higood afternoon everyone and welcome i’mmai sisla deputy director of the aspentech policy hubfor those of you who are new to us theaspen tech policy hub is a policyincubator that trains technologists inthe policy process through fellowshipand executive education programsi’m thrilled to welcome you all today toour second demonstration day event ofthe second cohort of the tech executiveleadership initiativealso known as telly the tele program isa joint initiative in the aspen techpolicy hub and the tech talent projectit is a 10-week skills buildinginitiative to prepare experienced techleaders to engage effectively withpublic sector challengesthe program provides senior techprofessionals with a unique leadershipopportunity to build skillsthrough real world engagement withgovernment and policythe hub and tech talent project cametogether this spring to run the secondcohort of thisinitiative every week from january tomid april we met with our cohort of teleleaders to prepare them for governmentand policywork this afternoon we’ll be introducinga few of those leadersthey will be presenting results from theculminating project of the tele programthroughout the tele program we asked theleaders to participate in a variety ofexercisesfrom writing policy memos to creatingstakeholder maps to working on a sixweekschallenge project their culminatingproject asked them to take all of thelessons learned and devise a solution toa real tech policy problem thatgovernments are now facinglast week we presented our first set ofprojects focused on improving technologyproject approval processes at the stateof californiathis week we’ll be presenting our secondset of projects on a problem that manystate governments are grappling withthe idea of covet 19 digital credentialsas more people across the countryreceive covid19 vaccinesthere is a growing interest frombusinesses schools and other entitiesand a mechanism to confirmindividuals vaccination status beforethey access areas and certain servicesvarious groups have proposed a varietyof solutions from digital versions ofthe physical cdcvaccine cards many of us received togovernment issued health passportsas you might imagine state manageddigital vaccine credential systems bringup a myriad of privacysecurity and ethical questionsour leaders were tasked with thefollowing question should statescreate digital vaccine credentials giventhe widespread implications of doing sothey were asked to give a recommendationto the fictional state of outdoorsvilleon whether the state should implementdigital vaccine credentialsand if not what the state should do toensure that businessesand schools can open up safelythe leaders were split into three teamsfor this project and as such we’ll havethree teams presenting their own uniquesolutionsto be clear these teams only had a fewweeks to both understand their problemand propose a solution to this verytricky and complicated issuethat was changing in real time as you’llsee they’ve come up with outstandingwork in this limited timewhich just goes to show the power thatthis type of creative thinking can haveto improve policy and governmentservicessome brief logistical announcements forthis afternoonafter all of the teams present we willintroduce our fabulous keynote speakersid harrell a civic technologist andformer chief of staff of 18fwe also wanted to know that the teamsare releasing their projects liveso please check out the links in thechat box so you can follow in real timelast we’ll save a few minutes for q a atthe end please submit your questions inthe q a box below and we’ll have theteam members eitheranswer their questions live or via thechat boxso with that i’m thrilled to introducethe four italian leaders on the firstteamfor this afternoon this first teamincludeselizabeth nash a data executive who iscurrently chief data officer atpolicymapa platform that solves place-basedproblems for government agencieslawden nasserian a data engineeringproject manager at applefocused on data privacy and machinelearning brian sagera tech founder of multiple companies whois currently founder and ctoof reveal networks a natural languageprocessing companyand tony sebro an attorney engaged intechintellectual property and privacy issueswho is currently deputygeneral counsel at wikimedia for thispresentation we’ll have elizabeth nashand tony sebro presentingover to you elizabeth and tonythank you byeum elizabeth just just so you knowyou’re on view thank youno problem these days so thank you verymuch for the opportunity to present ourrecommendations on this really toughquestion that’s on many of our mindsour group had a solution that i want totalk a little bit about today and thatisthat we think that instead of buildingout a centralized or decentralizeddigital vaccine credential system thestate should advocate for the federalgovernment to issue guidance on theissuewe think this because with this approachwe can ensure consistency across stateborders to account for touristsand workers coming from outside thestatewe think that they could be used in aprivate orpublic credential we believethat it’s a neutral stance ona highly divisive issuethis solution could ensure privacy dataprotectionand transparency and as suchwe think that outdoorsville could submita memo to the department of health andhuman servicesin support of acredential standard that could beadopted by either the public or theprivate sectorwe also think that they could advocatefor a nationwide set of clear technicaland ethical standards that would serveoutdoorsville citizensand the united states citizens morebroadlylet’s talk a little bit about thecontext in which we’re workingi think we can all agree that thecontext changes daily on this issuegiven the uncertainty around so muchrelated to vaccinesand the vaccine passports we have toconsider that herd immunity is not acertainty through the vaccine presidencyand the lifespan of the virus isundetermined at this pointperhaps making the case for a moreassertive advocacy for a federalgovernment-guided vaccine credentialvirus variants are proving to be wildcards as one epidemiologist at johnshopkins that we interviewed notedthe variants are moving the goalpostsfor her immunityagain these recent developments and ourfindings about her immunity andwhether or not we’ll even get thereindicate that a vaccine credential maybe more necessarythan we had previously thought at thebeginning of this projectthere are multiple emerging vaccinetechnologies that are being developedall over the world these vaccines havediffering efficaciesand they also may have