hi everybodywelcome my name is vivian schiller andi’m the executive director of aspendigital a program of the aspen institutewe’re really glad you could be with ustoday the new york times bestseller listcan often seem to be a mirror of thenational psycheand as such this year it seems toreflect a nation going throughan awakening on matters of race bookswritten by people of color and aboutmatters of race and racism havefilled those lists both fiction andnon-fictionthat’s the good news sadly thepublishing industry does not necessarilyalways reflect that realitythe recent twitter protests hashtagpublishing paid meexposed the major pay disparity in theindustry between black and non-blackauthorsthere are few people of color who serveas publishing staff or literary agentsand even fewer who operate atdecision-making levelsand for those who are publishedsometimes the marketing exposure can besub-optimaland this as in this year of nationalreckoning on racismwe’re going to take a look at the bookindustry the book publishing industryand whether it can bring more racialdiversity to the fieldthis is part of our changing thenarrative seriesuh which that looks at issues of racethrough the media we had one programon the news media and we have upcominganother programabout the entertainment entertainmentindustry we explore the challengesbut importantly we also look at the newpossibilitiesin this case for employing andpublishing more booksby and about people of colorso i’m about to introduce our panel andthen our moderator for today but beforei do just a reminderum this is a live program um you aregoing to hear a conversationuh among our moderator and ourfantastic panelists but then later inthe hour we’re going to takeyour questions so if you look down atthe bottom of your screen you can see alittle button that says q aat any time starting now you can clickon that button andenter your question we would ask uh thatyou add your name and your affiliationif you’re comfortable doing soit just adds a little more uh texture toand context for the questionswe will then curate those questions andprovide those toour wonderful moderator who will thenpose them toour panelists so again anytime justclick on itstarting starting now now let me introintroduce our panelists and so we canget started uh we have with us uh reginabrooks the founder and president ofserendipity literary agencybased in brooklyn her agent hasrepresented and established a diversebase of award-winning clientsin adult and young adult fictionnon-fiction and children’s literaturenicole dennis ben is the author of herecomes the suna new york times notable book of theyear and a 2017 lambda literary awardwinnerher best-selling second novel patsy is a2020 lambda literary award winner a newyork times editor’s choiceof financial times critic choicesstonewall book awards honor book and oncountlessum best book of the year listslisa lucas has been the executivedirector of the national book foundationand is the incoming senior vicepresident and publisherof pantheon and shogun books prior tojoining the foundationlisa served as the publisher of guernicaa non-profit online magazine focusing onwriting that explores the intersectionof arts and politics with aninternational and diverse focuswe have with us also errol mcdonald thevice presidentand executive editor in the double daydivision of penguin random house wherehe has worked in variouseditorial capacities for more than threedecadesamong the distinguished authors he haspublished are jack henry abbott jamesbaldwin count basie atala calvino henrylewis gatesfran leibowitz tony morrison and manymany moreand finally i’m so pleased to introducemy colleague and the moderator for todayadrian broder she is the uhhead of executive director of aspenwordsuh she is also the author of the memoirwild game which is in development for afilmduring her 15 years in the publishingindustry adrian founded the litter aliterary magazine withfilmmaker francis ford coppola was anacquiring editorharcourt and hmh books and served as ajudge for the national book awardsamong other literary contests she’s beenpublished far and widein magazines she’s been with aspen since2013aspen words is a literary artsnon-profit program of the aspeninstitutewhich includes the aspen words literaryprizewe are so pleased to have you with usadrianmy beloved colleague and so i turn itover to you and to the otherpanelists thank you so much vivienne forthat introduction and thank you to theaspen words and aspen digital teams forhosting this eventand to all of you our panelists and toall of youwho are zooming in today for yourinterest in changing the narrativesomething long overdue in the publishingindustryas an fyi to all of you watching thisgroup metyesterday um to have a little pregameconversationand we decided that as much as possibleum we’d like to make thisa forward-thinking solution-drivenconversationso in other words while we’re not goingto sugarcoat any of the factsor gloss over the historical situationssurrounding the racial inequalities thatexist in publishingwe’re not we’re also not going to spendtoo much timerestating and rehashing the obvious theobvious beingone the publishing industry has alwaysbeenpredominantly white 76 according toa recent survey and that figures queueshigherwhen it comes to the highest positionsin the industryand two that are as a result of thatpower structure and the fact that whitepeoplehave been the primary arbiters ofliterary cultureblack writers and other writers of colorhave had a harder time getting publishedthere are of course other issuescultural appropriation disparitiesin pay that vivian mentioned in the umwhat publishing paid me a twittertwitter protest um so we’re gonna havelots and