good morningmy name is betsy cooper and i am thedirector of the aspen tech policy huband i’m so thrilled to have you for thefifth webinar in our seriesuh releasing the products of our winter2020 fellowship cohortuh when we started this cohort we couldnot have imaginedthe timeliness of this particularsession uh right now i’m in the bay areaand uh fires that are the clear resultsof climate changeare creating an immediate uh urgentresponse needfor uh ways to communicateduring those situations and that’s noteven to mention the covet 19 pandemicthat has challenged us all even furtherso this is the perfect time to betalking about disaster responseresilience and climate changeand i’m extremely pleased to have anamazing panel to introduce to you todayso first we’re going to be releasing twoamazing projects uh the first run byalexander romeroon emergency response and he’ll befollowed by rayleen young who will betalking to us about tech companiescombating climate changeboth of those will be followed by anamazing keynote by carlos castilloand then we will have audience q aa couple logistical announcements if youhave questions and wehope you do please use the q a box atthe bottom of your screen to ask thoseand then of course uh we’ll be releasingour products throughoutand so you can check the chat so thatyou can get theimmediate link as soon as they go liveso you can check out in real timethe work the fellows have done so firsti’mextremely excited to introduce alexanderromero he works at the defense digitalserviceand in his day job he’s focused on thehack the pentagon programbut at the hub he uh created a reallyinteresting project aroundemergency management response when celltowers go downexactly what’s happening right now inmany parts of our country his work couldnot be more timely and i’m extremelyexcited for him to share with youuh his findings on how to improve thisspace soover to you roro to tell us morethanks betsy um so i’d like to talkabout an issue that should be near anddear to all of usuh that is the issue of emergencycommunicationsduring a disaster or other eventspecifically how to improve that lastmileof communication to your mobile deviceumso communications during emergencies arecritically important uh think about howmuch more difficult it would beto get through the current kova 19pandemic without a way to get muchneeded information or to connect toloved onesso today i’ll be discussing a few thingsthis problem where we are todayand uh where we need to goso what happens today if we all gooffline if the towers that we connect tofor our emergency services either stopfunctioningor uh get see it’s a cyber attack ofsome kind and they just go offlinethey’re no longer availableuh what actually would happen um so tounderstand this problem a little bitbetter you sort of have to know a littlebit about spectrumum so i’d like to discuss a little bitabout what spectrum is i’m going to beoversimplifying quite a lotuh but to start out in the context ofmobile devices spectrum refers to theradio frequencies that wireless signalstravel overthese signals are what enable us to makecalls from our mobile devices tag ourfriends in social media request ridesharespull up directions for destination doeverything on our mobile deviceswithout needing to be plugged into thewall uh the frequencies that we use forour smartphones are actually just a tinyportion of the larger electromagneticspectrumand unfortunately much like real estatethere is only so much availablespectrum that can be used for wirelesscommunications to our cell phonesour cell phones have built-in basebandradios that allow us to communicatewith only certain frequencies into thosetowers and so that isa precious spectrum but fortunatelywe as the people actually own thisspectrum it is considered a publicresourceand we have a say in how it’s used andauctioned offthe federal communications commissionthe fcc they’re charged withmanaging and auctioning off the spectrumso licensingit for specific use cases how and whenit can be used and by whomso if we believe that staying connectedeven during large-scale disasters oremergencies or outagesshould be prioritized we have a say inthatum so today nearly 20 of americans usetheir cellular service as their primaryform of connectivitymeaning that they don’t have an isp athome um and much likefolks used to have wired phones at homeand those were actually consideredpublic safety networksuh we have largely gotten rid of that infavor of wireless communicationsand the trend is continuing so theconvergence to using morewireless communications as the primarymeans of communicationsis definitely uh taking off many folksare also moving away from keeping astandard am fm radio aroundin favor of a personalized internetexperience and app based experience sowhy listen to one station at a time whenyou can justdownload your information as needed andget a more personalized experienceunfortunately those fm stations andthose ways of communicatingare are good when you’re trying tobroadcast out messagesand so if that internet connectivitygoes offline for whatever reason say thefire is in californiaor a cyber attack on our criticalinfrastructure umthen you lose that form of communicationand so on emergency uh notificationsthere’s a system called the uh ipos theintegrated public alert and warningsystemum so essentially it’s the emergencytext messages that you may have seenin the case of hawaii with uh some ofthe mishaps that happened therebut it is is useful when it’s actuallyable to connect you withimportant information around specificeventsor if you need to take shelter or if youneed to be concerned aboutuh various things um so gettinginformation from the government nowis accomplished through various meansbut ipos is one of thoseuh critical methods to get informationout to usum it requires that you have a goodcellular connection and that you’reactually connected thoughso it is totally dependent on these celltowers and last year during the fires inmarin countyuh over 57 percent of the cell phonetowers went offlinedue to insufficient power backups ummeaning that they had rolling blackoutsin the power so they could try tocontrol the fire spreadand that led to the cell phone towersbeing more reliant on their backupbatteries and generatorswhich they only have so much capacity soif they go offline and there is an alertlet’s say the winds have shifted and thefire is now headed in your directionyou may not receive that message and infact that’s actually what has happenedin quite a few cases and ironically as5g networks are beginning to roll outthere’s been other issues um whereconspiracy theories have led tofolks actually burning down cell phonetowers uh because they believe it’s tiedto covet or whateverobviously it’s not true but um as ifthat were not bad enough uh5g in a way sort of makes this a littlebit worse because you need more towersto cover the samearea and so more complexity leads tohigher potential for failure in some wayso where are we now as discussed we’reconverging all forms of communicationintobasically relying on the internet as thebackhaul mechanism to get us connectedum but today there are three and a halfbillion smartphone users around theworldover 