differentdurabilitiestravelers to the state of outdoorsvillecould come from any of those locationsbuilding a credential system of dubiousvalue is potentially expensiveuh private industry is already workingon a vaccine credentialour recommendations are practicable byprivate industry orpublic implementation numerousjurisdictionsstates etc several federal agenciesare initiating vaccine credentials aswell but the standards have not yet beenestablished and that’s where we come inpotential use cases could differ bycountry statecounty city and local businesses alsowith different tolerances for assumedrisk forspecific constituencies and finallythere’s a little proof that a vaccinecredential system will actually reducethe risk of code of 19 transmissionin outdoorsvilleso the first item that we arerecommending is a memoto the department of health and humanservices to advocatefor a federal credential standardfederal guidance could mean that statesadopt similar protocolsand can enjoy consistency across statebordersthe specific technical and ethical andequity requirementsthat we’re suggesting that could beissued by the department of health andhuman serviceswould mean that any system would begrounded in best practicesi’m now going to turn it over to mycolleague tonythanks elizabeth i’ll first walk youthrough the technical criteria that wethink outdoorsvilleshould advocate to be included in thecredential standardas a threshold matter we recommendsetting the standard for immunity to besuch that credential holdersuh have been inoculated with vaccinesthat both protect the individual fromthe virusand prevent this better probate toothers next slidenow what are the technical requirementswe recommend that outdoorsville stronglyadvocate for our standard that promotesinteroperability acrossdifferent credential systems this isespecially important to outdoorsvillegiven the state’s economic interest inleisure and business travelwe recommend that the credential bebuilt around a web-based technicalstandardthat allows for the use of readilyavailable software stacksany such system should also comply withfda guidelinesaround electronic records as well ashipaawe also recommend that these standardscomply with and are interoperable withinternational standards to facilitateinternational traveland lastly as table stakes anyassociated mobile apps should be madeavailableon both android and ios next slideuh we also think that the standardshould be should be future looking andso thereforeinclude guidelines regarding metadatarelated to an individual’s vaccinationsthat we think might be useful in thefutureuh to the extent that any such system isbuiltaround an immunization informationsystem on the back end that systemshould maintain metadata aroundwhen the user was vaccinated in casethis information becomes usefuland actionable as we learn more aboutcovid about vaccine efficacy and aboutthe mutation of new strainsthis would also mean that the systemshould be able to distinguish betweendifferent types of vaccinesincluding their relative efficacyagainst emerging variantsnext slidewe also think that the system shouldadhere to best practices regardingsecurityat a minimum the system should supportuh the transport layer security protocoluh any personal data that needs to becollected should be secured securelyand encrypted on both the device and intransitthe standard should call for a cleardata access frameworkto be adopted that only grants theminimum amount of access needed tocomplete a particular functionalso we want to make sure the credentialholders clearly understand theconditions that they use the credentialso transparency is a must uh next slidei’m going to shift to ethicalrequirements for starters datacollection should be opt-inwith users maintaining control overtheir personal datathis would also mean that if they wantto leave the system they should be ableto delete their data from theimmunization information systemthis nature of opt-in should apply tocommercial entities as wellnext slide we acknowledge that accessand adoption may still be adverselyimpacted by existing societalinequalitiesthe federal standards should avoidapplications that might inadvertentlywiden that gapso in other words uh the system shouldnot be used to restrict access toessential servicesit should all be invented injurisdictions where the vaccine isavailable to everyoneand we’re getting very close toachieving that already uhthe solution should be affordable forcis for individuals and governments toimplementin general you want to avoiddiscrimination and exacerbating existinginequalities such as vaccine presidencyin certain groupsor adversely impacting pregnant women orother groups that areunable to uh um gain access to thesystem currentlynext slide uh very briefly offlinefunctionality the system should beportable to allow for non-mobile usersto provide either paper copies or someother flexible formatyou can’t require someone to have aniphone in a data plan just to buygroceriesuh next slide the standard shouldencourage implementations that adhere todata minimization principlesso only collect the minimum amount ofdata and store it for the minimum amountof timeto maintain efficacy there’s no need totrack unnecessary dataor use third-party tracking ordependenciesand uh lastly the federal standardsshould require state levelimplementationof a digital immunity credential to bebuilt using open sourcethis should apply to both theapplication and on the server endand i included we included this as anethical issue because using open sourcewill promote transparencyand agenda trust it also prevents vendorlock-inand lastly we would benefit fromcrowdsourcing identification and fixingof vulnerabilities and addingimprovementsand next slide that is it on behalf ofour group it’s been a privilege toparticipate in the telly programthank you uh to the coordinators foryour feedback and guidance and supporti’ll hand it back over to mine who willintroduce the next groupthanks so much elizabeth tony and to therest of your teamfor your work on advocating for federalstandards for vaccine credentialsum to the audience members i also wantto remind you that if you have anyquestions for our leaders please putthem in the q a boxat the bottom of the screen we’ll get toquestions for all of the teams at theend of this webinarand if you also look at the chat you’llsee a link to the first teams productsnext i’m thrilled to introduce the nextfive telly leaders on the second teamfor this afternoonthis second team includes jason bachbots a fractional executive to multipletech companies and a board member to thenorth