lots to talk aboutuh but before we dive into theconversation it feelsimportant to acknowledge that i am awhite woman and i’m surehave blind spots in terms of my ownprivilege and i’m working hardto become more self-aware as we all needto do at this timebut with that let’s beginum as all of us on this call knowwe are lucky enough to work in one ofthe most fascinatingexciting wonderful industries publishingthe world of literature and storytellingand lettersand what i’d like to start with is sortof um with you talking about what drewyou to the literary worldand what the publishing industry needsto donow to open up opportunities to peopleof colorand regina i thought we’d start with youand maybe you’d beable to talk a little bit about yourexperience at howard university pressbook publishing institutesure thank you so much for having me i’mso excited to be on this panelum you know when i think about thegenesis of how istarted in publishing it was veryserendipitous andi guess that’s the name of my companyserendipity literary agency um i have abackground in engineering uhas an aerospace engineer and i had thissummeroff and i said well i was gonna takethis publishing programat howard university uh and it reallychanged my lifeand changed my world upside down uh i’vealways had kind of a backgroundinterest and i said background butbackground interest in booksi was just uh interviewed probably abouta week agoand i was trying to think like goshregina you’ve always been a person whogoes to the library you’ve all there wasa library right around the corner frommy houseand um i realized that i asked my mom togo upstairs and she found thisum it was a certificate that i hadactually givenjames baldwin an award soi’ve always been a part of thepublishing space or booksbut i ended up at the howard universitypublishing institute and that instituteno longer exists today i think it wasalmost 27 years agoand that’s how i was introduced to thepublishingmarketplace as an engineer i started outworking for john wiley and sons and istarted in salesand then eventually they moved me to newyork and i became an editorand i worked as an editor in theengineering disciplines ummechanical chemical electrical butit’s so funny because again justthinking back to the genesisthere are two people that i met at thatpublishing institutewho are still in the business today andone of them is a business partner nowso one was marie brown she was aliterary agentum she and i have our own imprint calledopen lens nowum and also i met cheryl hudsonshe’s a publisher with her husband wadeand theyagain still are in the business and sothere’s something to be saidabout the longevity of beingin the business as a black personthere’s also something to be said aboutthe fundamentals that were learned atthat publishing institutelike i said howard university publishinginstitute no longer exists todaybut when i think about what kind ofthings could the industry doto really bring more people into thebusinessand also sustain them and i think thatit would be an awesome ideato um re-invigoratethat institute there are still there areother institutes that exist like thedenver institute colombia i think has aprogramalso nyu but i think thatnumerous publishers today are trying tofigure out how do we get tothe talent how do we get to the talentand there’s no bigger and better way todo thatthan to have the institute again and andi did readum just today that in publishingperspectives that harpercollins echoin partnership with cynthia dupreesweeney created a publishing diversityfellowshipwhich is new i believe as part of the uhcolumbia publishing coursebut you know that’s still that’s still asmaller a smaller organization than theone that you’re talking about it alsoreally segues nicely to something lisawas mentioning yesterday which wasreally about the bounty ofjobs and publishing that we don’t reallynecessarily all know are there withoutsome kind of education in the fieldbecause i think most of us think writerseditors okay that’s it and do you wantto talk at all about that lisayeah i mean i think that um i was jokingyesterday when we had a little pre-callthat if somebody told me thata job like being a literary scoutexisted i probably would have been aliterary scout since it sounded likeyou know as a 28 year old i was likewait what what did i missbut i think that it’s a complicatedindustry and i think i’m still learningyou know i didn’t start working atliterary magazines until i was 33and so i really came from outside of theindustry although i’ve been within itsince thenand it was a real education and all thethings that no one had told meand i think that we have to be thinkingabout diversifying the industry ofcoursewith decision makers and executivesand publishers and editors but we alsoneed to think about our marketingfolks and think about our publicityfolks and think about designand legal at hr and all of the thingsthat actually go intoand sales um there are so many piecesevery bookyou know you see the book and it has acolophon and uhan imprint uh and it has a title of anauthor and you thinkyou know whoa this person made this bookbut it takes an actualenormous team to make a lot of thesebooks sing andif you don’t have diversity at everylevel you know you don’t have the checksand balances that prevent embarrassingthis steps from happeningyou don’t have a diversity of you knowinformation aboutwhere there are challenges whether it’snhr it’s in the blind spots are allthroughout and so i think that we dofocus on the authors and on the editorsand i think that we have to be thinkingreally broadly about what anentire team that makes a book possibleor an imprint possible or publishing howit’s possibleor the agent’s representation regina