80 percent of americans havesmartphones anduh half of those say they couldn’t livewithout their devices it’s the firstthing we look at when we wake up it’s wewe grab it before we even grab ourwallets and keys sometimes and umit is critical to kind of how wefunction in society today but they’reamazing devicesthey allow us to they have the abilityto do all sorts of processing andstoragebut the important piece to all this isthe radios that are built inyou have the ability to connect overwi-fi and bluetooth but those have avery limited range in terms of how farthey cancommunicate if you think about yourhouse you might have bad spots in termsof like wi-ficonnectivity within your own house butyou usually have a decent umsell signal or at least it tends to beable to propagate and push into yourhouse furtheruh and into difficult to reach areas umbut in an emergency uh with if yourcarrier has gone offline if there’s anoutage and communications that alsoaffects the internethow useful is your phone uh even if youfind a wi-fi network to join thosephysical lines may have been severed dueto those disasters discussedum so as climate change happens more andmorei think we’re going to see more of thosekinds of issues tornadoes firesuh hurricanes you name it um they allhave the ability to affect that criticalinfrastructurebut this also presents an interestingopportunity in the form of mesh networksand specifically mesh over cellular sothere is a way to solve this today thethe issue of being so reliant on theseantennas that could failum there is a policy angle and approachthat could be used to do something aboutthiswhere a portion of that spectrum that isbeing allocated and auctioned offis used for this purposeso where we need to go essentially weneed to have a backup networkthat can be turned off at the flick of aswitch uh and one that doesn’t requirenew or expensivegear hardware as an example this is agreat little device it’s called agotennaand if you’re out backpacking you and afriend can have one of these and you cancommunicate over several milesit’s great if you have one it requiresthat it’s charged you have downloadedthe app you’ve registeredit takes some planning in advance sothis needs to be easy to usemake use of existing resources so youdon’t have to buy anything extra or setup newwi-fi networks um and potentially makeuse of the cellular spectrum as itexistsit is it’s out there it works reallygreat and works across long distancesso the helpful alternative link protocolas i’m calling itbecause everything needs a fun namethese days or help for shortis basically mesh network servercellular it presents an offline meshedmodeallowing you to connect to others aroundyou so directly like you would just talkto somebody in a roomyou can talk over these mesh networksnot having to first go to the antennasand the towers and yourservice providers and then backand you can do that today with thesewifi networks but they don’t have thethe optimal characteristicsso this is basically what i’m presentingtodayis an option for your phone to thenconnect you uhto to through this help mode umand essentially this is what it wouldlook like your phone would notice or youwould notice that you’re offline andyou’re not connected it may even showthat you have a signal but nothing seemsto be going throughso you open up an option to turn yourphone into help modethis could then allow you to connect toothers around you letting them know thatyou need assistanceor you’re able to give help you can alsouse it to figure out where thoseresources are at and to communicate withfirst responderswhat help is not so it is a protocol itis not meant toreplace your cell phone carriers it ismeant to augment their ability to getinformation to youum and also for the government to beable to then sendemergency messages to you or firstresponders to be able to connectto to them um so to wrap it upnow this is a lot of information but i’dlike toat least wrap up a little bit uhcommunications during emergencies iscriticalall systems fail it’s improving time andtime again with mytime working at the hack the pentagoneffort i’ve seen how systems can faileven the most resilient ones butallowing access to a portion of theexisting cellular frequencies to be usedover a meshwould create a highly resilient backupnetwork that would bevery difficult to take down because eachnode is essentially its own towerand the more folks that actually jointhese mesh networks the stronger theyactuallyget so i’d like to invite you to visitumthe website resilientlastmile.com uhtook an amazing effort from the team uhand aspentech policyhub tocome together and help me really polishthis up it looks super professional andawesome nowso i just wanted to thank you for yourtime today if you want to contact methat’s my contact information and lastlyi’d really like to thankall the folks that helped to make thispossibilityand of course dr betsy cooper and theteam at the aspen tech policy hub inaspen digitaluh thank you so much for your time andback over to you betsythanks so much roro we’re so proud to befinally releasing this product andextremely excited to have help becomenot just an idea but a true possibilityum and so i just do want to apologize ithink a number of people areexperiencing some technical issues ihopethey’ll be able to get back in andrejoin us but in the interim we’ll keepgoing and make sure to circulate therecordingat the end of the event uh let me remindyou to use the q a button at the bottomof your screen if you have any questionsfor roro orother participants and of course we’llbe releasing our products uhat the uh in the chat so you can nowclick through and see all the amazingthings that rover has produced relatedto helpso next up is rayleen young she’s anengineering executivewho is formerly at stripe and facebookand on leaving the hub she became afounder and ceo of the us digitalresponse which is an amazing brand neworganizationthat pairs tech volunteers with stateand local governmentsin need of help with covid response atthe hubrayleen worked on giving tech companiesand venture capitalists new tools tocombat climate changeagain extremely timely and topical uhissueso i’d like to pass it over to rayleento tell us more about her really reallyinteresting workthanks betsy and thanks to everyone forbeing here todayso you just heard roro talk about a fewways uh to use existing technologies tosolveto solve for and respond to disastersand progress and today i’m going to talkabout the significant impact techcompaniesand cloud computing are having on theclimate and i’m going to focus on waysto addressthat impact that don’t involve inventingbrand new thingsum climate change is a huge global issuei thinkeveryone kind of knows and hears aboutthis and it remains an existentialcrisis forthe whole planet but the role of techand of the tech industry in the climateis not but especially software companiesis not that well understoodum and as the copic crisis has taken thetoptop spot in terms of global pandemicsand criseswe’ve actually seen can come toappreciate the ways that software andtechhave played a beneficial role with ahuge movement to everyone working fromhome and relying on digital toolsbut the climate crisis