carolina department of commercececilia marahart director of businessarchitecture at splunkrebecca gasser the cio and vp of it atferrandino and sun where she works tomodernizethe company’s tech landscape enriquejenkinsan it leader focused on strategy andexecution and current head of it atdoordashand gene yoon a tech product leaderstartup execventure capitalist lawyer and nowcandidate for the california statesenatefor this presentation we’ll have enriquejenkins and cecilia mara hart presentingover to use enrique and ceciliagood afternoon everyone and thank youfor the opportunity to share ourproposal todayuh i am cecilia marahart i’ll presentour plan and then enriquewill share a demo at the endso next slide pleaseevery state in the nation as you as weknow is has been working to navigatethis ever-changing environmentand the guidance related to covet 19. sowhen we were considering how to advisethe state we looked at a variety ofoptionsfrom across the spectrum from do nothingtodo everything and build their ownstandalone solutionto even something in between next slidepleasesince the state already has a reputationas a leader in creating and deployingtechnology and service to its citizenswe believe that the correct solution forwould be for the stateto take a more middle-of-the-roadapproach and create an open framework torespond to the current needs and lay thefoundation for future needstherefore next slide pleaseour recommendation is for outdoorsvilleto leverage the systemsapplications uh and processes arealready in placeuh programs that are already in flightand extend those with aneye on the equitable and inclusiveaccess for underserved citizenswe feel that this approach would be themost effective from a cost and timesaving perspectiveespecially since the alternative wouldbe to buy or build new solutionswhich would be prohibitive next slidepleaseas i mentioned there’s already quite abit of infrastructure already in placethis diagram is meant to illustrate ourunderstanding of the current systems andsolutions and the myriad of stakeholderswith an interest in accessing itenhancements or modifications would beneededto enable this open framework forcitizens and other stakeholders toaccess their informationand while this looks a little bitcomplicated the solutions for citizensare meant to be asfrictionless as possible so what doesthat really look likenext slide please today the majority ofcitizens have smartphones approximately85as per a pew research study uh fieldedearlier this yearthus we believe that most ofoutdoorsville’s citizens would be ableto access their personal vaccine statusvia the already available myoutdoorsville appbut what does that mean for theremaining 15 percentthis is where we propose using acitizen’s idwith the scannable barcode on the backand they can either use their currentstate id which does have this barcodeor the real ids that are being advocatedby the department of homeland securityuh as the state may know and and mayhave already experienced uhthis is a program that dhs is is reallypushing the adoption ofconsistently across the country again weenvisioned thatthe state would be able to leverage anexisting government appa version of which is already being usedby state troopers todayand extend the access to that appto businesses especially venues thestate would obviouslyneed to approve access to the app andperhaps tie that to business license oruse some other methodso that they can verify that access tothe app and the system supporting itis used for the appropriate purposeswith thislayered on a component we believe thatyou might be able to cover about 97of your student of your citizens what dowe do about the final three percentthoughum you still have people who wouldpotentially be uncoveredso here’s where it gets a little bitless optimalless technological you’re really lookingat ananalog solution here where you’re eitherlooking at the paper cdc cards that aregiven out when you receive your vaccineor what happens if they lose those cardswell the stop gap for that would be awebsitethat where people could access theirinformation and print out that scannableqr codethat qr code again would be scannable bythe government version of the appthat that’s already being used today butwith extended to businessesuh who could be approved for access nextslide pleasepulling it all together though obviouslyit still has to be knit together with anopen apiand so that was that’s what wouldbasically pull all of it together andmake it possible for the solutionsdescribed on the previous slide to existnext slide please however we can do allthe workin the world to build those connectionsacross systems and processesbut it won’t actually work unless wehave robust outreach to the generalpublicunless we engage key leaders at thestate and county levels and then finallywork with communitypartners who can create awareness andadoption specifically with thoseunderserved citizens withouteasy access to technology you can learnmore about these plansplease take a look at the website all ofthese materials have been made availableonlineuh so finally we’ve covered quite a bitof grounduh in the last couple minutes so just tosummarize uh the solutionthis solution really is meant to be atemplate not only forthe current covid situation but also forfuture instances whereaccess to vaccine information might benecessaryso don’t buy or build instead enable andextendleverage those current programs systemsapplications and processes that arealready in place you will need to layerin and establish an open and secureframework with api accessto all the data repositories and thenaugment all of that witha robust outreach and advocacy programto make sure that we’re getting to thoseunderserved communitiesthank you so much for the time with thati will turn it over to enriqueto show you a demothank you cecilia let me get my demoready up hereall right good afternoon everybody soi’m going to highlight a veryvery brief version of our demonstrationtoshow you and highlight one of the areaswhich we’ve talked about so as you seehere in the bottom left cornerthat little orange icon is the app iconfor themy audio application and just be mindfulthat we made some assumptions here howthe workflow will work the appalready exists we’re just adding afunctionality or feature into thatso with any phone or mobile app you willlog into the appyou’re going to go through the actualauthentication flow you can log in addto your credentialsand then we’re going to get us here tothis page here this exists alreadythe amount of me the my outdoorapplication already