helloand welcome everybody my name is vivianschiller i’m the executive director ofaspen digitala program of the aspen institute ourprogram’smission is to empower policy makerscivic organizationscompanies and the public to beresponsible stewards of tech and themediaand that is very much related to whatwe’re here to talk about today one ofour awesome programsis called the tech policy hub it’s a bayarea based policy incubatorthat aims to train a new generation oftech policy entrepreneursthrough fellowships and grant programsand i ampleased to be representing them todayearlier this year when the pandemic wasfirst ragingwe came up with the idea to create acoven 19challenge grant we saw that there was apotential for technologists tocontribute to mitigating some of thenegative effects of coven 19and in the end we funded six projectprojects in totalwith these challenge grants today’swebinaris to present the last two of those sixthe two we are sharing with you todayare designed to help journalistsresearchers and the public better accessresources and informationin the midst of this still ragingpandemic ascoven 19 crisis has turned many of ourtraditional communicationand information systems upside down tosay the leastso here’s what we’re going to do todayfirst uh eachuh each of the uh grant recipients theyhave one person representing each teamwill presenttheir projects for about 10 minutes andthen we will have a fantastic keynotespeakerand the civic technologist ryanpanjasaramformer u.s deputy chief technologyofficer to respond to the projectsand help us put all this in contextso just a few uh housekeeping notes atthe bottom of your screen you’ll see theqa function at any time during thisentire hour you can click on thatand you can enter a question that youwant to ask to either of ourpresenters or to ryan pleaselist your name and your affiliation andfeel comfortable if you feel comfortabledoing soit just helps provide important uhcontext and alsowe’re going to be dropping over thecourse of this hour uhlinks to the project so you can readmore about thembut hopefully not while this is goingyou’ll hang on to them and look at themafter so that we can allpay attention okay let’s get going firstupmichael morrissey is the founder ofmuckracka non-profit collaborative news sitethat brings together journalistsresearchers activists and regularcitizensto request analyze and share governmentdocumentsmaking politics more transparent anddemocracies more informedmichael’s project is a crowdsourcingplatform that lets journalistsresearchers and community organizersdefine uh data defined data quests thatdivide up largeinformation gathering and uh and uhchallengesso michael over to youthank you so much vivian it’s a realpleasure to be here and we’re sograteful for aspen tech’ssupport um so over the past yearnewsrooms around the country have had toquickly adapt to the changinginformation needs of our communitiesand that’s for monitoring local maskregulations to checking on whenand how schools are reopening in personthis also comes at a time of continuingshrinking resources to actually do thisworkto address this challenge at muckrockwe’ve taken what we’ve learned from ourprevious crowdsourcing experimentsto launch the covet 19 data collectorwhich makes it easy for newsroomsresearchers and community groupsto quickly organize volunteers to divideand conquer large data gatheringand analysis problems as a littlebackgroundi’m the co-founder of the muck rockfoundation which builds open sourcetools for transparency journalism andcivic engagementthat includes document cloud otranscribefoia machine and muckrock itselfcombined our portfolio reaches about 80million people each monthand we’re proud to work with many of thelargest and maybe even more importantlymany of the smallest newsrooms andnonprofit groups in the countryour tools are mostly focused on helpingto obtain analyze and sharevetted primary source materials with thepublicmuckrock is our open platform that helpsfile public records requestsalmost 90 000 to date and then we sharethose results with the worldalong with each step of the process it’shelped release over six million pages ofdocumentsbut being collaborative and communitydriven has been essential to our dnasince we started anyone can use themuckrock platform to submit requestsand share them and since the beginningwe’ve looked for ways to let peoplecontribute in novel wayswhether by helping us track down agencycontact informationor catching typos in our story insidecopythat’s not only helped us get more donewith a small team but also to build abroader more diverse transparencycommunityas we make it easier for other people tounderstand and feel invested in thepower of public recordsfor reporters document cloud has helpedanalyze the results of those requestsas well as other primary source materialusers uploadthis platform is focused primarily onnewsrooms but we’re experimenting withopening upto more non-profit research and academicorganizationsit currently helps host over 100 millionpages of edit documentsgiven our special place within the newsecosystem we have a keen understandingof the challenges facing reportersand others who are tackling momentouschallenges and keeping up with all theinformation availableand this project idea came out of ourdiscussions with newsroomsas well as our long history in findingcreative ways of broadening publicengagementwith trustworthy news virtually everynewsroom in the country and over 30thousand reportersuse at least one of our tools and ourgoal with this project was to bringtogether this network of 3000 newsroomstogether with a crowdsourcing platformdesigned to harness civic interestand contributing to quality data on thecovet 19 crisisand while we’re continuing to invest inbuilding and expanding it the covet 19data collector is already helping toscale efforts to collect and analyzethe information needed to inform policyoriginal reportingand community responses to the evolvinghealth and economic crisisfacing our countrythe platform starts by letting reportersuse a drag and drop interfaceshown here to define the questions theywant answered including setting upspecific fields to cover such items asdatedrop down selection free form textresponsesand many other itemsquestions are set up ad lib style withtemplate tags used to insert textthat will change on a task by task basisfor example you might upload a set ofstatements from different publicofficials and ask people to evaluatethose statements based on set criteriaor you can ask people to do someactivity off-site such as look fordocuments on different government webpagesand then paste in the url if they canfind itthe journalists can then pair this formwith one of muckrock’s existing datasetsincluding a database of everyjurisdiction in the country and over 16000 different government agencies tohave that question tasked out per entityfor example you can have volunteerssearch for a copy of every schooldistrict’s privacy policyeach state’s latest executive orders orthe most recent social media postsregarding protests from every policedepartment in the countryyou can also upload any otherspreadsheet file and use that as thebasis for task creation as wellcreating a very flexible system that’seasy to get up and running to