has not gone awayas all this has happenedand actually the rapid growth ofsoftware and cloud computingthat we are only relying on more witheach dayactually means we’re incurring a growinghitting cost on the climateso in this presentation i’ll give you aconcrete senseof the impact that tech companies haveon the climate todayi’ll do a deep dive on cloud computingspecificallyand i’ll close with some recommendationsfor the tech industry and for startupfounderson how they can take actions to addressthisso what is the impact that techcompanies are having on the climateand this is not i think that wellunderstoodfirst of all um it helps to take a stepback and look atthe global industry in aggregate sofirst you see that digital products andcomputing actually have a huge carbonfootprintat four percent of global emissions thatmight not seem like a lotbut when you think about as you’veprobably heard that flying is really badfor the environmentand then you realize that cloudcomputing is actually equivalent to allof the emissions produced by globalaviationso when you think twice about getting ona plane you might also want to thinktwice aboutyour next netflix marathon or day fullof zoom calls as welllooking within the industry we see thatsoftware companies specifically pack abig punchif you were to map the emissionsproduced by just three companiesamazon google and microsoft to whatwould and translating them to per capitaemissions of u.s citiesthey together would actually be thesecond biggest city in the countryand again these companies are growingfar faster than our cities actually arelooking inside the companies themselvesthe vast majority of emissionsactually come from data centers andcloud computingso really cloud computing is the biggestsource of damage that comes from thesecompaniesbut that means they also represent thebiggest opportunity for changestepping back a little bit and kind oftalking about the concept of climateimpactso to measure many times people willtalk about your carbon footprintand what that means is they’re measuringthe net climate impactthis means you take a look at theemissions you produce which is directlytied to the energy you’re usingand you subtract any makeup or kind ofrecovery actions that you might takesuch as buying carbon offsets oremissions offsets these are things likeplanting treesor paying to recapture methane gasthat’s leaking from landfillsand these are these are good attempts todo good and their attempts to undo thedamage that’s been donebut as you can see from this equation toreally minimize your impact on theenvironment you actually need to focuson theemissions produced and minimize thoseemissions that you’re producing in thefirst placeso now i’ll talk about how exactly allof thisis related to cloud computing and how itimpacts the climateto set some context for the industry thecloud computing market is actuallydominated by a very small number ofcompaniestwo-thirds of the global market iscovered by the same three companies imentioned earliermicrosoft amazon and google and if youlook within the usthese three companies have by far theline’s share of the marketso if you’re a cloud user your only realchoice here iswhich provider you choose and how tochoose their servicesif you’re thinking about minimizing yourclimate impactto break down cloud computing a bit morethe footprint or that the carbonemissionsreally come from three different sourcesthe first is the physical infrastructuresuch as lights building cooling and systinternal systemsthe second is the servers and howefficient they are and finally the thirdis the source of electricityor what the energy is that’s poweringall of this computingwhat’s in just what’s interesting isthat tech companies have actually madesignificant investments in both the datacenter umoperations and infrastructure and serverefficiencyso that while even though the demand forcloud computing has risengreatly over the last five years theneed for the electricity needs haveactually remained pretty flatso that means over time the bulk of theimpact here is really coming from thatthird categorywhat type of energy you are usingbut this gets even more complicatedturns out when you talk about the energythat you’re using there’s a lot ofnuance hereyou may have heard about some largercategories of energyin the news so you think of fossil fuelsyou might think of them as dirty energysourceslike natural gas oil and coal and thenyou may have heard of clean energyand you might think great clean energyis great right must be clean must begoodbut thinking back on the early equationi showed earlierwe see that many different types ofenergy sources or kind ofenergy emissions can be classified asclean but what’s actually happeningunderneath the hood can be wildlydifferentso here you see that 100 renewableenergythat is actually produced and used inreal time from clean sources like solarand windis by far the best option and canactually do a lot less damage thansomething like100 carbon neutral because you don’treally see what’s happeningin terms of the emissions producedversus offseti think this classification of cleanenergy is a little bit likethe low-fat or fat-free movement innutritionwhere a lot of products were initiallymarketed as good for you as beinglow-fatbut actually manufacturers werecompensating for the low fat by adding alot more sugarso in the end these foods weren’tnecessarily that much better for youand the marketing can be a bitmisleadingso not only does the source of energymatters but to make this even trickierthe location also really matters sowhile the value proposition of cloudcomputingis that you can easily access your datafrom anywhere anytimein truth all of that data is beinghoused in some physical locationand if you’re a startup in the u.s it’sprobably in a data center somewhere inthe countryhosted by amazon google or microsoftand that location really matters when itcomes to the climate impacthere is a sampling of some common datacenter locations in the u.sand the associated produced emissionsand net emissions from the three majorprovidersand i know i’ve worked at companies thathave hosted data centers in many ofthese states like oregoncalifornia and virginia if you look atthe data hereyou see that these choices can have ahuge impact on your footprintas a google cloud platform user if youwere to switch from a data center invirginiato one in oregon you could actuallyreduce your grid emissionsby almost 60 percent and those are thoseactual emissions produced in real timeif you’re an aws user switching fromohio to oregon could actually save you75 percentand if you care about that low fatoption you can if you switch fromaws to either google or microsoft azurein most places this will bring your netemissions all the way down to zeroso what does that all mean and what dowe do about all of thisfor the industry at large i thinkunderstanding all of this is the firststepin that same analogy we all need tolearn how to read the nutrition labelsand to un really understand what’shappening when companies aretalking about their clean strategies andthe clean energyand by understanding uh those details wecan learn how to make smarter choicesand to share that knowledge with otherswe