existsbut i want to highlight the my vaccinerecord function here so hereto highlight what we’re talking about iswe have the function for the citizen toaddcurrent past future vaccines hereif you see on the right hand columnthere’s a privacy toggle there which youcan actually showto any kind of institution which youwant to share i’ll demonstrate that in amomentbut this vaccine record page is tohighlightthe current expiring overdue vaccinesrecords which you want to share as acitizenyou can actually go and enact your copy19 vaccine tetanus measles influenzawhatever you want to have it’s on theend user with a citizen to do soif you click in here to one of theactual vaccine recordscover 18 you can demonstrate the actionprovider the date of the vaccination thelocationthe vendor the market et cetera etcetera you can share with someone aswell on the fly with that big greencheck markand as i mentioned earlier that mydigital vaccine kind ofqr code this is a scannable verifiableresource for you to share with whateverinstitution you’re working withso as i highlighted before if you wantto turn that on and turn that offthat’s actually what’s added to thisrecord hereadditionally there’s some other featureswhich will be highlighted to intensifythe platform to add some news headlinesas your profile features here as wellbut we’re not getting the details ofthat for nowwe want to focus on the vaccine recordsand so with that that concludes ourdemonstration i want to thank you foryour time todayand my back to yougreat thank you so much cecilia enriqueand to the rest of your team members forfor your demo and for your innovativeand implementable idea ofof creating an open api system um iespecially appreciate this idea becauseyou all have thought about equity inproviding an optionfor those who might not have access tostate issue ids so thank you for thatnext i’m excited to introduce our thirdand last team for the afternoonthis last team includes anjali joshium an engineering and product leaderwith the long track record of scalingnew technologies and advising startupsphil marshall a physician entrepreneurreimagining personalized health carethrough tech at conversaretina sorry paulie a health tech leaderimproving clinical outcomes with ai andmachine learningas the global director of data scienceat ge healthcarejeremy tobin a product leader andentrepreneur working at the intersectionof tech and media at warner mediaand nevin zimmerman a long-time tech andbusiness executive who is the ceo andfounder of uber techfor this presentation we’ll have philmarshall and jeremy tobin presentingover to you phil and jeremyall right thank you mai it’s a pleasureto be talking with you todaygo ahead and share my screen as my saidi’m a physician myself and so this wasan excitingchallenge to tackle and so wecharacterized the challengethis way and that is that if the stateof outdoorsville would like to minimizetheincidence of coven 19 in theirpopulation and keep the communities safeand increase confidence among thepopulation to get back to work schooland attend gatherings eventsand now that mask requirements havechanged forvaccinated individuals is verifiablevaccine credential solution going tohelp themto achieve that objective and if sowhat is it and how can it be implementedand if not then why not and what shouldbe done instead and so that ishow we have recast slightly thechallenge and soum just up front we’ll go through alittle bit of backgrounduh information and key learningshopefully it won’t be too repetitiveum but of course we started with whatwhat is it what is a vaccine credentialuh the credential or passport is a wayto provide proof of code vaccinationstatusand it can either be non-verifiable umsuch as the cdc card or it can beverifiablesuch as what a qr code might be able toafforduh it might be used by event organizersbusinesses schools or othersto make sure of the individual’svaccination statusnow a couple of other key learnings thatwe in our team have had um it’sobviously become controversial and ninestates have already prohibitedprohibited the vaccine credentialswhilst two states have already embracedthemunfortunately the federal governmentwill not be providing a vaccinecredential as states andvaccine providers are the ones with thedata to provide such credentialand frankly which was an interestinglearning some states don’t even storeenough information to provide them ifthey want touh we don’t believe that you are in thatsituationum so several countries are developingthese for traveland technical standards are emerging forbeing able to do thisprivately and securely such as the workdone by the vaccine credentialinitiativeand so the cdc card to start therethat is a form of a credential of courseit’s easily spoofableeven though it’s quite easy to use andon top of that if outdoorsville were toprovide a state-sponsored online portalto allow access to one’s own vaccinehistorythe advantages would be that that’sright in line with hipaa’sposition that citizens have rights totheir own health databut of course that in and of itself isnot verifiable eitherand so as we go one step further i’mgoing to turn it over to my colleaguejeremythank you phil so we want to establishthat these are thefour what we call pillars of having averifiablevaccine credential and when i go througheach four let’s be cleara signed credential means it’s thedigital equivalent of a signature pageit’s digitally been tracked at all timesso in other wordswe consider it a prerequisite thatwhatever the proposed system we makecan securely confirm a givenindividual’s vaccination statuspoint two we assert that the opportunityper sefor a vaccine credential system existssomewhere betweena minimum state where everybody couldget a vaccineand sort of an end state where herdimmunity or some other equivalenthas made it irrelevant to even have avaccination status to show to anyonethe third point our concern here is thathow might different groups andcommunities be adverselyimpacted by such a system and what arethe unintended consequenceswhich tend to emerge through a lot oftechnology solutionsadditionally we do recognize that theimpact could bequite significant for non-residentscollege students people who work in thetransportation industry such as truckdrivers and pilotsas well as business and leisuretravelers and finally point fourfrom our research we believe thegreatest opportunity to implement thissystemis by a voluntary is voluntary by opt-inbased organizationsbecause the implications for enforcementand policing such a systemwould be non-trivial to say the least solet’s move