organizethe groups of volunteers for a ridewide variety of tasksthe journalist then launches the projectand promotes a link that lets volunteerscontribute to each individual taskvolunteers can complete as few or asmany submissions as they likeand the person running the project canask that each piece of data be submittedmultiple times by different volunteersto ensure that the information isaccuratethat data once submitted is thenavailable in a browseable searchable webinterfacedownloadable as a spreadsheet oraccessible via an apiallowing other potential futureintegrationswe think that this approach will helpeven small newsrooms more easily tacklelargepreviously impossible stories thatrequire lots of manual methodicalcheckingbut beyond um but beyond the potentialfor tackling these new types of storieswe hope that this also spawns newapproaches to working togetherwith the communities that newsorganizations serveespecially during the last few monthswe’ve heard from many people that theyjust want to contribute meaningfully totheir communities in a non-monetary waybut often are not sure how so as wecontinue to build out the platform we’rereally invested in finding ways to makeit easy to follow up with volunteersand build strong feedback loops rangingfrom messaging users to thank them fromtheir contributionsright within the tool to building asense of shared community aroundcontributionsfor example recently we partnered withan academic program that had theirstudents volunteer for a dayand we split them into two groups whereeach could track their collectiveprogress towards a goalas well as compare their progressagainst that other group and it reallyhelped jumpstart contributions towardsthat specific data gathering taskgoing forward we’re really excited tocontinue building this outand refining the platform and giving ita future that goes beyond just cover 19related coverageto becoming an integral tool fornewsrooms and other organizationslooking to inform the publicwe’re particularly interested in findingways to help it report on and engageunderserved communitiessuch as including communities of colorand those living in news deserts that nolonger have primary source outletsfocused on them we’ve recently seenreporting that as trustworthy newssources disappear in communities aroundthe countryfake news operations as well as veiledpartisan sites are quickly filling thevoidleaving communities less informed andmore dividedour hope is that we can help fill thatgap and provide not only extra capacityto existing newsroomsbut genuine engagement that builds trustsupportand news literacy within thesecommunitieswe’re really excited to share that wejust got some new support to continuetesting these approaches in chicagowith a number of independent newsroomsthere and we’re hoping to bring our workto a community near you in the nearfuturewe’re going to continue building out notjust the software but our understandingof how this kind of crowdsourcingcan help and how it can so if you’reinterested inpartnering with us or have some ideas onthese approaches please do get in touchthe tool is under active development andcan be a little more temperamental thanwe’d like sometimesbut we think that the goal of a morecommunity-centered collaborativejournalistic practice is neededboth for the newsrooms that practice itbut most particularly the communitiesthat relyon trustworthy reliable information tokeep our democracy strongwe’re very grateful to aspen tech forthe opportunity to do thisand with that i’ll pass it back toviviangreat thank you so much michael um youknow you guys that uhmuckrock are really among the leaders incrowdsourcing and journalism and havebeenfor so long so it’s really thrilling forus tosee you take all of those tools thatyou’ve built and then create these newproducts specificallyto address the crisis that we’re in soum we’re going to have somequestions for you later in the hour umin the meantime speaking of questionsjust a reminder to everybodyif you have a question for any of ourpanelists click on the q a boxtype in your question please add yourname and your affiliation and one moreimportant thingplease say who your question is directedat because when we look at it later wewant to make sure we knowwhich project it’s aimed at okay thankyouuh so we are now going to go to uhswitching gears a little bit and we’regoing to go to our second challengegranteebrendan lind brendan is with humanagency a digital solutions and designcompany that works with non-profitsgovernment agencies and entrepreneursbrendan and his team at human agency aredeveloping an interactive messagingservicethat can be integrated into platformslike slack or smnsms messaging to allow users tohave coven 19 screening questionsanswered we’ve all experienced that indifferent parts of our life and so theidea of having it integratedis just fantastic and i can’t wait tosee your presentation soover to you uh now brendangreat thanks vivian and thanks everybodyforbeing here today all rightso i’m brendan lind with human agencyanduh gonna go through our projectwhat’s the problem that we’re trying toaddress so the cova 19pandemic is a once-in-a-lifetime crisisas we’re all awareand it’s affected millions of people andin addition to that generallyinequitablyone of the challenges that peopleencounter is just finding access to goodinformationwhere how do you figure out where to betested how do you understandwhat the different ways to know if youhave covet arejust accessing good information isincredibly difficult these daysinformation delugeand the the kind of consequence of thisis thatnot enough people are getting screenedwhether that’s through testing or justgenerally performing quick dailyassessments ofwhether they are in a good place to goabout their normal livesand this is you know incrediblyproblematic um and i think the key thinghere is thatwe need to figure out how we canincrease the rateof both just testing and generalassessment of how people are are arefeelingand so to be truly effectivecommunity-wide screening must be quickto adaptcheap to deploy and accessible to alland i think the the the most equitableway to do thatat a minimum is with information whichis our solutionand so what we’ve built is aninteractive web and tech spot that meetspeople where they areso that cover 19 screening is seamlessand so the basic idea of how this worksis it canyou can interact with it on a in a webapp you can interact with it viavia sms you can interact with it in awhole bunch of different placesif you want to demo it out you can textthis numberyou can you can see how see how it worksand it’s it’s a builder so this could beyou this can be useduh from anything from customizing tospecific use cases that someone hasfor how they want to do a covet screenertoreally any type of interactive uhexperienceand then the the idea is someone cantext in and people can also text out soif you’re a government and you want tosend out to everyone in in in thecommunity you can proactively send outthe bot andlots of us will get texts that will sayhere’s the information ifyou’re in new york city i get a text allthe time where it’ll they’ll sayhere’s the information today for you toknow but there isn’t a lot ofinteractive communication that’s comingfrom government to help