isso important right you need people whounderstand the challenges and so youhave to really educate people about whatbooks are i think that sometimesi used to work in film and i think oneof our jobs was to work with teenagersand they were all interested in becomingin film becoming filmmakers and i thinkthe mostimportant thing we did was to demystifywhat it looked like to articulatebelow the line jobs as well as what itmeant to be a director or aneditor or a producer right so thatpeople really had an understanding ofwhat was happening and and there’swe’re very happy to sort of seem like wemake magic i think everyone who makesart is like oh my magicalyou know art form that i work in and noone could ever figure out what we doyou know and that all you know obscuresyou know that there are roles for peopleto filland that there are job trajectories andi think that you know we’rea parent of a child might not supportthem if they want to go be anauthor or go be an editor they mightreally understand what it means to bein hr in a huge corporateway to to work in the arts with a lawdegree or whatever it is i mean i thinkthat it goes from a high to low doesn’tmatter whether you’re talking about ajobinside of a warehouse or you’re talkingabout a job at the top top you knowthinking about operations or sales ormarketing or what have you i think thatwe really have to you know starteducating people about what publishingand the whole literary field includingliterary nonprofitsneeds to look like for it to beequitable in some way and to bereflective of the society that weactually live in because we are tellingthose stories and i think we think aboutonly the art and the art is first butthere’s so muchthat has to happen for that art to liveand we need to educate people aboutthose as wellthose roles that’s my thought on thatthat’s so important and then maybe wecan turn to the artistto nicole and um ask you sort of whatyour career journey was like and was ithard for you to find tractionin the industry in the beginning findingan agent uman editor all that with your first novelum definitely it was a challenge and youknow just thinking aboutwhat lisa had just me um said you knowthis demystifying the industryum i had i knew nothing about theindustry you know i’m i’m coming from apublic healthmedical background um and so of courseas afirst generation immigrant you were toldthat that’s what you ought to dobut yes i knew i always wanted to be awriter i didn’t have any avenueswhatsoever did not know any writersgrowing upespecially writers of color or blackwriters period so when i came toum to the us and of course after collegeandgrad school that was when i got into thewhole like what it was an mfa programandyou know got into one and was surprisedthat i was like i’m one of two blackstudentsin that program um long story shortwe’re told that getting agents were thehardest thing and thinking that that’sactually the only hurdlethat you have to jump through um to getinto the realm of publishing and that’sfar from the truthum as lisa just mentioned you know youhave the editors that you have the wholehouse that you have to sellall those things um so it took me awhileum you know i submitted that first bookum because i got the right personthought i got somebody who wasinterested that person ended up tellingmeum to take out the jamaican pathway outof my book becausea woman in michigan would never read mybooks and understand what i’m talkingabout andbeing a young writer i thought that wasthe end-all and beyond i thought thati had to do that in order to besuccessful so i didum and of course reading my book i itdidn’t feel like mineluckily i had a mentor marita golden andshe was the head ofperson right um where i had a fellowshipand she told me you know nicolelet this one go you know um as a writerit’s gonna be it’s a part of the game toget rejectionsso go back to the drawing board get onthe umon the computer and just submit queryletters to agents so that’sthat’s what i ended up doing i ended upactually writing a whole new bookactuallyum and resubmitting to agents and so ofcourseum i went down an alphabetical orderfrom poets and writers databaseand you know um a couple weeks later igot hits from three agents and i was sohappythat um julie bear happened to be one ofthem with who i fell in love withbecauseone thing i was looking um that ofcourse my mentoragain very important to have mentors onething that maria said to me is that youknow what your agent is it’s like arelationshipyou know a lot of young writers outthere would latch on to the agentbecause ohyou know that’s that’s what you’re toldthat you ought to get to be successfulbut it’s important to have somebody whogets your work and especially as a blackwriter a black immigrant writer as wellum tapping into a very very dark issuesum you know sexuality um all thesethings you know the person has to get itto sell the book welland you know i had that um the luck ofhaving that happen you know um julie sawmy book umbut the thing is that not manypublishing houses were latching on to itum here comes the sun was a hard sellyou know umyou know in in fact what the onlypublisher that latched on to the bookwas katie um adamsfrom um liveright from norton liverightum you know because i was gettingmessages like oh it’s too commercial oroh we don’t understand why a young blackgirl is bleaching her skinlike what is that you know and so iguess again you knowin terms of um diversifying umpublishingi feel like if i had other more um moreblack editors perhapsin houses um who are looking at the workand say oh yeah you know we get that weknow we understand the importance oftackling colorism you know um or attackor see the other side of this so-calledparadise that people