on into our solutionnext likely okay great putting all theabove and playwe’ve taken a slightly differentapproach to our recommendation we’representing this as a multi-stepdecision-making process rather than onespecific outcomeso considering the rapidly changinglandscape we’re discussingwe think that having it as a process isa bettersolution for the state of doorsvillethan a fixed solutionmany of us in the technology industrywould call this an agile style solutionso the three steps we look at are a misthe necessity necessity and feasibilityof a solutionand if past how we might implement it solet’s dive into that in more detailsnext slide please thank you in order tobest serve the residents ofoutdoorsvillewe’re going to consider the followingone can everyone who wantsone get the vaccine if we cannot offerto those in needwe cannot mandate its use in any way twois there a sufficient market demand ifthis were a product or enough people outthere to buy itare business owners and organizationsasking the state to do thisthree do we think of this as low hangingfruit or a huge uphillbattle we might argue if this were afacebook relationship statusthe answer is it’s complicated and forone of our most important considerationsdo we truly provide a tangible benefitby creating and offering such a systemso far our recommendation to the stateof outdoorsville is that all four ofthese criteriacriteria must be met and from our team’sresearch we do not believe they have yetbeen metbut just to continue down the path let’ssee what we would do in step twoonce we have reached that status sotechnical feasibilitycan we do it in short from our findingsthe current answer is nothe state’s immunization informationsystem does not currently provide accessfor all the state’s residents to createor access accountsso if you think of an analogy like thedmv couldn’t exist onlineby offering say renewal license orregistration without a basicweb experience user registration recoverpasswords etca similar underlying secure system mustbe built forvaccine credential retrieval it is worthnoting we do not believe that buildingsuch an infrastructure is a highlycomplicated task in the modern techlandscapebut we do consider a minimum requirementfor implementingsuch a system i’m going to hand it backover now to phil to talk through how ourrecommendationsuh go from here yeah so taking thedecision tree one step further then ifthoseuh and when those first two steps wouldbetrue then step three would beviable and and that is um to preparefor offering a verifiable credential andsowe believe that there are certain basicstandards that must be met a person musthave their own agency to opt intoparticipationminimize the data that’s displayed onthe credentialprevent any third parties from storingany unnecessary dataand the data in the vaccine credentialsshould be used for proving vaccinestatus and that’s allum and so as we take that then one stepfurther and look at a few featuresum opt in we’ve already mentioned whichalso means the ability for a person toopt out at any timeand then the ability to download thatcredential um such as what you mightfind in a qr code that could thenwork to independently verify thatperson’s statuswhich could be stored as an image itcould be printable at homeit might be an app there’s a number ofways to do thatum and this is an example of thatum and so a qr code could be generatedfor the vaccine credential off of thestate systemafter meeting the prior requirementsthat jeremy mentionedum and wouldn’t have to involve passingidentifiable information to any thirdpartyum and so it would connect in with realtime in the into the registryuh the advantages are that it would beindependently verifiable that verifiableuh credentialand signed by the registry umdisadvantages arethat whoever is scanning it would needto be connectedum and we put a little mock up there foryou for outdoorsvilleuh and so with that um hopefully thatprovides you some food forthought um we’re greatly appreciativefor being able towork on this project with you and so iwill turn it backover to minethanks so much uh to phil jeremy and therest of this third team uh for yourcreative idea of asking states to pass aseries of testsbefore implementing a digital credentiali especially appreciate as jeremy saidthe agileness of this solutionas well so next i’m thrilled to announcethe keynote speaker for our event sidharrellsid is a long time civic technologistand user researcher who has spent hercareer helping governments maketechnology workbetter for their constituents and staffshe was previously chief of staffof 18f the us government digitalservices agencyshe is also author of a civictechnologist practice guidean onboarding guide and survival manualfor civic technologistssid thank you so much for being herewith us today and sharing your thoughtson these projects andon more generally the importance ofbringing diverse tech perspectives intocritical decisions like theseover to you sid thank you so much my i’mhonored to be here and to be able tohear all of theseexcellent ideas to the teamsthank you and congratulations i’m veryimpressed with how you engage with whatmay bethe hottest government tech issue sincehealthcare.govand one in which there are just anabsolute myriad of considerationsto think about um a couple of things ipulled in particular from yourpresentationum tony’s idea that you can’t requirepeople to have an iphoneto buy groceriesand i appreciated that the first teamreally engaged with us from a standardsperspectiveand an idea that we want a unifiedenvironment across the countryteam two in particular umhad for me a design approach and i alsoan apidesign approach in addition to a digitaldesign approach umthe use of the existing app thatoutdoorsville had i’m curious about theuptake numbers on that butit sounded like there’s already amajority umand i was very curious to see in thefinal prototype the potential expansionsto things like flu shotsthat meshes very well into what teamthree did about a decision tree becauseit’s an interesting question whether wewould putthe burden of vaccine verification onpeople for a less deadly and morecommon disease like the fluand finally team three which i feltengaged very much from a productmanagement perspective and i reallyappreciate your clear and luciddefinition of non-verifiable versusverifiable for your clientas well as the potential utility ofthis credential in the space whereeveryone has access and we haven’t yetreached herd immunityso i wanted to kind of recap for thelarger groupwhere we are this week as a couple ofthe teams