peoplenavigate services other than justone-off pieces of informationso the idea here is that the governmentor or business or bodycan send out communication that thenpeople can interact with so that boththe senders getting information theyneed and orthe recipient is getting informationthey need or it can be inbound a personcan come to a websiteinteract with a form or they can text anumber so this isjust an example of of how this can workonhow this works on on a computer right sothis is a desktop viewof of the of the bot andand it’s the same technology that getsdeployedin different settings text sms orthe same thing web messenger you name itand so the idea is that this thisintegrates with kind of a whole bunch ofdifferentthat we all use so that oneyou can get it out to people easilyyou can reach people and then thatinformation can also go backinto your databases or wherever you needthat information to goso you can be as as kind of effectiveand and prepared as possible for servingthe communitynumber of different use cases for howthis ultimatelycan be used one is on the employer sideso you we ideally everyone haswe have daily testing and and and soforth but that just isn’t reality andit’s also cost prohibitiveand so while while people are encouragednot to go to workif they’re not feeling well the thesimplest thing to dois to that helps step up the likelihoodof of successful containmentis that employees actually need to gothrough a step-by-step process to reallyconfirm that they’re that they’refeelingall right on that given day so this is ause case we’ve been testing outwith a couple different organizationsthenext one is more community organizationcentricand so that this this bot in addition toexisting onyou know as a full form on a website orsms can also just bea a widget that you can embed on a siteand popup and so thenan organization can make accessing covetinformationvery accessible and uhand then and as you can see here you cankind of customize it so not only does itneed to be a covet screeneryou can also have information wheresomeone’s getting access to help orthey’re able to give help and volunteerand and it can really be you can buildit to really make sure that you’rehelping someone navigate the informationthat they needand that they’re providing you the sportyou’re looking forand i think another just cool thing onthis is justhow the idea here in is really tomake it easy for people to accessinformation and askind of we see people maybe in the pastthey would go around and they wouldinteract with people and you get so muchinformation throughinteracting with people and what we’rereally trying to do here is to say okaypeople are on their phone but maybe theydon’t go to a website maybethey’re just they just the best way todo is to text themmaybe someone goes to a website but theydon’t want to search how do you make itas easy as possible for people accessthe information they neednext use case local government i hit onthis a little bit earlierbut really really big thing for localgovernment is figuring out how do youeffectively use technology to helppeople access resourcesand in particularaccessing governmental resources is isat kind ofwith with less means is is difficult andyou know in the past you could go to agovernment agency or office and go inand itthere’s at least some access to supportit’s become harder to even go in personanywhereand so accessing government resources isreally challengingand so our hope here is to make iteasier for governmentwhere there’s you know actuallygovernment provides just such anincrediblenumber of support resources for ourcommunity but how do we make it easierfor people to actually access thoseresources so that’s thethat’s the idea of the partnership onthe government sideand the next steps of kind of wherewe’re at so we built out this technologywe’remaking improvements every every week youknow an exampleof just one of those is just even todaytoday if you text it’ll say respond witha b or cin two days when you text it’ll all benatural languageso we’re continuing to make improvementsrecruiting early adoptadapters in local governmentorganizations and employersum we are then and if you’reif you’re one of those reach out to uslet us knowand then as we move forward kind ofworking on building awarenesswith those different use cases we’vewe’ve secured a couple short codes soin addition creating kind of centralizedshort codes people can text withto get this information without needingto text long codesand then taking learnings from thisprocess with different partnersto improve the technology at largeand as i said we’re human agencyreally appreciate the opportunity towork with aspen and work on thisthis project and try to do meaningfulworkand we’ll love to hear from anybody andthank youback to you yeah thank you so muchbrendan i’vei’ve got a lot of questions for you i’msure um our participantsdo as well but um this is such a smartand needed ideathat it’s you know the way that peopleare collecting information is all overthe map and i’m sure for a lot oforganizations particularly small onesit’s hard for them to figure out how todo something like thisand if you can make it simple and turnkey that’s fantastic soboth of these projects as you can seeare are still in their initial stagesit’s going to be really exciting to seethe next iterations over the next coupleof months andbut i what i love about both of them ishow we’re usingtechnology simple technology uhor technology made simple to users ishould sayum to connect individuals to theresources they need whether it’sconsumers journalists who are ultimatelyinforming consumersso really really encourage everybody tocheck out their projects on the websitewe’ve linked to them in the chat andwe’re going to continue to follow theirteams and update all of you as they’rebeing developed umreminder that we are going to come toyour questions so please drop yourquestionsin the q a um list your question whichuh list your name and your affiliationand who your question isfor so um please get those ready dropthem in any time we’ll come to themlaterbut i am really excited now to introduceour keynotespeaker ryan panjadzaramis a civic technology leader currentlyan advisor to the chairman of theventure firmkleiner perkins ryan was formerly deputychieftechnology officer of the united stateswhere he helped federal governmentagencies deliver services in a moreeffectivedesign-centric and data-driven way soreally excited to have ryan share someof his thoughts on what’s been presenteduh this morning and to put that in thebroader context soryan over to you thank you vivian i ithink you said it best like these toolsuh that both michael from mike mackbrock and brendan from human agencyshowed off for things that canabsolutely help with this response tocovidi mean both of them are tools thataccelerate and scale what’s happening atthe local level right with muckrock theability to create theseassignments and ways to break up thesetasks like is a pretty neat tool to helpempower journalistsi think for this crisis journalists havebeen leading the way and uncovering datathat’s beenyou know pushed in corners hidden orneeded to be clarified and cleaned upand so i’m a big fan of that tooland then brendan with human agencysharing different ways foragencies