seebut as oh bob marley and all thesethings but i was actually getting deeperinto the um who we arebehind the fantasy and i feel likenobody got thatexcept for one woman who happens to bewhite and um or two women who happen tobe whiteuh but you know so the also the eastergets the importance of alliesas well um but what one thing thathappened in 2020 that i was really happyaboutgiven that my foot is in the door i gottaxi out and peoplelove patsy was that you know lisa iscoming on nowas you know you know here she is uh inher new positionthere’s um dana kennedy and there’s uhhere ariel mcdonald’sis sitting here in this channel reginabrooks and i felt like you know but theyoung me did not knowthese people you know the young the onlycall coming out of the mlp program knewnothing about thatum but no it’s more um we’re more inthis realm where we’re nohere on this level um these individualsare nowplaced in higher positions and iinterviewed dana kennedy two weeks agofor zora magazine and she said to me youknow the change has to happen from thetop you know um yes i know it has totrickle down but the top is where ithappensfirst you know and so i honestly believethat and i’m so i’m so happy that she’snowsitting at that top and now looking atthe little umyou know people mfa persons or eveni forget mfa you’re a writer coming intothe gameyou know you could see you could seeyourself in on the page i know that youcan do it as wellyou can achieve that because there arepeople behind those closed doors who arealso rooting for youand so that’s really where i’m comingfrom rightnow thank you and errol you’veobviously been in the industry for sometime 40 yearsum why is the industry been so very slowto diversify andwhat other initiatives need to bedevelopedto sort of achieve greater inclusivitywell um there’s so much fake news outthere about publishing in general andpublishers have done such a lousy jobaccounting for and describing theindustry that i don’t know where tostartlet me begin by simply saying that toconflatepublishing with literary publishing perseis a non-starter because publishing isa huge universe of categoriesthat most people don’t pay attention tothe press is mostly interested inliterary and commercial fiction but ithink publisherscan increase diversity and inclusionby um advertising jobsin a multiplicity of categoriesand a multiplicity of functions um so iecho whatlisa says thatalong every aspect of the publishingchainum we should think about itreflecting america reflecting howamerica looksand right now the emphasis is strictlyonum decision makers and that should notbeif it’s going to be on decision makersit should be on decision makersin publicity in marketing in salesand then the book selling communityyeah no that’s that’s umit’s a very true and it and it is such aan enormous industry umi’d like to for a moment sort of turntowards thethe very current moment we’re existingin and i think it is i think we canagree that it’s sort of a unique momentin time or a special moment right nowthat in recent weeks um black authorsincluding isabelle wilkerson rickbennettibrahim khande kendy and michellealexander amongst many othershave surged to the top of the bestsellerlistand i know we wish all of us we wishthat this moment hadn’t been brought onby this racial reckoningthat took place in the aftermath of themurders of innocent black peoplegeorge floyd brianna taylor ahmed aubrybut does this moment actually feeldifferentto you and maybe errol we can just keepgoing with youis this does it still feel like i meando you think this one’s gonna last doesit feel like a moment and what can whiteand black publishing professionals do tosort of continue to sustainrecognition of authors of color so it’snot just sort of a blip that that windsdownit is a moment and i don’t believe it’san inflectionin the history of publishing um oneremembers thatbooks by black writers were hugelypopularin the 60s and 70s in the umduring the civil rights movement and umduring the black power movement um soand that went away okay right nowwe’re at a moment where um the narrativeis still being definedto a certain degree bypeople in power so that those booksthat are on the bestseller list aretheremostly to educate whites okaywhites have taken on um these books asif they were a self-help programum i believe that interest in thesebooks willattenuate but i do think thattheir appearance on the bestseller listhasincreased interest in acquiring morebooks like thoseamong publishersyeah okay um and then reginawhy do you think that black stories sortofhave been riskier bets recently thanwhite stories i’m talking in the moredistant but recent pastand you know like this isn’t how itworks in the music industry for instancewhatwhat can we do from your perspective orfrom the literary agent’s perspective tocontinue to change thiswhoops you’re on mutesorry about that now i was just sayingwow that’s a big question um there are anumber of different ways that i canapproachanswering that question i think thefirst thing echoes back to what was saidbeforeis it’s very difficult forpeople to penetrate the marketplaceif there is a lack of understanding ofthe contentso as a literary agent one of the thingsthat i’ve consistently askededitors is if you know that there’s anaudience for a bookand you know that um the book is goingto sellbut the book is not necessarilysomething that you would read or youwould go pick up in the bookstorewould you acquire that book and moreoften than noteditors say well if it doesn’t resonatewith meand it’s not a book that i feel like ican truly championthen i’m not the best editor for thatbookso there’s a true understanding from anagent and editor standpointwhy they may say that but that is a