notedthings are shifting incredibly quicklysojust this week near my home chase centerthe nba arenahas started a vaccinated seating sectionwhen they’re asking people to showtheir cdc card which is thenon-verifiable credentialum that’s interesting for a couple ofreasonsdoesn’t sound like a giant equity issuein thatit’s not an essential service to attendan nba gamebut it does already bring up somequestions for people here can i bring mykidwho isn’t eligible yet for vaccinationand is this appropriate forother types of environments we’ve had alot of grocery stores in response to therecent cdc announcementsaying they’re dropping mass mandatesand we don’t yet have a vaccineverification and sowhat does that mean as far aswho should be in a grocery store and howsafe people should feelin a grocery store and would having averifiable credential increase thatum the 85 smartphone availabilityin outdoorsville is high and that seemsgreatum i wanted to call out in particularpartly because my teenagerum would be very upset with me if ididn’t that umkids are part of the world of who isgoing to need toshow their vaccine credentials inour our situation here umsmartphone use for u.s kids may behigher in outdoorsville but it’s around70at age 12. best data i could find andum use of state ids i believe isprobably lower than that in many cases70 year olds also have lower smartphoneuse so i’m kind of envisioningthe scenario if we had really highrequirements for these we might need avaccine credential to enter a restaurantand that doesn’t just mean a sit-downrestaurant that as a matter of policywill usually meanthe local fast food joint or the localcoffee shopum so you know grandma and the middleschooler headout for an after school cup of boba orcookie what do they need to do and isthat reasonable to ask of themto be able to participate in that aspectof public lifeso umone of the things i’ll say to the to theleaders newly considering enteringuh public sector um and with so much ofmy thanks is that having done it for awhileum those of us who who joingovernment agencies or or otherwiseparticipate in this sector often getpermission to askawkward questions and one of myfavorites from the product managementworldis really really why are we doing thisand how are we going to know that it’sworking or not workingi think and several of you came prettyclose to stating it especially inthe second last slide from team threeif doing whatever the vaccine credentialis doesn’t increase public safetythen outdoorsville shouldn’t do itand figuring out how to answer thequestion of does it increase publicsafety orin what circumstances would it increasepublic safetyis something i would love to see leadersworking with their partners and clientson from those rigorous productmanagement perspectivesand some of the other ones that youbring inum i started adding to this sentence tosay well okay if it doesn’t increasepublic secsafety equitably as so many folksmentionedwe have you know equity of access notjust to smartphones but to printersequity of access to data plansthere’s also the question of who tendsto get asked for their credentials morethan other people in these lovelyunited states umdoes this actually increase publicsafety over and abovea less burdensome program like these cdccardsand uh i thought you know showing thecdc cardsthey are fakeable but it takes a bit ofworkthey are potentially being sold and thatsounds likea real problem but i don’t knowand i think if i were in a stategovernment i would want to ask myepidemiological staff to help me figureoutwhat’s the impact if some credentialsare fakedand what’s the impact depending on wherewe are in the process of achieving lowcommunity spreadand um and vaccineuptake within the population umif one percent ofcards are fake how much does thatactually decrease the public safetyin say a grocery store what about at aparade what about at a stadiumand then we have the idea that at a costthatis worth the amount of increase that webuy to public safetyand again that is more than just a sortof safety theaterwhere people who can easily access averifiable credentialfeel safer whileour safety is not accruing as much maybeto more vulnerable populationswho don’t have as much access towhatever technical mechanism we’re usingtodisplay and create credentialsthe time period when it matters iappreciated so much what jeremy saidabout there’s a space between everyonehaving access andus reaching herd immunity where thatmakes senseand my mind actually went right back tothe age situation there whereright now just about everyone over 12theoretically has access although thatmay not be as truein a practical sense and we’re lookingat hopefully by fall we may seeelementary school kids having accessi think it’s actually going to be quitean interesting question for policymakershow to include youth and childrenin these calculations of who needs tohave access in order for it to beethicalfor this to exist children um alsobeing less likely to have smartphonesbeing worse atcarrying around pieces of paper areinteresting to design something likethis for if it’s something that needs tobe shown frequencyfrequently you might think thatmuch like with a passport and a veryyoung child you can add a kid toa vaccine credential but kids overabout nine or ten circulate around inthe world and takepublic transportation another activitywhich is a really interesting questionfor whether you would restrict it tovaccinated peopleum so i i think that considering themis one of those interesting cases ofdesigning for a difficult caseand helping figure out what weshould do but i think umvery rightly um the decision tree builtby team threeand the team ones memo to the fedsasking the feds to set some of thesestandardsfor weather outdoorsvilleshould do it umand umgetting a little deeper on questions umhow do we figure outif this increases public safety enoughumwhat settings would we need to use it infor it to meaningfully change safetyis it every time we enter a building orget on a busum is it only reallythose kinds of situations like the startof a school year or the beginning of anew job or going to an airport that arealreadymarked um and where wewould um now already present some kindsof credentials where it wouldn’t be thatmuch of an extra burdenum i also really agreed with team two’seventual integrationof this credential with state idsthose have their own access issues butthis if this is something that we needover a space of multiple years ordecades it probablyshould somehow be integrated intoexisting idsystems rather than being a fullyseparate itemeverybody