and local governments to takeadvantage ofyou know data collection and structuredways right to tackle tasks thatthey want to tackle i think that’s kindof the big theme in this is how do webuild more toolsand technologies to assist the localresponse and how do wealmost get out of the way of the peoplethat are doing the really hard workand give them tools to just acceleratethat and so within about maybe10 or 12 minutes i wanted to take us ona little journey onthis topic of civic tech and morespecifically civic tech and opendata and how it fits in with thepandemic response let meshare my screen and the reason i want togo down this route isbecause open data as a whole has been atopic that i think many folks within ourcommunity have been championing forquite some timeand we almost take it for granted thatit’s you know the open dated executiveorder that came outuh during the obama administration trumpsigned the open data act soisn’t it the default and well thereality it isn’t especially for thiscrisis in particular andthe reason i think that it’s importantto spend a little time on this issueis because open data as a topic can bebucketed away as maybe sometimes thisproblem that’sbeen solved and in reality open data isthis thing we need to continually investinand you know looking at both of thetechnology tools that were shared it’slike just looking at the muck rock teamin their base technology for foiais this continual idea that there’s morein thereand more of it needs to be shared withthe public and then once it’s sharedwith the public how can it be structuredin waysthat it’s useful and then as well as thedata thatthe human agency team is collecting andcreatingwhile in the moment it solves aparticular need butwhat can that data help inform us withand on andi think the question that most of ushave been askingwhen it was back in january februarymarch is around covet iswell where is it right where is thisvirus where is itappearing and not just that i think thebig question that folks were trying tolean on open data to helpanswer is the question of am i saferight is my family safe can i go to workwhat are we supposed to doand the real question that i think we’veall are asking nowis well is the virus under controlis it under control in my state in mylocal community or as the country aswhole and these questions here are soimportant becausei think now that we’re in october thereality is we don’t enterback into our new normal or the way weused to liveuntil we do get this virus under controland with that we need to have accessto great data when it comes to cobit andthis whole pandemic response as a wholei think most folks are really familiarwith this image here this was one of thefirst dashboards that was put outearly on about where kovid was and isand it was a global map and i think thismap gets something on the order ofbillions of viewsuh a month and the energy and attentionherewas channeled by a few people i thinkthat’s going to be my consistent themeand trend here is thata group of very passionate people andplaceswith or the tools around them have beenable to really helpguide us in a country through thisresponse and this team here at johnhopkinshas not only continued on their originalcharge right shipping just this oneversion of a mapbut you can go to their website andactually get even more information atthe state level and testing and vaccinesand regions butthis was the first and so i’m kind oftaking us back in time when we go backto february march i think we all werevery familiar with thisum in the march time frame too i think abig question if we remember then waswellhow is testing going right we know thisvirus is around buthow are we doing on testing in theunited states i’m hearing from thenational level that we’ve had we’ve gotthousands and thousands of tests andmillions on the waybut um a journalist named alexismadrigaland robinson mayor were digging intothis and the reality was well there wasno place to find that information outand so what these twodid was they actually went to each statewebsiteto see what was being reported they evenwent to the you know national bodyof of uh public health laboratories andsaid wellwhere is this information going to beand is it the cdc going to report it andyou can see the time stamp for march 3rdyou know the cdc said no we’re not goingto share anything on this butyou know go to the state labs right goto the states they’re responsible forthisand so well that’s what they did umtogether with jeff hammerbacherand alexis madrigal then a group ofvolunteers they created a project calledthe covid tracking projectand it started with a google sheet andthis google spreadsheetum uh kept track of every stateand in the beginning it was justwashington and then massachusetts andthen a few moreyou can actually go back to the historyand just see when states were startingto reportthis on their websites this littleproject got a lotof attention very quickly right just acouple of days lateryou know this is jeff one of thefounders saying hey google sheets pleasehelpwhat do we do here and of course thegoogle team you know standing byin times like this we’re like well let’sfigure us out and how to help youand the neat thing is what you look attoday has been this project that’sevolved rightsince march april may june july augustseptember octoberinto a wonderful team of full-timeuh non-profit folks as well as a team offull-time volunteersaround the clock going to states pullingthis data out and structuring it inreally incredible waysand what you have here is thisincredible resourcethat gets you at the state levelreported that the state levelyou know websites you can click and seescreenshots of all the different piecesof informationbeing um pulled like where it’s comingfrom you can see maps and historyas well as as the crisis has evolvedthey’ve had to collectmore and more data right in thebeginning was just positive cases aswell asum a number of tests and now it’s willhospitalizations what kind of testand you know they also go even furtherand have an incredible apias well too and their engineering teamhave built one that’s really really goodand in a lot of ways should be the goldstandard in north star for howopen data is done hopefully from thefederal level but this is happening by agroup ofvolunteers and it’s quite incredible andwhen you go and lookat the project and its impact right agroup of volunteers a non-profityou know there’s over almost 600research papers wherethis information is being used not justthat there’s over you know almost 2million results on the internetabout the project itself but the reachthat it’s had inuh the news coverage as well as forpretty much every other part of theresponse has been invaluablethe sad part here is that the placewhere people aren’t going for thisinformationis the cdc and it becomes to raise thequestion of wellwhat is the role of a federal governmentright our national government on thesekinds of responsesyou know for whether we never questionwhere we get that data from right forwhether because it affects multiplestates at any given timeand like a virus that doesn’t respectborders or boundaries we expect ourfederal government to stepup and do these things and so when thekobe tracking project started their workin marchit took till may