also need to fundamentally push to100renewable energy actually produced andpurchased and used in real timethere are some significant industrycoalitions out there such as therenewable energy buyers allianceand the re-100 where hundreds ofcompanies from all across the worldhave committed to going 100 renewableand these companies include names you’veheard of like applefacebook and google and microsoft butalso some companies like starbucks andtargetall of them have made public commitcommitments to moving to 100renewable energy which is great but weneedmany more companies to also make thesame commitment and collectively we needto get there a lot fasterso finally what about startups um whilethey’re often dismissed as being toosmallor too focused on growth and survival toreally be able to prioritize theirclimate impacti think startups can have a huge climateimpact when you think ofthe fact that they’re more agile thanlarger established companiesthey’re growing at a much faster rateand they have the ability to changecloud providersand software vendors with far fewerdisruptions to their businessand furthermore i think one of the greatthings about startups is how fast theygrow and howsmall companies today will end up beingthe tech giants of the futureso if you think about that any changesthat all startups make todaywill quickly quickly compound over timeas they all growand scale into global companiesso here are a few suggested actions forstartupsthey really form they really take a fewforms i think that first step is againunderstanding do calculate a basiccarbon footprintusing a simplified framework forstartups and take a hard look at yourcloud computing setup what provideryou’re using what regions you’veselectedand how what does your energy use looklikethere’s a lot of good work in thisindustry to learn from too soyou can actually examine what leadingcompanies like google have already doneand learn from their actionsand finally i think we can’t get therewithout collective actionso it’s really important to not onlytake these climate actions but todocument them and share them with theworldi think this can be really inspiring notonly for other companiesand your investors but also for youremployees whereat a fast increasing rate how cleantheir company is and how environmentallysustainable the company’s operations areare becoming an increasing factor inwhich companiesnew employees choose to work for sotying this all togetheras part of my project i’ll be launchingall of these outputs on the new websiteclimateprimer.orgincluding a detailed startup climateguide that actually walks throughsome tips and tricks for following allthe steps i mentioned in thispresentationand with that i want to thank everyonewho contributed to this especially myproject collaboratorcollaborator and fellow and fellowfellow anjana rajanbut also a huge thank you to the manypeople i reached out to throughout thecourse of researching this projectall of whom are working hard on theclimate fight so thank you very muchagainback to you betsyfabulous job rayleen and we’re so proudof all the work that you were able toput togetheronto this project we hope that you’lltake a look in the chat functionand link over so you can see the amazingwebsite that she’s created and allthe tools that are ready to be used bystartups and venture capitalists sothis is something that we’re not justsharing as research it’s actually a toolthat we hope you’ll continue to usegoing forward and also please be intouch with rayleen to continue thoseconversationsum next i also want to point out thatthe qa button is open so if you have anyquestions for rayleenuh for roro or for anyone who’sparticipating todayplease insert them in the q a box at thebottom of your screennext i’m very excited to introducecarlos castillohe recently became the chief developmentofficer of tidal basin groupbut he joined that team from fema andmost recently wasacting deputy administrator forresilience thereso his work um after a storied careerin resilience and disaster response isperfectly at the intersectionof the products that we’re releasingtoday and we’re thrilled to have himcommenton these projects we should also notethat like i did and like several othersdidcarlos had some technical difficultiesso he may have missed portions of thepresentationsuh but uh we know that he has amazingthings to say regardless souh carlos over to you for your commentsand thanks again for being herewell well thank you uh betsy and yes idid have somealmost uh ironically i did have sometechnical issues but i’m happy to saythey’ve been uh they’ve been taken careofuh i uh first i wanna thank you forhaving me here today it it truly is apleasure to be here and uh all of youparticipating in this session whetheryou’re a panelist or whether you’re apresenteryou play an integral role in helping ourcountry be better prepared for anemergencyas mentioned i prior to joining titlebasin as chief development officer i wasthe acting deputy administrator ofresilience at fema andi oversaw national continuitypreparedness programs grant andinsurance and mitigation basically allthe the pre-disasterfunctions at fema we had threeoverarching strategic goals and one wasto to build a culture of preparednesswhichi was responsible for second to readythe nation for catastrophic disastersand three to reduce the complexity offemaso to help us build this culturepreparedness we form the resiliencesection withinuh within the agency so you may ask whatwhat’s resilience what does it mean tousthere are a variety of definitions andwe adopted one from the nationalinstitute of standards and technologyand it says resilience is the ability toprepare for anticipated hazardsadapt to changing conditions andwithstand andrecover rapidly from disruptionsso if you think about it the thedefinition almostum uh sort of uhaccepts that we are going to be there’sgoing to be the earth moving there aregoing to beweather events or the the hurricanes aregoing to comebut it doesn’t mean it’s a disaster andthey’re anticipated and we know aboutthem so there’s a lot we can do toprepareand to prevent there’s no truer test ofresilience and our abilityto bounce back then the situation thatfaces us today with covet 19.while our nation mourns the loss of somany due to this hidden enemythe fact that we can still holdimportant forms like this virtually is atestamentto our nation’s resilience effectivedisaster management i’ve learned overthe years islocally executed state managed andfederally supportedi’m a true believer in this philosophy istarted my career at the local level mytime was with miami-dade county inflorida gave me an appreciationfor the unique challenges of localgovernment and i also gained anappreciation for how a preparedresilient community can bounce back evenstronger than theythan they were before the disaster i’vealso come to seethe benefits of hearing from peopleoutside government people like yourpresenters and many of you participatingvirtuallyfirst let me let me talk a little bitabout uh what fema’s doing with inresponse to covid19because i think that you’ll see somesome tie-ins thereso under the direction of the whitehouse coronavirus task force femacontinues to execute a whole of