bighurdlebecause most of the people again thatarein these positions of power to makedecisionsare white and that doesn’t mean thatwhite people can’t enjoybooks that are written by people ofcolor butgenerally speaking the the people thatthey doraise up and and buy books fromare celebrities that are people of colorright and so that is one bigobstacle so it starts in an editorialsideyeah the other thing that i hear too isthe fact thateven if they were interested in buyingthe bookunderstanding how to position the bookonce itis acquired that’s a big issue and whatwe what do we mean by positionmeaning how do we get it out into themarketplace so thatthe audience that is going to beinterested in this bookactually knows about itand this is both in the children’s youngadult adultmarketplace all of these all of the thedifferent areas within publishingdo we have issues andagain staffing issues so if there werepeople in the salesdepartment people in marketing people inpublicity that were people of colorthere could be a lot more understandingof how that those books could bepositionedright i was just on a call today andi’ll make this quick i was just on acall todaywhere i was talking to a marketingdirector and explaining thati’m okay at this point that you don’tknow how to position this bookbut i’m here to stand in the gap yeah ihave my fingeron the pulse of certain communities andi want you touse me as an ally to help position someof these booksand but there aren’t a lot of peoplelike mefirst of all agents typically don’t helpwith marketing rightand then yeah right and then the secondthing is when they dothe the structure is not set up to allowagents to have that kind ofaccess to the marketing department topublicity departmentsit’s bailey with the editors so forinstance nicole since you had a solidlywhiteteam as i understand it right marketingpublicityum sales etc who washelping you with that gap i mean did youhave someone help in this second roundyou know with patsy where you hadi mean both of your books have been verysuccessful but you know was theresomething did you have the equivalent ofregina to guide you through some of thatyeah i my agent also did that as well umsomehow she stepped into that gap but myi had a really great publicist michaeltitans who umyou know miraculously i mean he has hispulse i feel like he had his um fingerson all the poles andlike this time around especially withpatsy when more people knew who i wasafter here comes the sun um i felt likei sawmore folks um coming on board so wherehere comes the sun for exampleyou know it wasn’t on any essence listorum you know i was like you know where’swhere’s ebony where’s essencepaxi fell on those lists right um thepockets that i wantedmy book to also hit um as well as thejamaicans whoum who i wanted to read the book as wellthey they also got paxiand i think that was you know for me umi think it was audiobook i think thatdid that because i had a jamaicanum actress who read the audiobook andthen i had um thisall these um these the hits from jamaicaand saying oh my gosh we have to get thebook as well soall those things happen i think you knowmultiple multiple factorsum came into play and i was really happythat all the stars were alignedi mean it’s the publicity of the twobooks that’s great i actually did listento your book too and it was wonderfulreadingum so lisa in terms of you like you’veyou’ve obviously been credited withrevitalizing the national book award andbook foundation and its annual award andi think in 2008 um authors of colorsweptall five categories is that right 20082018. sorry oh yeahabout a decade to your work there um butwhat was thewhy do you think there’s the disconnectbetween the recognitionand the perception of marketability forauthors of colorwell i mean i think back to a point thatearl made earlier which is if you reallywant to facilitate changeat the top you need to think aboutmarketing and you need to think aboutpublicityright and so functionally the nationalbook awardsis a publicity wing of books right likewe make noise about bookswe try to serve readers we are notpublisher facing we are notauthor facing we are reader facing rightand we are audience facing and so ourjob is to really widen the audience forbooks right that’s what we have workedto do and i think that that’s about theway that webuild our panels the way that we presentour show who we have as hoststhe different programs that we dowhether or not we’re giving books toyoung people and families in publichousingor doing middle school programs foryoung readersor we’re selecting books about massincarceration and coming up withyou know interesting ways to get peopleto read those books so they know moreabout the carceral systemum in this country you know these areall ways to connect reader and bookum and i think that you know ultimatelyone of the reasons why we see some ofthe problems that we seeis about a failure to imagine adifferent or new audienceand i think that the foundation isnimble enoughand small enough um that we can do thatreally easilyright you know i can get a new job andsay i think we can reach a biggeraudience andsomebody will put me on the news and ican say that and a funder will give ussome money and we can just flexiblystart doing that new programum and it’s not as difficult toimplement change i think on thepublishing side where i have not yetbeen but willsoon go it’s gonna be soon yeah soon imean i think one of the things is likeit you know there seems like such aresistance of people in publishingliterary publishing as errol pointed outvery wiselyyou know to think of what we sell is acomma the thing a commodity like we aremaking a transaction between consumerand sellerand if you were apple right and yousaid