for this site to getlaunched right for the cdc themselves tostart sayingwell this is how many tests are beingdone and what you start to under unpackis well cool you’re telling me that it’sthe testing being done but the realquestion of the moment is well is thisundercontrol and umuh i wear two hats one of them is ofcoursemy day job which is at kleiner perkinsan investment fund but the other had iwas wearing at the time wasbeing one of the co-founders of the usdigital response umraylene young who is from the aspen techpolicy crew helped start that and she’sthe ceo of it andwhen we were working together one of thethe things that was pulling my interestwas wellyou know we’re recruiting incrediblevolunteers but i’m getting a sense thatthere’s no state level federal levelkind of monitoring it was part of thehealthcare.gov rescue teamand one of the things we noticed therewhen we first arrived at the scene waswellthere’s no monitoring to tell us ifthese websites are working or notand so the same analogy was happeninghere like do we have monitoring on howstates are actually doing on thisresponse and so what does anyone do whenthese things come up you create a googlespreadsheet and so uh together with asmall group of folks who created agoogle spreadsheet started trackingdifferent statesand what actions they were taking anddoing and very quickly we could start tosee well some states are doing greatothers are doing okayand this project you know like ineverything we’re doing and maybeyou know for the folks that muck rockand human agency sometimes theseoriginal versions of itdon’t get much attention and thisproject in its first iterationdidn’t get much attention at all rightbut one thing happened wasin may the white house put out itsopening up america again guidelineswhich includedproposed state and regional gatingcriteria but this is all they put outright they didn’t say well this is howstates were doing they didn’t say wellthese are the rangesand so we did that for them and that’swhere the project coveted exit strategyone that had started withthree other wonderful incredible groupsthe united states of care resolve tosave lives and duke’s margolis centerand a handful of engineering volunteersfrom the us digital responsewe built this and if you go there todaywhat it does is it tries to answer thosequestions right how is my state doing onkey measureshow is the disease spreading and wetrack you on different metrics andmeasures and by the way all this datacomessorry most of the data comes from thekova tracking projectand then we get them from a few othersources can our health system handle thespreadsome of this data comes from the cdc andhhshow’s my state doing on testing and whatthislet us paint was a picture of well howare things reallydoing and when we started this projectwe thought we’d only be doing it for acouple of months butit’s october and we’re still working onthis pretty hardand in july we got a peek at what washappeningin the federal side right the data thatthey had and they’re working oni’m the biggest fan of liz white fromthe center for public integrity becauseback in july she released the firstwhite house task force report and itlooks very much like thisand what’s neat about it is it shows theincredible workthat the task force as well as you knowgovernment civil servants are doingevery day to collect this informationand to make it usable and to sharewhat’s happening at the county levelwhere the hot spots are where from likeaactual county point of view where thingsneed to be addressedbut the unfortunate thing is this reportis kept privateand these reports have incrediblerecommendations fromepi folks as well as public health folksat the white house and the task forceitselfthat tell us what we need to be doing toget out of this crisis butlike i said it’s kept private and soback in julyi you know did what any of us would doin our community was to remind folksthatcovet data is a public good right andthe u.s government needs to be treatingit like one as well tooand a lot of my attention at the momentwas really focused onthe data sets that were coming in butthen at the same time that report cameout i was like wellit also released that too it’s a pdf youcould probably justmail it to everyone right um you knowand the reason why this report is soimportantis because like i said this is responseas both a federal responsibility stateresponsibilitylocal responsibility and community onewithout us allsharing our data publicly there’s no waywe’re going to be able to navigate thisresponsewell this is the kentucky uh dashboardfor covid and what’s fascinating aboutit is it does not share positivity rightanywhereyou know i have a screenshot from thisfrom a few months ago this is actuallyfrom just yesterday and they stilldon’t show this data on their maindashboard and you need that number tohelp guide if you want to reopen schoolsor anything and wellwhat do you know that data is in thatwhite house task force reportright it’s sitting there right therethat’s positivity levels within eachcounty not just that i think we all wereliving together the different cases wewould see in the news washington statehaving data reporting issuescalifornia as well too you know wheredata was still being reported and couldhave been used as a quality cross-checkthe federal government um you know ihope the muckrack team is proud of me ithinki wish i used their tool though i justactually went the old-fashioned way andsent an email touh the state department asking for allof these documents right these whitehouse task force reports because that’swheredr burks is from that’s where the agencythat’s housing it and so i did myfour-year researchand i got a response saying yes weunderstand what you’re asking for we’reworking on itand then i replied asking well can youshare the eta of whenand as you can see here they reply june16thof 2023 right a thousand days fromyou know that moment that they wouldmaybe get back to me with these reportsthat could so easily be just sent byemailum what ended up happening is just youknow week after week uhliz from the center for public integrityas well as a wonderful crew of localjournalistsjust started knocking on every singlegovernor’s door saying i want this datawhere is it and what was incredibleabout it is that umuh the set of governors startedreleasing itwhich you ended up starting to see aswell too as different counties as wellstarted sharing the data as well too andalso saying countiesat the county level you know that’s notright let me help you fix it rightthat’s the point of sharing this datavery publicly the house released a setof themuh what’s interesting too is that instates like massachusetts which aretrying to help navigate this crisisbecause no open data existsthey point to our website right thecovid exit strategy projectto help uh with umtelling you what positivity rates areand soyou know i’m jumping through a fewslides because i think i only have a fewmore minutes left iswanted to show you what happens when youput out guidancewithout data right the cdc puts outguidance on what’s supposed to happen atschoolsit’s based on positivity where do youget that datayou can’t today right um but when you’reresponsible for the problemin this case here in cms right they’reresponsible for the