chamber foundationwhere i built a small strugglingnon-profitum into a community-based enterprisewith a budget just over 10 milliondollars and i dug into policy in ordertomake that happen and access to resourcesthat were madeavailable by very good policy in thestate of californiaand uh worked to umrealize my vision which was really afree market withouteconomic social or political barriers tothe financial success of bypocentrepreneurs and most especially thosefrom rural and disinvested communitiesso as a small uh business advocate inthat roleum i was keenly focused on policy andhow it affects the the ability oflocal entrepreneurs to achieve theirobjectivesi’ll finish my background statement withthis and i’ve been a small businessownerfor many years i’ve been a counselor fortwo small business development centersi’ve run a youth entrepreneurshipprogram for nine yearsuh a small business a feasibilityprogramum in a very hard hit um central valleycityand in my 25 years of experienceum in the small business ecosystemi think i’ve seen small businessdevelopment from just about everyviewpoint imaginableand including technology because thatwas the focus of my small businessso i applaud um these projectsand i whollyum support the vision onof aspen institute committed torealizing a free just and equitablesocietydriving change through dialogueleadership in actionuh to help solve the most importantchallenges facing the united states andthe worldum i can certainly relate to thesolutions put forth todayin support of that mission and strategyand i just want to reflect that i knowthat policyplays a huge role in governing the workof my officeand the small businesses that we supportpolicy can help and policy canhurt and it’s imperativefor those of us that are striving forgoodgovernance consider technologyas a way to improve data collection dataaggregationprocess automation and most importantlycustomer engagement no matter who thatcustomer isum if it’s legislatures maybe there canum their constituencyif it’s an agency it’s going to be ourstate holdersum so i just uh really want to reflectand saythese projects were incredibleum all of the participants did agreat job great ideas greatprojects i’m impressed by the depth ofanalysisand comprehensive solutions that wereoffereduh we we know the importanceof the solutions as we all witnessedthis past yearexactly how critical city and countyservices were to deliveringaid and relief to small businessesduring the height of the pandemicyou know i i always say that data iskingand queen and it’s up to usum you know what we do with itand i think solutions like these can goa long wayto creating the kind of streamlinedaccess to servicesuh that your team has demonstrated todayand i think um we also learned from thepandemicthat time is critical that a few dayscan make a big difference uh to smallbusinesses as they facea disaster and look for help anduh simple singleunified systems that make accessstraightforward also saves timeand lives as we sawand i just want to give a shout out umto the digital small business conciergeteami have to admit that thatum project to me really gets at theheartof a primary frustrationthat small businesses have wheninterfacing with government agencieswhether they are local or whether theyarestate and that frustration is how to getthe answersthey need when they need them not onsomeone else’s timeclock but on their own and i really feltthat thatchat bot is a great way to address thathurdleand increase um satisfaction forstakeholdersand enhance service uh deliveryand you know over time implementing thistype of technologyit leads to cost savings which we arealways looking to doum at government agencies adds long-termvalue and typifies the kind of solutionsthat we’re looking for in governmentso i will also say that theconsideration for in-language supportis critical and greatly appreciatedconsidering the diversityof people and hard-to-reach populationsespecially in rural areas that we havein californiaand um during the pandemic my officeconcentratedon promoting digital servicesand and really pulling manyof our small businesses back intothe economy and helping them to recoverwith our get digital california campaignum and so i just you know again i’vesaid itum a couple of times i really think thattechnology is key the last thing i willsay is that the state budgetis a place where quite a bit of policystartsand in california our governor has putforthon significant budget actionsand items to help all californiansachieve the california dreamand with the largestsmall business relief grant program inthe nation at 2.5 billion dollarsum california is paving the way for oureconomy to come roaring back strongerthanpre-pandemic levels and we’ve asked foranother 1.5 billion to help californiansrecoverum the governor has followed that upwith a 6.2 billion dollar tax cutprogram for small businessesalso the