you know it just seems like blackpeople just don’t like the ipad so we’rejustyou know we’re not going to sell themipads right so we’re just going to focuson who likes ipadsand to sell them ipads and you know withan everincreasing black population we’re justgoing to throw that money in the garbageand sayyou know not worth it they don’t likeipads and that feelsto me like a bit of what publishing hasdoneit said we know that black folks willbuy this kind of bookthat can guarantee us a sale andeverything else ah it’s never gonnahappenso you know maybe there’s a shot in thepan or flash in the pani’m the worst at making metaphors but umthere’s a flash in the penyou know or whatever the expression isumyou know and this happened to be a bigbest seller but never will it everhappen again so let’s just move on andgo back to sellingyour grandma in iowa a book because weknow she’ll buy it but the question forme is how did we get your grandma andiowa to love bookshow did we get her to know that she’sgoing to like a very specific kind ofbook that’s market research that’sinvestment that’s building the audiencethat’s working on howto ensure that a community isconsistently well served and that weinvolve our business to continueserving that cash cow that is thatparticular demographic segment ofamericaand in our continued refusal to actuallyconsider that we mightseek market share by doing moreinnovative business i think that we dothe greatest disservice we couldpossibly doto all of our black and browncommunities in america to our ruralcommunities in americayou know two audiences you know i thinkthat we reallyoften fail on that front and i thinkthat that’s just to me the thing that ijust keep coming back down to which islike do we like to sell things yes or nodo we want to sell more things yes or noare there more peoplewho have demonstrated again and againthat we over index on all culturalconsumptionand do we want to sell them things yesor nodo we like stories we people of color inamerica yeswe love film we love podcasts we lovetelevision we love books tooyou know and how do you transfer thatactual factualinformation into sales of a productand that insofar as i understand it isour joband i think that you know if we’re justthe continuation to sort of you knowwe’re talking earlier about all thesebooks falling off the bestseller listour job is to keep them on thebestseller listto continue pumping things into thereadingpopulation that actually doesn’t facethe white gays consistentlywe need to adjust our critical apparatuswe need to talk about the fact thatthereare very few black book sellers very fewlatino book sellers very fewindigenous book sellers very fewbookstores and communitiesthat serve these communities and so whatdo you do with that it’s like the wholething is structured to look only atwhite people and it’s a big big shipand you have to really systematicallylook at wherethose points are where we arecontinually failingand adjust not just for equity not justfor justice but like at the verybaseline most cynical level for moneyyeahyeah do any of the rest of you want toadd something to what lisa just saidit’s so fascinatingi want to focus on the um the books thathave been on the bestseller listthese books on race and racismbecause even those books which aredescribed the so-called black booksare in fact addressed to white readersokay i haven’t seen a lot of blackpeople with how to be an anti-raciston subways when it came out okayi’ll see a lot of black people readingwhite fragilityokay so we have to understand thatpublishers need to broadentheir understanding of what booksmatter to black peopleno no absolutely anyone elseand i’d argue that we have to as acountry decide that blackpeople matter before we can decide thatblack folks deserve good culture i meanit’s just the exclusionaryhistory you know it is suppression it’sit’si think the thing is we use thislanguage that is so softnot even i mean even in harsh languageit’s still so soft this is culturalsuppressionyou know there was the article that cameout about the criterion collection thisyear and the conclusion of only fourfilmmakers that were black two of themliving you know inin since the 1980s in an enormouscollection of the best filmson planet earth right and it’s likethe fact that those books have not beencan’t those books those filmshave not been canonized right have notbeen given the same treatment meaningthatwe are excluded from what is consideredthe bestyou know and it’s like and that that issuppression that is you know when youthink aboutyou know julie dash and daughters of thedust not to go up on the film tangentyou think about just another girl on theirt and you think aboutyou know so many of spike lee’s filmsand you think about all of theseyou know all of these incredible thingsthat have shaped black cultureand shaped black thought on the filmside and their actual exclusion itdisincentivizes participation right youdon’t you know you can’t win so why playyou know it it fails to educate theamerican populationright it just there’s so but at the endwhat it doesis suppress our voices our real voicesif we are not saying something thatspeaks tothis gatekeeper then it is not of valueand that person is able to articulatewhat value is through cultureto everyone and then we become devaluedso i think thedangerous nature of this sort of thing ithink that’s the thing that people don’tunderstandi think that even people who are makingthese decisions don’t understandit’s not just an equal it’s notjust unjust it is also a violencedone to people who live in this countryyeahof all kinds and i mean that might beslightly off tangent but it’s just likei just feel sort of like you know wehave to really understand thatfoundationabout