nursing homes in thecountrythey have the data right you know it’skind of this little hidden linkyou’ve got links to the archives and sothis kind of realization of if we reallywant to get through this crisisyou got to actually share the data ifyou want people to act on it and youknow this projecthhs protect has over 200 data setsthat we absolutely need and this is apiece from just a month ago nowstill cleaning for this data and in themeantimeyou know why this is so important is youknow there’s a greatdocumentary on netflix called the socialdilemma and there’s a piece at the endthat talks about the shared reality thatwe all live inand if we can’t agree to a sharedreality there’s no way wework together well as a society and inthis case here this pew research reportfound thatif you got your news from trump and thewhite house task forceyou believed that this situation wasunder controland i think for all of us that look atthe data we know that’s absolutely nottrue because it always comes back tothis question ofam i safe and what we see today is thatyou have acadre of people in the public spherenon-profits journalists academics doingeverything they can to keep us informedyou have a world of state and localgovernment officials doing everythingthey can to keep their communitiesinformedyou know they wouldn’t be able to dotheir work without resources liketableauand microsoft bi and google studio anddata wrapper and all the things that webuild right to help themwith these wonderful visualizations andmaps upyou have groups like resolve to savelives who are going state by state tosay hey you’re missing these keyindicatorscompanies like apple and carbon healthand others using their tools to help younavigate government resources liketesting as well as cdc criteriacompanies working together to share howyou know contact tracing data worksand going full loop you know where westarted today rightwith both the teams at humid agency andmuckrock you know thesetools start out as ideas to help ourcommunities and then they can scaleand we’ve got so much work to do so muchwork to do butmy hope is that everything that we doright in our spare time in our company’sspare time the tools that we buildyou know in our normal company time aswell too can hopefully gethelp guide our federal efforts becausewith this third surgeright 30 states are in the red zoneaccording to those task force reportswe’ve got a lot of work to do and so ihope our federal friends rightinside government get inspired by thework that we all are doingand catch up and so with that vivian i’dlove to turn it back to you and sowe can get into some q ayeah um thank you so much ryan we aregonnauh get into question and answerum from those of you who are arewatching today and i’ve got a fewquestions on my own and while we’rewhile you are putting your questions inthat reminder to to put your questionsin the qa tab with your name your affiliationand who your question is directed forbutbut while folks are still getting up tospeed ryanuh so your presentation just nowwas simultaneously so incrediblyinspiring in in so far as so manyvolunteersjournalists and entrepreneurs umfor good like we see at mukhrak like weseeat human agency are doing so much toprovidethe country the incredibly importantinformation and datathat it needs so you were inspiring andsimultaneouslyi feel like my head is going to spin offmy shouldersbecause it is so incredibly frustratingand infuriatingthat the federal government and and somestates and some communities are notforthcoming with the informationthat we need you made a great analogy tothe weather it’s sort of like keepingthe wet how are we i meanonly you know on the one hand we need toknow the weather so i know whether tobring a coat or an umbrella only thisin this case it’s life and death so howdo wehow do we rebuild as a result so muchtrust has been lostin the cdc and in other federal agencieswhere do we go from herehow do we rebuild that trust throughprivate public partnershipshow us the path out of heremy hope here is uh there is reallyincredible work that’s happening withinthe federal government rightand and the issue here is politics aregetting in the way ofthe progress and the actual tacklingwhat we need to do right every time isee one of those reportsthey actually get better right so itmeans there’s really thoughtful peopleinsidetrying to make it better right theyspend every weekend writing thoserecommendations and soi think the important message here isthat there are great people doing thatworkinside there’s an unfortunate layerthat’s preventing it from being sharedpublicly and that’s reallywhat’s criminal right i mean likethere’s no way any of us would tolerateif our weather reports wereprevented or sent only to governors andany of that kind of stuffand i i think what’s happening outsideinthe broader sphere right for all thework that we’re you know we allare doing you know it just shows thatlike i always look for sometimes a solarliningand it’s like the power of what humansand people and compassion can doi think everybody working on any of oneof those projects that i showedwakes up every morning feeling likethey’ve made a difference right likethat they’ve actuallyevery feature they create or every bugthey fixis helping with the problem right and soyou know whenand if the federal government’s willingto open their armsyou know to reach out to all thesegroups to say hey coveted trackingtell us how you built that api hey uhmichaelfrom muckrock like your primary productit’s like how can we integrate better sowe can streamline the foia process oryou know brendan and the team at humanagencyyou know is there a way we can eitherwork with you or open source some ofthese components so we can buildsomething and sharelike there’s all there’s so muchpotential it just takes someonetrying that’s great and i think make youyou kind ofvery quickly noted a very importantpoint i just want to amplify here iswhich there are manysuperb dedicated committed civilservants throughout all these governmentagencieswho are doing the hard work theimportant work with dedication every dayit’s just a matter ofunleashing their data so that it can getinto the hands of the people they needit sobrendan and michael this brings up uh soyou know pressure’s on you were part ofthis incredibly important cohort ofentrepreneurs and technologists who arefilling in the gaps whereum where uh data is so desperatelyneededi you know if you have a reflection onwhat you heard from ryan i’d lovefor you to um jump in with that and wealso have some questions for youum so i will throw your questions i iwill uhuh direct uh questions to each of youand also give you an opportunity inaddition to answering those to addressanything that you heardthat ryan was talking about so ummichael we’ll start with you we got aquestion from afrom a listener beatrice spadachinihopefully i pronounced it pronounce itright she’s interested in learningwhether the new data collector toolis usable in other countries uh outsidethe united states this is obviously aglobalpandemic any plans for that yeah so itit’s currently english only but it isuh we can we can set it up to run umyou know in any country right so it’snot restricted to just you with u.sjurisdictionsand going forward we’re hoping