largest in the nation and wearepreparing to um support thestate small business credit initiativeto the tune of 895 million dollars whichworks to strengthen state programsthat support financing to smallbusinesses soall told you know the governor isignitinguh the economy and making a wayfor our smallest and our mostvulnerable entrepreneurs to grow andthrive in the marketplaceand to me that’s goodpolicy through budget andwe’re looking to seeing a great yearahead i want to congratulate all threeteams you guys were phenomenal you hadgreat solutions and congratulationsto each of you i think it’s back to younow betsythank you so so much tara we are sograteful to you for being hereuh and really liked your uh reflectionson so many of thedetails of the projects and it’s greatto hear from someone who knows smallbusiness as well that these thingswill actually be helpful um so we’regoing to bring up the entire crew hereand start digging into a few questionsum from the audience so please rememberyou can put yourquestions for the team into the chat orsorry into the q a boxand we will either answer them live oranswer typed up questions umtara i’ll start with you um sincejoining the office of the small businessadvocate what have you found to be thebusiness ownersbiggest concerns right now um what’s topof mind for small business ownerswell frankly top of mind is gettingrecovery underway um significantlygetting usopen on getting our economyback moving the way that it waspre-pandemicand that’s a struggle for many um whenyou considerthat uh 50 of all small businesses arehome baseduh there are a lot of dependenciesthat um can affect successuh rent moratoriumsyou know housing shortages i mean thereare a lot ofancillary things that affect umthe mindset of our small business ownersum the stresses and the strains on themuh and and so we’re just really lookingin my officeto provide the resourcesto smooth that transition back to anopen economyand our businesses to get back tothrivingthat makes perfect sense thank you somuch next i’d like to ask uh trishuh we had a question um do you envisionthisuniversal form idea hurting smallbusinesses applying for relieffor instance could agencies see thatsome small businesses have alreadygotten supportby using some form of universal formi’m sorry could you could you repeat thequestionsure um the question is do you envisionthat this could actually hurt smallbusinesses to have a universal form forinstanceone agency might decide not to givemoney because another agency has alreadysupported the same business for instanceoh um that’s definitely a considerationandthat would be a cause for concern interms of agency coordinationthe idea is to have engagementfor these small businesses across theboard and there shouldn’t bereally any competing for that so thefirst order of businessreally is bringing together thoseagencies umto coordinate and to have theseagreements codifiedum and um and kind ofand you know enforced through you knowcity city hallmaking sure that we are doing everythingforthe benefit of the small business andnot for the benefit of any one agencygreat and next question is for thesecond teamcan cities just use crms like salesforceor should cities go out and develop anew platformto support these sorts of thingsi can take that um so our recommendationis to go with a commercial off-the-shelfproductjust cots you may have heard about it umlike salesforce and others becauseone um operationally it’s much moreeasier to implement something like thatum it’s also uh you know you don’t haveto double up and keepupdating the software nowadays it’s allum service based souh all the updates and the latesttechnologies would beenabled without having to you knowreinvent the wheelso our recommendations to go with uhwith something like something that’salready availableand there’s there’s a few softwarethat’s available for that especially forthe government uhagencies great thank you um for teamthree the chat botare there any privacy concerns that youfound around using a chat bot forinstancewould chat transcripts be saveduh i can take that question uh betsy cani just first saythat your presentation gave me thegoosebumps so thank you andas a california resident i’m excited tohave you as our small business leaderuh look privacy is certainly a concernright uh and as a consumer iworry about that uh you know when i’mtalking on abot chatbots can have their ownchallenges and i think this is really aproblem that needs to be studied betweenthe citythe small businesses need to know thatthese thingsmay be these transcripts may be savedwith their permissionso i think that’s something that thecities have to figure outuh there’s certainly useful guidance outthere uhespecially from the european commissionthey’ve tried this quite a bitwe’ve seen that the la uh small businessuhfolks have also tried it so there’scertainly interactions thereand i think