americaresponse which means everyoneto fight the covet 19 pandemic andprotect the publicearly on our fema administrator petegainer identified three main objectivesfor our agency number onelead federal operations on behalf of thetask force and be prepared to respond toanystafford act declaration in a covet 19environmentincluding possible future covet 19incidentsnumber two preserve the workforce ourmost valuable resourceand three execute mission essentialfunctions becausewe’re still responsible for doing thatour national response coordinationcenterhas been fully integrated with thedepartment of health and human servicesoperations and fema was working with 10regional offices throughout the countryto under understand the needs ofpartners on the groundall 50 states the district of columbiafive territories and several tribes havebeen approved for major disasterdeclarations additionally71 tribes are working directly with femaunder the emergency declarationthis alone is unprecedented in ournation’s historyso that’s why the the title of this thissessionis key because we are in anunprecedented time inunprecedented uh circumstancesfema’s also executing moving a movementof critical supplies from the globalmarketto medical distributors in variouslocations across the countrymuch of this is being done through ournation’s private sectorwhich is critical to the whole ofamerica responseand i want to talk about this becauseit’s a waste that thatboth the presenters and and others cancan it’s a way to to make a differenceand to influence the decisions at femaso we coordinate well why was that femaand fema still coordinateswith the private sector primarilythrough the national businessemergency operations center or nbeocbecause everything must be an acronym inthe federal government you understandthe the nbeoc was created to enhancecommunication and collaboration withprivate industry partnersand ensure their integration intodisaster operations at a strategic andtactical levelduring response operations nbeocmembers are linked to fema’s naturalresponse coordination centerand the broader network of emergencymanagement operations to include ourstate and federal partnersthe nbeoc offers a platform to shareinformation on impactsoperating status and recovery challengesas well as access to information tosupportbusiness continuity decisions andintegration into planningtraining and exercises participation inthe mboc is voluntary and open to allorganizations with significant andmulti-stategeographical footprints in the privatesectorwhich include large businesses chambersof commerce trade associationsuniversitiesthink tanks and non-profits thiscontinues to be a federally supportedstate managed and locally executedresponsea word about preparing for otherdisasters and soof course we’ve responded to the thecurrent crisis at femawe also needed to prepare for otherdisasters and keep in mind this thisyear wasn’t the first time that fema hasmanaged more than onemajor disaster at a time in 2018 theagency responded to two major hurricaneson the east coast and the worstwildfires in california’s history at thesame timethousands of female employees were stillworking recovery efforts from thedevastating 2017hurricanes so this fema’s alreadyresponded to severe weatherevents during the pandemic likedevastating tornadoes in the southeastand several tropical storms andhurricaneskeep in mind we’re approaching thestatistical peak of hurricane seasonand let me just briefly cover what wedid to prepare for this seasonfor in this this kobe 19 environment onewe established an additional nationalresponsecoordination center across from femaheadquarters in case another disasteroccurs so we identified over 200 peoplemany of them across my organizationready to be activatedfor a surge if necessary a workforceeven with more than 3 100 employeessupporting the co-fed 19 response werely on our 20 000 employees who arecommitted emergency managersin addition to other federal agenciesand others that come in as temporaryemployees sheltering and this is is keyespecially for for hurricanes as peoplemight have to evacuate their homesum we need we’ve provided guidance tomake sure that people realize thatit’s not business as usual in a covetenvironment you’re going to be leavingyour home perhaps to some place thatwill be kept you’ll be kept safe but itperhaps it’s not the most comfortableso encourage the people to to wheneverthey canshelter at home or as they say shelterin placeand one key point i think especially forfor the aspenuh tech hub you know is isestablishing virtual operations we’revirtualizing our operations as much aspossible includingvirtual joint field offices this iswhere allareas all entities come together in thefield and ouras well as our national and regionalresponse coordination centerswe’re using technology to conductvirtual inspectionsfor fema individual assistance as wellas a national flood insuranceprogram claims adjusting using picturesand video streaming from impactedsurvivor homespredimela preliminary damage assessmentsfor public assistance can also beconducted remotely using windshieldsurveys from a vehicleor virtually using desktop assessmentsthere’s several other things that thatwe’re doing that we were doing at femaand a lot has to do with how to how tofunction in this covet environmentwhich is how we’re all uh having toadapt toand uh you know shortly after umwe entered into the the emergencyoperations for covidi turned on my laptop one morning justas we were giving the direction thatpeopleat fema that our employees couldn’tcould uh work remotely could basicallywork from homeand i see this this icon for microsoftteams and hadno idea what it was but that wouldbecome an invaluable partner for usboth teams and zoom would come in avaluable partner thatwe switched over almost instantly whichi know is unheard of sometimes in thefederal government but we were able todo it and we’re able to functionwe’re also doing some things likepushing out messaging through publicservice announcements we’re updatingprotective action guidance onon ready.gov which has informationonline for individualsfamilies kids and and businesses on howto preparefor hurricane season and under otherevents other disastersand now uh a little a few words and iapologize i missed part of thethe first presentation from railroad butum i you knowi want to i have to tell you followingevery major disasterit’s standard process or standardpractice to conduct an after actionreview and this is toto identify ways that that emergencymanagerscan improve their response i can’t thinkof one after action review that has notincludedcommunications as an area forimprovement so i think part of what whatrailroad presented is key isand is important is is taking that intoaccount that that it’s key and partis the technical communications but it’salso the verbal and oral communicationsthat that go along with itthat has to be done and i think buildingon the existingprocesses that and uh and systems thatare there that peopleare used to using will make it a loteasier and a lot i thinkmore potential for for acceptancelikewise and and i will i would love totake questions on both ones once i’mdone i’malmost wrapping up here but uh