tointernationalize more of our toolscurrently document cloud works in anylanguage and so we’re hoping to bring upthe rest of our tools to that parodyokay great and and brendan what whataboutuh your tool it wasn’t directed at youbut i’d love to hear what whether you’relooking globally as wellyep yeah so uh everything in our tool ispretty much global yeah and and withotheruh the opportunity for other languagesas well i assumeyeah um okay great so umuh uh you know michael backback to you with another anotherquestion from a from ananonymous um listener um who points outthat covet data setsare are time sensitive um you know thenational and local situations areevolving rapidly daily honestlyum are there any time limits on the dataquest to make sure that the reportedvalues are stillrelevant once the particular reportingproject is completedthat’s that’s a really great questionand i think that’s absolutely why wesort of took the approach that we didwas so that you know maybetoday all of a sudden we we see newguidance thatum there’s a new policy around how masksare used and we really want to getanswersvery quickly so we can see where thingsare um so you cannot currently set sortof like hey this is going to close atthis time but you can certainly sort ofinclude that in the textand our goal is that sort of we we cansupportprojects where it says hey we want thisupdated every week here’s this week’squest here’s next week’s questand sort of set it up like that so youcan do ongoing engagement sowe’re really interested in sort offiguring out how do we best help withwith time-sensitive data gatheringtechniques because we think that’s wherethis could really shineright plus i assume since your productis really for journalistsuh and others who are reportinginformation that it’s incumbent on themalso tomake clear what time period a particulardata setis related to absolutely and i think oneof the things we’ve been really inspiredby is all the the news organizationsthat are going out doing reallyintensive gathering with just one or tworeporters and saying okayhere’s each state’s policy on issue xbut thenthey can’t keep that updated everysingle week and so we don’t really havea sense of when thosethose goal posts are shifting and so ithink being able to kind of tackleproblems like thatis really what we’re interested in doingyeahum brandon question question back to youtalk to us about privacy considerationsuh i understand this is a tool that youare you know making available on anenterprise leveluh for those who want to collect datawhether it’s from customersor their employees or what have youhow can uh individuals who areresponding tothe queries via whatever platform slacksms what have youuh be confident about where their datais goingyeah that’s a great question umi mean i think part of that comes toreally and this isn’t like a greatanswer but it’s just thatyou have to essentially provide yourdata to a trusted partyto some degree right i mean likeif you have i mean our users are goingto be you know governments oryou know civic organizations andi mean i think there’s there’s all kindsof concerns ofokay how does that data safely get tothoseentities how do those organizationshandle that data just from a datasecurity perspective and then alsowho do they make that data available toand i would sayi we don’t really control all of thatfrom a technological perspectiveuh we can make it so that we canmake it so depending on the partner thatthe data is likehipaa protected so we can do hipaaprotectionson our end we can store the data in likea a hipaadatabase so we can take differentactions but alsoa lot of a lot of it comes down to who’sultimately using that informationso you’re really relying on the on theon theperson or the institution or the agencythat isdeploying your tool yeah and i thinkif if someone wanted to use our toolthat we didn’t find to bevaguely reputable you know like i meanwe wouldn’thave them use it but i think the uhi think the how people use thetechnology ultimately there’sthere’s there’s so many layers of waysthatthat how people can use it and then howpeople can use data they collect it’sconcerning but also hard to control ryani’d love for you to talk a little bitabout the privacyissue um it’s certainly you know agrowing concern as we seeyou know various uh you know hacks ofdata or justdata leakage even if it’s not ummalicious in any wayyou know a lot of the speaking aboutfederal uh you knowlocal state and federal government dataa lot of course is anonymized butwhat about the what about people’sconcerns about sharing privateinformation as part of that datacollection how did you think about thatwhenyou were in government and how do youthink about it now i mean when you werein government there was no pandemic butthere were otherother issues of course i mean on thatissue i think the the open dataexecutive order and all the work thatthose teams have donelike to to classify different types ofdata sets right there arepublic ones that have no privatesensitive information all the way toones that actually havesensitive information or you knowprotected health information in it andthere’s really good ways of being ableto aggregate that datafeeling safe and comfortable at whatlevel you can share iti mean there are teams that fromeverybody from omb to hhs they know howto do thatso well and so you know hearing theresponse that wellthe information in these reports issensitive is kind of like i laugh alittle bit because i’m like that’s justthe worst excuse or it’s hipaai can’t share it and they’re like idon’t think you know what hipaa is and ibet you don’t know how many p’s or a’sare in there eitherlike it’s uh these are just excuses thatlove to be thrownout when in reality you knowthis is data that needs to be sharedwith the public rightprotects individual uh individuals notthat’s aggregate data that’s right andas a community we know exactly how toaggregate this data when it’s sensitiveandfor most coveted response data it’sprettyum like aggregated right at the countlike it’s it’s soum it’s so noisy or it’s so aggregatedthat there’s no way you can identifyit back to a person so there should beno concern there but for any group orteam that’s collectingactual information from people theirnametheir uh addresses or anything like thatto those details they’ve got to treatthat with respect and careand i think for teams that arecollecting that data they know that andyou know they’re following all the localyou know state laws as well as federallaws to make sure that it’s okayand brendan i’m sure that’s somethingthat you’re that you’re focusing on asyou develop your product becauseuh as i’m sure you know even if ifthere’s a leakage at allyou know could undermine everybody’sdata collection effort so i’mglad to hear you’re going to be mindfulof that you know ryan what uhthere was an another question you knowwe keep talking about open data and thisquestionuh next question is good because i thinknot everybody understands what thatmeans the question is when you say opendata does that mean that the federalgovernment cannot blockthis open access was there not againthis is the question was there not anattempt by the federal government realestate for statesnot to send data on covet to cdc orother federal agenciesof course you