it’s valuable to have thoseconversations between folks who havealreadytried and figured out what worksgreat thank you so much um back to tarauh do you thinkbusiness owners would be able tonavigate text solutions like a universalrelief application or a chat botum i think that there are quite a fewthat would be um thereare considerations umi think that this team uh took intoaccountthat makes it that much more accessibleand that is the in language supportwhich i think is absolutely criticalum for anyone providing a solutionor any type of self-service uhit is just um a significant advantagefor folks to be able to interface withthe systemin their native tongue uh soyes i think that there are many thatwould be able to accessnow the one hurdle that i think thatstill existsin some hard-to-reach populations andcommunitiesare areas where um goodfast reliable internet access is not yetubiquitousand as long as we have largepockets and large groups of peoplethat are in those areas any technologysolution is going to be difficult forthose folks to accessso with that as the caveat umi would say yes i think anybody who’sconnected to the internetfolks who have mobile devices you knowthose of usthat are engaging onin you know digital tools umyeah i i think there would be no issueat allaccessing the the chatbotin fact i could see i’m sorry just forcome back i could seemyself preferring the chat botfrankly because i could do it um youknowanytime i wanted to to interface i’m notyou know caught between an eight to fivetime frame to access a city or countyresourceor state resource for that matter youknow thatdesk becomes open 24 7 and that’s a gamechangerthat’s great now really appreciate thatso we’re getting close to the end oftime so i’m going to askeveryone who has presented here onefinal question which iswhat is your bumper sticker imagine thatyou have the opportunity to speak to theleadership at the city of foggytonwhat is the one thing that you wouldwant to tell them and soum i’ll start with trish what is yourbumper sticker oh goshuh i i would say uhyou know we’re a match made in foggy tinawesome aunty palm what about you youknow that’s a smallbusiness is rock sonia what about youtry it transparently oh i like itgoona what’s your bumper sticker i cutyou caught me off guard here um but iwould sayyou know hey i’m a data guy so i wouldsay universal datafor for all of uhyou know uh business owners we’ll workon your brevity for bumper stickers inthe futuretara what’s your what’s your bumpersticker mine isequity and opportunity createdcalifornia for alli love it well so as we close theevening i want to thank all of the teamsand speakers for their outstanding workon this project as i mentioned beforethe fact that they were able to producethese ideas during a part-time programin just a few weeks gives us a glimpseof what’s possible when you partnercivil service leaderswith modern technology experts toimprove public policybefore we close for the afternoon i alsowant to take a moment to thank everyonewho made this specific event possiblethis includes our wonderful tele staffmehamai cass along with anyone who mentoredand supported the teams as theyconducted research on this projecti’d also like to thank the keynotespeaker taraand of course the tele leadersthemselves for all the work they’ve donecongratulations you’re done uh thisculminates the last of our teledemonstration days for this secondcohortour aspen tech policy hub and techtalent project team will be welcoming anew cohort of tele leaders this summerand we’re eager and excited to announcethem soon to receiveupdates about the new cohort join ourmailing list at aspentechpolicyhub.orgin the meantime we’ll be so eager to seehow this cohort of tele leadersuses their learnings from this programto help impact policythank you so much again for joining usyou
Small businesses have suffered tremendously during the COVID-19 crisis. While cities have tried to provide relief opportunities to help small businesses stay afloat, these efforts are often uncoordinated amongst city departments and usually require businesses to submit separate lengthy applications to multiple agencies. Small businesses are also not always aware of the relief opportunities available to them, resulting in socioeconomic and racial disparities in how business owners are taking up relief opportunities. How can cities better make COVID-19 relief efforts available to small businesses?
On May 25, leaders from the Aspen Tech Policy Hub & Tech Talent Project’s Winter 2021 Tech Executive Leadership Initiative Cohort showcased their projects focused on ‘Helping Small Businesses Access COVID-19 Relief.’ Following the presentations, Tara Lynn Gray, Director of the State of California Office of the Small Business Advocate, gave a keynote address.
THE BEST OF ASPEN DIGITAL, RIGHT IN YOUR INBOX.
Sign up for our email list to stay current on our work.