talked about this beingvoluntary and opt-in and i’m reallycurious how many peoplewould need to sign on for it in orderfor for it to really be effective andincreasingour public health safety and securityand a piece of that question is againhow much does the fraud matter andthere’s been some interestingexplorations of new york’s excelsiorpass which is this blockchain-based onethatit it is actually fakeableif you are savvy umbut uh the question of how many peoplewould try how hard to fake itum is one that i don’t have a goodanswer to but i think it’s onethat requires at least a an estimatedanswerum from the kinds of social scientistswho work on perhaps voting fraud andthings like that in order toshore up a key piece of the data in thedecision systemand absolutely the question of whencould this be sunsettedi think this is an important questionfor almost anytech intervention in government but umi don’t think and i didn’t hear anybodyrecommend certainly and i wouldn’trecommend to outdoors billthe idea of setting up a sort ofperpetual expectation that we shareimmunity data multiple times a day inorder to participate in public lifeum that doesn’t soundeasily like something i want to say weshould commit to and so we should thinkabout how do we stop ourselves fromdoing thatum how do we stop ourselves fromum you know what happened after 9 11when we started displaying americanflagsand there wasn’t a set end to the periodof warning and so we saw people’s flagsget tattered and sort of stay out therehow do we have those conditions alreadyin placewhere we stop using the system whenwe’re ready to be done with itand so um all of theseideas that i think all three teams haveoutlined will be necessary for thefictional state of outdoorsvillein deciding what the best thing is to doon behalf of its residents andconstituentsbut i think the teams have done anenormous amount to illuminateuh what outdoorsville should look at andhow difficultthis question is for every stategovernmentin understanding how best to invest itstax money its staff timeand its burden on citizens andincreasingpublic safety with a novel disease likethisso thank you again to the teams andthank you to telly and aspen and thankyouto all of you for being herethank you so much sid for those wordsand for responding to our team’sprojectsi especially appreciated how much youyou connected these projects to thingsthat are happening in real timeuh this project was especiallychallenging as uh as you mentionedstates and private institutions werechanging their guidance on a on adaily basis while our leaders wereworking on this so i really appreciatedthatthat tie into what what you know thecdc’s announcement just last weekum next to all of our attendees we’regonna spend a few minutes on q a so justa reminder that you can enter somequestionsin in the q a box below umand i will have my first question be forsid while i have you here umso in some ways this conversation aboutvaccine credentials and digital vaccinecredentialsuh intersects far more with ethicspoliticspeople’s perception of privacy thannecessarily it does with technologyum why do why do you think it’simportant for technologistsuh to be part of these somewhatpolitical conversationsthat’s a great question um i think it’simportant to engage with them withhumilitybut technologists alsobring a number of disciplines thatengage with similar questionsin very concrete ways from thedevelopment of tech products that engagewithyou know impact on users um uhimpact to wider communities um and and ithink that theyou know we we bring this particularskill in identifyingthose kinds of impacts and translatingthose into concrete actionsum we also often carry into thegovernment spacea certain kind of privilege becauseeverybody thinks technologists arereally smarti don’t personally claim that um butwhat we can do with thatsometimes is put forward things that canbe hard for other people in the space tosayand uh i have never worked on agovernment technology project that wasmostly about the technologyso this ends up being one of the mostimportant places to engagewonderful thank you so much sid um mynext question is forthe first team elizabeth and tony um sowe’ve had a coupleof comments in the q a box talking abouthowvaccine credentials at a state level aredifficult to implement because peopletravel in and out of statesum and yours was the only solution thatreally talked about a federalum solution um so i’m curious why notask the federal government to actuallydevelop this type of credential ratherthan advocatinguh for them to establish a set ofstandardssure so um we actually talked offlineaboutthis very question and uhhonestly our first uh proposal was thatthe federal governmentshould do this we then got signal fromthe federal government that they werenot going to do thisand so we changed course um we also andi think it’s in that umanswer and tony may be able to speak toit better we haveuh there’s a more technical um reason aswell that another team member providedi don’t know tony if you have anyadditional thoughts on thatsure uh you know our our colleague lodnahad also done some thinking about thisshe wasn’t able to stick around for therest of the uh the session but as sheput in the chatum the some of the some of the feedbackthat we received when we were looking atthis at the federal government levelwas um i guess some just broaderconcerns arounduh holding the health health relatedpersonal data of citizens at the federallevelsomething that really just hasn’thappened before and so there might bejust some broader policy implicationsassociated withwith developing that so you know frommargaret’s perspectiveyes there was a certainly a benefit toum adopting a uniform standard andmanaging it centrally butexcept that there wasn’t really anappetite uh to take on a problem thatlargebut i think the next best solution wethought the next best solution was toencourage the um the release of astandardthat would that you know jurisdictionscould uh iterate on and use the baselineif they wanted to innovate on top ofthatthey could as long as these baselinestandardsof interoperability and the like weremet umand perhaps it’s no different from whatyou see with umdifferent states having various versionsof easy paths that allow forinvulnerability you can still jump upand down the turnpikeum even though each state has their ownsystem and keeps data separatelygreat thanks so much elizabeth and tonyin team oneum a question for team two for sicilianenriqueum why did you decide to to connect thisvaccine credential system to the statedatabase of