i alsoyou know likewise changing futureconditions in our environment must beplanned for and mitigatedum i i have to point out uh um andraeleen you had some excellent pointsand i thinkpart of uh of making those changes butfor both of you i think isis creating the awareness that these areissues and i think you didyou’re doing a good job in doing thatespecially establishing the website thati think most people don’t realizeuh what the effects are but i think femaum stepping up to the plate recentlyannouncedfunding that will be available to stateand local governments and tribal areasto mitigate disaster risk before thedisaster occursthis program is called the the buildingresilient infrastructure and communitiesor bricprogram this year alone it will provide500 million dollars for mitigationprojects throughout the country andbefore i go into moreand and go into questions i i want topoint out just uh outline a few waysthat you can help fema um fema valuesinput from people like you who bring afresh new perspectivefema’s created a how to help page onfema.gov which includes guidance on waysyou can supportthe coronavirus response questionsoffers or donations can be fielded tofema in its nationalbusiness operation center email inboxforms like this this demo day areimportant ways to continue to develop aculture of preparedness andand i thank you for the support and uhbeing a passionate emergency managerfor a long time um i’m really happy tosee thethe the the potential for what you’vepresented here and some ofthe other work that that you’ve beendoing um with that uh i’ll i’ll turn itback over to betsy and and i’ll bearound forquestions as wellgreat thanks so much carlos and wereally appreciate both you’re taking thetime to give us such a thorough updateon all of these uh reallyinteresting aspects of covet 19 responseand then tying it into the fellows workand the need for better communicationwhich is definitely something that wefocus on here at the hubso i’d now like to bring up all thepanelists um so that we can startanswering the many questions that arecoming inuh while we’re getting that settled uhjust a reminder touh feel free to ask additional questionsin the q a box at the bottom of yourscreenand then make sure to check out the chatfunction uh so that you canuh see the products that we’ve beenreleasingso first uh i want to turn my firstquestionto carlos uh in what wayshas coven 19 confirmed your thinkingabout disasterpreparedness and then in what ways hasit shifted your thinking on disasterpreparednessuh you need to unmute as well sorrycarlosyes and so you know preparednessdisaster preparedness or emergencypreparednessis a two-way street you know everyemergency manager everyone involved initum has a constant challenge to getpeople to listen to take action for forwhat’s presenteda lot of times it takes something majorhappening soif we have for instance a hurricaneaffecting one communitythat community will be very wellprepared going forward because they knowit could happenbut also there’s sometimes the effect ofof other communities that identify withthe affected onethat say you know what this could happenherein this case because and i you know idon’t throwaround the word unprecedented lightlybutkovid 19 is an unprecedented disaster ifyou willnot just here but globally so peoplesee and and have come to action and andno so i think that confirmssome of my my thoughts along the the wayinto my philosophy thatyou have to get people’s attention iwould prefer not to have to do it withkobitbut i think people have come and seenthat the benefits ofof preparing and doing doing what theyneed to do becauselives are at stake and and just aboutany everyone is affected either directlyor indirectly with covet 19.fantastic thanks so much um i next wantto turnto row rows so what is the long-termgoal for meshin your opinion does a mesh network havethe potential to replace the cell towernetwork in the future an audience memberasksi think so i if anybody’s watched theshow umsilicon valley from hbo there’s a wholenotion of pied piper and piper netsthat’s notthat’s not what this is about so i wantto make sure that’s clear this is notmeant to really replace thecellular networks uh it is meant toaugment them umbecause i think if they saw this as athreat then they wouldn’t be willing towork uhto hand in hand because we’reessentially asking to use a portion oftheir frequenciesto push that connectivity out to thatlast mileum so i mean theoretically it couldyes and and with new 5g technologiesthey’re actuallylooking at how they can use uh forexample it’s called v2xvehicle to other things so your vehiclecan then be connected in a mesh networkwithout needing to connect to theantennas so theoretically yes it couldbe but the intent of this project wasspecifically around emergencycommunicationsgreat thanks so much um and so i want tobring rayleen into the conversationso climate change is one of the mostnebulous and daunting challenges facingour world todaybut your project proposes really simpleand elegant solutionshow did you figure out the scope forthis project and what was the process bywhat you got therelike i felt like a very longdifficult process lots of winding turnsumyeah i think it is a really broadproblem and i think the first thing idid was actually talk toa bunch of experts in the field and ishowed on the last slide of mypresentation thatthe people that i talk to span a hugerange of areassome are working in making the buildingbetter software for the energy gridsome are entirely focused on advocacyand policy efforts to kind of influencegovernments to set higher renewableenergy targets somy research took me in a pretty wideranging uhdirections and ultimately i settledthere’s a few reasonsa few reasons i zeroed in on softwarecompanies in cloudi think for one that’s my background sojust when i started researchingspecifically cloud providers andstartups andit all resonated more with my personalexperience so i was kind of able toto get the concepts faster and dive inand the second one was actually similarto what rovo said in his presentationi think if you are only looking atsolutions that arekind of high tech or maybe not yetmature technologyit can feel like you know you’re sort ofnot able to do anythingright now with what’s in front of you soi specifically wanted to focus on stepsthat you can taketoday that have nothing to do withneeding new climate technologies to comeonlineeverything that i describe you can dotoday and reduce your footprint withoutumreally any new technologyfantastic thanks so much um and so thenext question comes from steven smithand it’s for carlosdoes the model of disaster responsebeing locally managedstate funded and nationally supportedstill applywith a global pandemic like kova 19i’d say it absolutely does you know whoknowsat the local level at your communitylevel who knowswhat the good the bad the good the badand the ugly if you willis about your community better than youuh i don’t think you you wantthe federal government coming into everysingle community and trying to runthings and take things overso understanding and having the toolsand the supportuh perhaps for major disasters likekobituh from the federal government is