touched on this um a bitin your presentation butexplain what open data means preciselyso open data precisely means a data setthat the government has that they’remaking availablepublicly and so if the federalgovernment’s collecting data whether itbe weather data orcova data it becomes open when theyrelease it to the public and it could beas simple as a pdfa csv or you know an api and it’s up tothem and this next part of your questionbeatrice is really importantwhich is was there not an attempt by thefederal government to force statesto report and you’re right yes there wasand is a current attemptby the federal government to increasethe reporting rate from hospitalsbecause it’s truebut a lot of hospitals don’t reportevery week as frequently as the federalgovernment needsto keep their data set up to date and sothey’re doing lots of work to make surethat the data they’re collecting inhhs protect is really good but theproblem is that data is being collectedand only shared within the government insome waysproduced for these task force reportsbut it’s not being shared publicly soit’s not open data yetthe sad part about the stuff that uh uhyou know even within the government youknow we have folks that come to covetextra strategy that come from dot govaddresses just tohelp them guide their reopening effortsthey should be looking at the task forcereports right but they don’t get accessto them and so that’s the kind of weirdthat’s why this problem is so weird ithink for all of us we would expect thisdata to be made public and openand it’s weird that it hasn’t beenthat’s the part that’s been so many daysand it still hasn’tright right well again um in themeantime thank goodness forum all of the all of the uh the citizensand entrepreneurs and academics andresearchers inprivate industry that are jumping in totry to fill that void up there’s aquestion from natalie ward at the beakcenter at georgetown i’ll give this oneover to you um michael as stategovernments begin to realize the valueof the data they collect store andmanageuh she asks how can that data beleveraged as a strategicasset to formulate public policy at thestate levelso that’s the question and i would sayyou know i would sort of you knowframe it a little bit for you as youknow this is a valuable asset beyondjust journalists and do you have queriesor do you have relationships at thelocal or state level whereby thatthe data that that crowdsource data youcollect also can be usefuluh to those agencies and state and localgovernmentyeah i mean i think to answer thatfollowing up on what ryan said you knowi think it’sopen data doesn’t just benefit thepublic it doesn’t just benefitpublic trust it also benefits governmentright because i think it’s so oftenpeople within large organizationspublic or private you know if if youcan’t google it then itif it’s on you’re only on your intraneteven if you technically have access toitit’s really really hard to find it umand that’s that’s truekind of universally these days and ithink it’s particularly true thatwhen government opens up its own datait’s also just benefitingfolks working on these issues and ithink that’s true with our data as wellwe’re really interested in sort ofmaking as many of our our data resultspublic as possibleand um you know we’ve been involved withsome of the code for america brigadeswho are interested in sort of tacklingcertain certain data problems so rightnow our tool is mostly geared atjournalistsbut we’re really sort of figuring outwhat can we do to build stronginformation ecosystems no matter who’sconvening themyeah that’s great so we are running outof time so i’m going to just do a quicklightning round with all of you the lastquestion is the way we close out all thehub webinars so the question iswhat is the bumper sticker phrasedoesn’t have to literally fit on abumper sticker but shortthat you want folks to take away what isthe really what is thewhat what do you most want people tohave learned fromeverything that we’ve talked about todayand i’ll go down um the list andstart with you michael uh crowdsourcingand informed democracyyou were ready for that one excellentbrendancovent entrepreneurialism civicentrepreneurialism is happeningand ryan oh this is a a big bumperstickeryeah go ahead go for it no nois the only cure we have forany global crisis we’re gonna facepandemicsclimate change any of these parts andpuzzle pieces souh more open datathat’s great i sense a theme so this wasreally fabulous and and it’s again it’sjust so inspiring to see the kind ofuh see all of you and so many peoplearound the country and around the worldsort of step up to to you know togetherto try tosolve for the data gap to solve forinformation to solve fornew technologies that can help us endurethis global pandemic which sadly is notgoing awayanytime soon so um uh i want to thankbefore we closeum those that made this covet challengegrants and these programs possiblethe ford foundation the omidyar networkand also the teams uh themembers of the team that allowed this tohappen our program uh coordinator umour director betsy who’s currently onmaternity leaveuh deputy director uh my the team ataspen digital and aspen institute incincluding sevilla carnerum the aspen av team and our covid 19grantees michael brendanand our keynote uh er ryanand of course javier from our tech teamsorry did not want to leave you outso this is the last of our coven 19’schallenge grant series this year we’rereally proud of the work that’s beendone through these six projects weencourage you to check them all out onour websiteuh which we are posting in the beenposted in the comments sectionand we hope you will join us forwebinarsin the future and keep fighting the goodfight thank you for joining useverybody bye byeyou
The COVID-19 crisis has turned many of our traditional communication and information systems upside-down. How can we build resilient tools for accessing resources and information in the midst of a pandemic?
Join Aspen Tech Policy Hub Challenge Grantees as they showcase their projects focused on the theme: Informing COVID Response & Communication Through Tech. Following the presentations of the projects, civic tech leader and former US Deputy Chief Technology Officer Ryan Panchadsaram gave further remarks.
Presented Projects
COVID-19 DataCollector by Michael Morisy & MuckRock: Bringing together MuckRock’s network of 3,000 newsrooms with a crowdsourcing platform designed to harness civic interest in contributing to quality data on the COVID-19 crisis, the COVID-19 DataCollector helps quickly scale efforts to collect and analyze the data needed to inform policy, original reporting, and community responses to the evolving health and economic crises.
Responsive Messaging for COVID-19 Support by Brendan Lind & Human Agency: The demand for and inequity in accessing resources has never been greater, from self-screening for COVID-19 to applying for jobs. Human Agency’s project, Responsive Messaging for Covid Support, is programmed to engage directly with individuals by web, SMS, or messenger app, connecting them to specific resources in their community and interacting throughout the process of accessing what they need.
THE BEST OF ASPEN DIGITAL, RIGHT IN YOUR INBOX.
Sign up for our email list to stay current on our work.