driver’s licensesare you concerned about the privacyimplications of this design choiceso thank you for the questioni think what we looked at was you knowideally what you want to do is be ableto leverage the systemsand technology that are already in placeand leverage those connectionsthe idea was that you’re only accessingthe components to verify that the personwho is in front of you that this isactually them and that that is theiractual vaccine statusbut that the ability to actually seeanything more than thatwould would be limited and that issomething that thethe state and i would assume inconsultation withall the various stakeholders woulddecide how much or how little to showand that citizens would have quite avoice in thatdoes that answer the question enrique doyou have anythingelse you’d like to add no that waspretty spot-onso great thanks so much team twoum for team three for jeremy and phil uhhave youconsidered methodologies that serve theunvaccinated in your solutionso could there be consideration for theinclusion of unvaccinated individualswho carry a certain level of immunity orantibodies um if they’re testedyou want to do this one year we go philuh why don’t you start go aheadsure so if you think about our approachby being a decision treeuh and one of our sections there washaving the needs of all of theresidents as well as potentiallyvisitors or pastors throughuh being met we would probably arguethat that would be part of that decisionprocess such thatwhen it comes time to issuing that hasbeen accounted forso whether that’s some kind of bypassstep oror antibodies identification i think forus it’s less prescriptive that this isexactly how it gets doled out as opposedtohow it gets authorized at allgreat thanks so much team three um andthis is a question that i have forfor all of the teams in for sid so we’llwe’ll giveeach team a chance to respond um so ifyou have one key takeaway for stategovernments that are grapplingwith this question what would it be umso we’ll startwith team three and then go backwards toteam one and then to sidjeremy do you want to uh give a go withthati i think and it was what sid referencedand i think even my reference in ourpresentation i thinkwe fundamentally believe that the moregovernments at the state federal anylevelcan approach things with agility bereconsideringuh the situation as it’s changing rightin six months we’ll be having thisdiscussion and talking more aboutvariants and boosters and other issuessoi think my strongest recommendation isdon’t decide nowwhat’s going to happen next year look atwhat you need to do now for today andfor tomorrowand then have the next step ready to gowhen that hitsgreat thanks jeremy thank you team twoi think if it was one key takeaway uhwe really wanted to acknowledge andhonor the amount of workand infrastructure that already was inexistenceuh for the state and um and not proposedsolutions thatthat didn’t already take advantage of itand honor that andand really i mean i think the word forme was always amplifyhow do we amplify what’s alreadyhappening and expand upon that andleverage thatas opposed to reinventing the wheel andand so i think our solution certainlyspeaks to that and i think the otherteam’s solutions also do as wellgreat thanks team two team oneyes so i would just say um i thinkthat after all of this uh i still thinkthat advocating fora set of standardsis the way to go and that is becausewe’ve come this farwith our passport look where we arewith reopening and i think the focus nowneeds toinstead be on addressing vaccineevidencegreat thanks team one and sidum i think you know always the questionofwould something something simpler workjust as welland finally the the really big one washow would we know it was workingum and and those are questions that willrarely guide you wrongeven though i don’t not sharing ananswer with you right nowgreat thanks so much sid um and thanksso much to all the teamsum as we close this afternoon i wantedto thank everyone for the teams and thespeakers for theiroutstanding work on these projects as imentioned before thethe fact that they were able to producethese ideas during a part-time programin just a few weeks when things werechanging daily really gives us a glimpseinto what’s possible when youpartner civil service leaders withmodern technical experts to improvepublic policy umbefore we close the afternoon i alsowant to take a moment to thank everyonewho made this specific event possiblethis includes our amazing tele staffmaeha alawaliaour director at the hub betsy coopercass madison and along with anyone whomentored and supported the teams as theyconducted research on their projectsum i’d also like to thank the keynotesid harrell and of course the teleleadersthemselves for all the work you all havedone um we hope you all will join usnext week for the last and final of ourtele demonstration dayswell we where we’ll be releasing threemore projects from our tele programthe event will be on tuesday may 25th at4 pm pacific time7 pm eastern we’ll be releasing threeprojects focused on helping governmentscitygovernments think through how tech canbe used to expedite covet 19 reliefopportunities for small businesses whohave struggledquite a bit during the pandemic um theevent will be keynoted by tarlyn graydirector of the office of the smallbusiness advocate for the state ofcaliforniawe’ve pasted the registration link forthat webinar in the chat and hope you’lljoin us for that sessionthanks again for joining us thisafternoonyou
As more people across the country receive COVID-19 vaccines, there is a growing interest from businesses, schools, and other entities in a mechanism to confirm individuals’ vaccination status before they access areas and services. Groups have proposed a variety of solutions, from digital versions of physical vaccine cards administered by healthcare organizations or private entities to government-issued “health passports.” State-managed digital vaccine credential systems bring up a myriad of privacy, security, ethical questions. Should states create digital vaccine credentials given the widespread implications of doing so?
On May 18th, the leaders of the Aspen Tech Policy Hub and Tech Talent Project’s Winter 2021 Tech Executive Leadership Initiative Cohort showcased their projects focused on ‘Considering the Merits of a COVID-19 Vaccine Credential.’ Following the presentations, Cyd Harrell, author of ‘A Civic Technologist’s Practice Guide,’ gave a keynote address.
THE BEST OF ASPEN DIGITAL, RIGHT IN YOUR INBOX.
Sign up for our email list to stay current on our work.