you know sort of being cynicalabout whetherwhat black people will read you knowand and and and artificiallymanufacturing a cultural landscapethat suppresses the real black voicein so many different instances is partof what is destroying our countrywould you talk a little bit oh sorry goaheadyeah um i was just gonna say you knowit’s interesting that um errol is herebecause you knowi was going to say tony morrison broughtme to literatureand you know um there were tons of timesagain i’d watch her uminterviews or uh read um her essays andyou know she always said you know do notwrite for the white gays you know writeyour storiesand write it true to heart and i feellike you know what errol just said aboutthe kinds of books that make best on thelist you know it’s like teaching whitepeopleand um you know i remember talking to afriend of mine you know becauseyou know even though patsy and herecomes the sun they where they werecritically acclaimedum i didn’t get any awards like i meanapart from lambdaand you know it wasn’t like a bestsellerlike a runoff like new york timesbestseller soi was like lamenting about that once youknow i mean you’re humanso i was like oh my gosh that’sinteresting and you know what she saidto me she’s likewhat would tony morrison say and i waslike why don’t you say she’ll shedoesn’t give a right because you’re an artist youstay true to that art form and noti’m not understood your head down andright and so i think that’s veryimportant but at the same time i dounderstand that yesyou know when i look up and i do seethat the books on the list you know i doseethat pattern in a sense of okay soum you know it’s i mean i mean i love ilove um most of the people who are onthat list you know their friends arecolleagues of minebut yes when you do look at the um theissues that that’s that’s written aboutit tends to have that element in thereand so i wouldn’t have even really giventhat that much thoughtuntil that um um ariel just said what hesaid but i doi do think it’s it’s a lot of pressureon the artist sometimes especially ifyou’re a young artistand you’re wondering i get this questionall the time on panels you know sowhat if we’re writing and nobody wantsto read what we write you knowi’ll always tell them just continuepushing continue writingand you know stay far from discussionslike this one i meanthis is a great discussion but you knowyou don’t want to worry ahead like whatpeople are going to latch on to justright um until i guess i guess from myperspective as an artistum you know if any other artists are islistening to this conversation justwrite let’s hope thatno um there are people in place thereare gatekeepers in place that’s nowgoing gonna hopefully listen um to whatwe have to sayyeah well i i’m glad you’re part of thisconversationum and before i realize that we’regetting close to wantingto turn it over to the umaudience q a but i just i wanted to umask one last question as sort of astalwart optimist and i’d like to knowyou know what does give you hope aboutthe industry these days and are therethings that really arei mean i think you’ve mentioned some butare looking up that you feel hopefulaboutand that any of you can chime in on welli’ll sayone of the things that i’m reallyexcited about isum i’m a part of i’m on the board of theassociation of author representativesam i on mute no i’m here i’m on theboard of the association of authorrepresentativesand um we are doing quite a bit to tryto bring more people of colorinto the agenting world because there’sthethere are the gatekeepers within thepublishing housesbut also in order to get into most ofthese mainstream publishing houses youdo need an agentand a lot of times for people of colorit can be difficult gettingan agent and just being an agent is avery difficult thing toobecause of the way the business model isset upso not too many people of colorare able to live in new york cityunfortunately that’s shiftingum and be in a umwhere their salary is set up based onyou eat what you killso as eight as an agent i get 15of the monies that my authors getfor an advance and that’s my commissionand so you mentioned earlier thepublishing paid me hashtagso as an agent if i’m working withclients thatare black i mean i have a combinationbut if i’m working with black authorswho arewhose work is being devalued andwe’re getting only a small percentageit’s a very difficultum business to be in but there’s a lotof changesthat are um being addressed in thatmarket that part of the businessand i’m super excited to be at the umuh one of the people who was helping tomake some of those shiftsso thank you yeah anyone elseyeah one of one of the things thatexcites me orthere are two things that excite me oneis thatthere appears to be a generational shiftinthe publishing industry i was reallyheartened by theattempted insurrection by some youngpeoplerecently in them making certain demandsof publishers and i think umi think it’s not unhealthy that anolder generation which adhered tocertain narratives i don’t think it’sunhealthythat that generation might be dying outi’d agree i would say that i think thething that gives me the most optimism isnot necessarilythe older generation leaving but the newgeneration coming ini mean it’s like i think you know and ithink i sit you know i’m20 years into a career you knowhopefullya while left to go you know so kind ofhappily in the middleum but you look at but i came up the wayi came upi had to change the way that i spoke ordressed or acted orwhat i said and the things that iaccepted you know that i feel ashamed ofnowyou know in many cases you know they’regrowing up believing this to beunacceptablethe narrative is different for them thethe the larger landscapeis different for them