keybut knowing wherehow you want to take your community andeveryone at the community level willtell you their community is uniqueand and in a way they are and i think umwhether it’s covet 19 or something notas largeit’s always i’ve seen the benefit of itumwhere the people at the at the ground onon the ground at the local levelunderstand what their needs are and arebetter equipped to to handle thatwith support for something like this andsome general guidance as wellso absolutely i think it would it’s beenworkingfantastic and so uh i want tothink us for a second about thestakeholder map because bothuh row row and rayleen’s projects have alot of different stakeholders that needto get onboard um so for each of you could youtalk a little bit about who are the keystakeholders that you want to bring onboardand do you have any tips for how to getthem to work collaborativelytogether to try to achieve real changeso rayleen maybe i’ll go to you first onthat pointgreat um yeah i think that the biggestthing uhi i realized was it all it kind of allstarts with some of the concretelike information and data i think that’sbeen most compelling forpeople i’ve talked to especially in thetech community so if you can kind ofbreak down the conceptsand and tie them to specific actionsmeasured in emissions or dollar savedor energy costs a lot of the followingarguments kind of fall in place so ithink it’s reducingthe problems into a common language thatpeople understandis where i’d startgreat what about you rory yeah thisone’s actually fascinating because uhthings have actually changed sothroughout the course of this projecti never thought i would see the daywhere google and apple work together umbut they work together forthe contact tracing um sort of back-endsupport system through bluetooth lowenergyand so they actually came together towork on a standard and a protocolso that information could be shared inorder to enable contact tracingi think they are still working on orindividual states are working on theirownapps but um that’s one of the keystakeholders is the device manufacturersthemselvesthey have to be able to support thisdown to the baseband providers the folksthat actually make the radiosin your phones to the network providersthe carriers and and the regulatorypieces of thisbut ultimately it comes down to theindividual who asksuh let’s say the fcc to set aside aportion of the cellular spectrum forthis use case so it isthere’s many stakeholders quite a few uhand they all have their important feesthat’s great and carlos you’ve beendealing with lots of stakeholders overyour careerdo you have one or two tips for how doyou get across the finish line when youneed to coordinate a huge number ofpeopleuh with varying interests i i think twotwo key points onetiming is everything i’ve learned youknow once you get people’s attentionyou know i think now so much is changingwith technologyand it’s coming to emergency managementas wellyou know so so that’s one thing theother thing isidentifying what barriers exist tobringing people to the table especiallyuh you mentioned amazon and google oryou know others thatthat bringing them together um what’skeeping them from doing that if you canhave a rallying cry a call to actionthatpeople can see the benefit of i thinkthat’s a step in the right directionfabulous and so um a related questionfor row row how do smallentities get involved in this meshnetwork system so larry clarkpoints out that cities counties mightnot even understand their non-emergencysteady state data requirements and flowsin this spaceso how do we’ll help deal with thesesorts ofuh education problems for stakeholdersyeah i think uh carlos said uh hit it onthe headin terms of being able to be aware youfirst need to be aware of the problem sothat’s the first step herebut then also individuals can uh informtheir governments that may this issomething that they want uh them to lookatand sort of drawing out where the thegaps are so is there a gap in thecurrent coverageum is there a history where the systemshave failed in the past and then usingthat to start a conversationthere are some really great projectsaround this actually uh some based innew york citythere’s one based in the san franciscoarea probably a fewdisaster dot radio where theyessentially put up these little solarpowered batterypowered devices on just sticks on top ofbuildings and then that can be used tothen connect to that wi-fi and thenuh enable emergency communication sothere’s lots of projects like thatum i think those are helpful tounderstand the problem but ultimately ithink the solution is using a cellularto enable that and another relatedquestion from an audience member wouldconsumers have to voluntarily downloadanything or consent to new softwarein order to allow their phones to usemeshthat’s a really important piece i thinkthat is something that still needs to beworked out butit it would be much better if it werejust baked into the phone today if youneed to call 9-1-1you don’t actually have to press thenumbers on your phone anymore there’s abuilt-in function where if you justpress i think five times on the powerbuttonor there’s some other modes ways to turnthat on automaticallyum it’s just a built-in feature and somuch like that is a built-in feature iwould expect thatthis protocol would be built into theunderlying operating systemso that you could you could easily useit without having to download otherthingsfantastic and i’ll turn this next one torayleen first sowhat can the folks watching the webinarstoday do to contribute to the success ofyour projects and the mission sorayleen if you wouldn’t mind jumping infirst and then row i think sharingum sharing some of the the lessons anddata and tipscaptured in the guide i think is thefirst step i think one thing i shouldsay we ran i ran a survey of some earlystage startups when i was doing thisprojectand what was it really interesting isthe vast majority of startup founderswere interested in understanding theirclimate footprint and taking someactions toreduce it but very few of them had anyideaabout how to do that so i think thisproject is really meant to give you thehow and i think if you can get the wordoutmore startup founders are actuallyreally excited to take action if theyknow how toyes if you uh check out the website um ihave a section on there saying that thatis labeled get preparedand so things that folks can do today toprepare themselvesfor an emergency you don’t want to bepreparing at the last minuteum you know the toilet paper crisis of2020 i think is a good example of thatrightor masks or other things right gettingit prepared in advance is superimportantso there are things that you can do toprepare umbut in order to to get informed you sortof need more informationto sort of decide what the best path issofolks want to actually help out there isa portion of the site thathas some draft language or samplelanguage that they can use to reach outto the fcc to then askto maybe make the spectrum available forthis use casegreat and we’re getting lots oftechnical questions for railroads soi’ll ask one moreone of the challenges here is populationdensity have you considered engagingoperators to add their towers or othercommunication platforms to make up fordensity gapsyes absolutely so that is that’sactually where originally i went withthisi wanted to make sure that the networksthemselves are more resilient so imentioned this a little bit but thewired networks of yesterdayuh that we no longer have in our homesum those were actually consideredsafety networks and they had separatepower separate backupso that you could still use it even ifyou didn’t have power to the housethe current networks are not classifiedthe same way and so i would say thatthat’s the first stepis changing the classification of thosenetworks so they are safety criticaland so that they have to have higher uptime and higher availabilityworking to make sure that there isbetter coverage is also a key part ofthisthere’s actually some draft legislationin the works today that saysin an emergency should be allowed toconnect to any cellular network so evenifyour service provider doesn’t have anantenna right by you you could useanother oneduring emergencies i think that’scritical as well umdon’t wanna monopolize the three minuteswe have left so i’ll stop therewell so as rory mentioned we’re almostto the end of our time so i will ask ourfinal question which is what is thebumper stickerthat you wish people could take awayfrom this panel so if you have the onesentence thing that should go on theback of your carwhat is that thing so i’ll go to rayleenfirstso uh in 2011 mark andreessen famouslysaid software is eating the worldand i think now in 2020 i think weshould update it too software ispolluting the worldoh very clever we might actually have toproduce thoseroro what about you uh i’ve thoughtabout this one and umso the short version is i would probablymake a bumper sticker that couldactually let people connect to it sothen everycar on the road is like part of thenodes um butrealistically if it’s just a vinylsticker maybe i mess you in the shape ofa hearti don’t know and romero made thestickers on her laptop soi wouldn’t put it past him that willactually have the opportunityto have those uh in the future carloswhat’s your bumper sticker for the paneli’d say that the time for change is nowand uh you know a lot behind that ithinktiming is everything like i said and andwe’ve got thethe political will the funding behind ituh at different levels and people arepaying attention so now is itthe time to to help build our resilienceas a nation thank youfantastic and thanks for joining us so iwant to thank our fellowscongratulations roryand rayleen amazing projects and we’rereally proud of youi want to thank carlos for joining ustoday it’s been phenomenal to have youhereadding your wisdom about what’s going onin real timei’d like to thank our team so sevillamaddie javiercarner the aspen support team i’d liketo welcome our two new team members ournew deputy director mai sislaand our new program coordinator mayhaanda special congratulations to our winter2020 classthis concludes your project launches socongratulationsuh this class is very special to us notleast because during their closingceremonieswas the moment at which the aspeninstitute shut down for covet 19so this class has been through a lottogether and we’re really proud ofeverything you’re doneat the hub we’re not resting on ourlaurels we have a new webinar serieson our covid19 challenge grant so wefunded close to a hundred thousanddollars of covet 19projects and we’re going to startreleasing those on september 9thso please stay tuned for moreinformation on thatand in the interim we just want to thankeverybody uhfor uh participating in this seriescongratulations again to the fellowsand we hope you have a wonderful dayyou
If there is anything that the COVID-19 crisis has taught us, it is the importance of planning for future large scale risks. How can we change or use technology to better prepare for the looming crisis of climate change and other disasters?
Join Aspen Tech Policy Hub Fellows as they showcase their projects focused on the theme: Disaster Tech: Preparing for Unprecedented Crisis. Following the presentations of the projects, Carlos J. Castillo, incoming Chief Development Officer of Tidal Basin Group, gave further remarks.
projects presented
Helpful Alternative Link Protocol: When disaster strikes, reliable and easy-to-use communications become absolutely critical. Dependable communications are needed to pair those in distress with those able to provide assistance. Alexander ‘RoRo’ Romero designed a project that aims to improve the resilience of cell networks and backup systems that are currently in use in a range of disaster-based situations.
Tech Companies Combating Climate Change: To avoid the worst effects of climate change, scientific consensus states that CO₂ emissions must decline 40 to 60 percent by 2030 to keep our planet from warming more than 1.5°C. To achieve these goals, the software industry, whose climate impact from cloud computing is often underestimated, must significantly change. Raylene Yung led a project that will help investors and startups with tools to understand the environmental impact of their cloud computing.
Presenters
Carlos J. Castillo
incoming Chief Development Officer, Tidal Basin Group
Carlos J. Castillo is the incoming Chief Development Officer of Tidal Basin Group, an expert consultancy in disaster preparedness & recovery. Most recently, Mr. Castillo was the Acting Deputy Administrator for Resilience at the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). In his nearly 40 year career in emergency and disaster management, Mr. Castillo oversaw FEMA’s Individual and Public Assistance Programs; led development of the Agency’s National Disaster Housing Strategy, working closely with other Federal partners following major disasters, including Hurricanes Katrina and Ike; and represented the U.S. internationally in disaster management at organizations such as the United Nations, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, and the Asia-Pacific Economic Consortium.
Alexander ‘RoRo’ Romero
Digital Services Expert, Defense Digital Service
Alexander ‘RoRo’ Romero is a Digital Services Expert at the Defense Digital Service and is the technical lead for the Hack the Pentagon Program. He was previously the CISO at the Defense Media Activity at the Department of Defense, and served in the Marines as an Electro-Optical Ordnance Repairer. Alexander has a Masters Degree in Information Systems with a focus in Computer Security from Strayer University. In his spare time he likes to run cybersecurity conferences, pick locks, punk self driving cars, and build electronic gadgets.
Raylene Yung
engineering leader, Stripe
Raylene Yung was an engineering leader at Stripe where she led Payments, Product, and global expansion in Asia-Pacific. Prior to Stripe, she was an engineering director at Facebook and led efforts on privacy, content creation, and News Feed. She holds a BS and MS in Computer Science from Stanford University.
This conversation is part of the Aspen Tech Policy Hub’s Demo Day Video Series. Please visit our website to learn more about our series and RSVP for other events.
THE BEST OF ASPEN DIGITAL, RIGHT IN YOUR INBOX.
Sign up for our email list to stay current on our work.