and so even thingsthat i as a pretty outspokenenraged person feel and think and dothey are so much more radical than icould ever dream of beingand i just can’t wait you know and ithink that that’syou know the thing that i can give youknow is toyou know i’ve had many mentors um manyof them from the old guard you know ilost one who was more of a model than arole model than a technical mentor butyou knowum to to try and really seek out youngpeople who can change thisyou know i can and to give them whateverinformation or contextyou know or contacts i have to empowerthem so that as they stageyou know their great shake-up of thecultural world that they have all thetools they could possibly have and youknow what at one pointthey’re gonna say lisa you’re tooconservative you’re not doing enoughyou’re not changing fast enough and iwelcome ityou know because they deserve the powerto actually be able to make this world alittle bitmore just and um and i think thati grew up in a different world you knowi was born in 1980you know i went to high school in the90s and i think it must be so differentand still very frustrating in 2020 to bethat age but i think that we do have theopportunity to change a few things and ithink that the bookthe book i think that peoplehave demonstrated that they still valuethe book i wish more people didright but it’s like but people thinkabout the book the news cares about thebook againa little more than it did maybe 10 yearsago and i think that thatintersection of young people who careabout literature no namefor instance um the rapper from chicagowho’s incredible right who’s taking adeepdeep and profound interest in gettingbooks into prisons and to talking aboutanti-capitalist books anddoing a book club and really thinkingabout who we’re speaking toand you know being spoken to by you knowit’s like i want to seeyou know what that looks like and i’mjust really excited for thatfuture you know and it may not eveninclude me in the degree that iwould like it to and that’s okay well ithink we have a lot to thank the four ofyou for aboutuh the resurgence of the book umi am going to look at these questionsthat are inthe chat line and ask you some of theseso here we golibraries are part of the larger bookecosystem and collectively havehuge have significant buying power howcanlibrary staff advocate for and push forchangein the publishing industry how canlibrary staff advocate for and push forchangeoh same thing sorry in the publishingindustryany thoughts therei mean i think it’s the same role inmany ways as a bookseller do you knowwhat i mean you have a community ofpeople coming in who want to participatein the book right and so what yourshelves look like what you were what doyou werewhat you were buying many copies of howyou are presenting them the programsthat you run around those books thoseare all going to speak to how welcomesomeone is or isn’tin that space and i think that that’sthe place to start who is this space foryou know who are we creating thesespaces for and i think that when youactually design spaces withthe real community in mind and and areal openness to what that communitymight want to receive culturallyi think that you start a conversationyou know andi mean librarians are doing god’s work imean honestlyyou know so it’s like i don’t have awhole lot of like critique for thelibrary communityum on the diversity issue because it’slike that’s you know ground zerofor like where people go to get books soit’s like i love the librarians but ithink that you do walk into librariessometime and you say who was thislike set up for you know who did thisand then to continue to sort of like ifyou were a senior librarianlike nurture young staff you know andempower themyoung people know you know they knowmore than we give them credit for andgot to let them and they’re they areliving they are building a moreequitable world so i think that you knowsharing powerwhen you have two generations that aredoing two totally different are havingtwo different conversations about equityi think we have to allow young peoplewho are far more progressive on theseissuesyou know to to to riseto do things on their own independentlyand i think that that often buildsa lot of equity in spaces as well butyou know but again i love the librariesvery much and i don’t really have awhole lot to critiqueno and i think mentorship is just one ofthe big takeaways from this talk of allum we have another uh question fromerica turnipseed who’s a writerwhat other activism needs to happen inorder to throw back the curtain on theseother jobs within publishingi don’t know that there’s much to addbeyond what we’ve already said ordid you have something regina well i ireally dofeel like it would be super advantageoustohave and i don’t want to be redundantbut to create to do something with thepublishing institutebecause you can talk about all of thedifferentpositions that are available umwithin the industry i think that havingpeople come in and talk toyoung people about what opportunitiesexistis the main it’s a lot of it’s justaccess and knowledgeand being able to see it yeah i agreewith thatjust quickly quickly just quickly i wantto say look i’ve worked it and i’veworked at nonprofits for 19 years i havenever worked at a publisher right thatis not what i’vedone i still can’t make heads or tailsof who does whatat the cannot double day publishinggroup i’m trying to figure out at nightfrom the internet on zoom how manypeople work there who does what you knowwho works on which imprint and what andhow it all works together it’s totallyobscure like it’s totally opaque there’sno wayto figure it out from outside and iliterally have the jobyeah you know so so if i can’t figureoutwhat in the world then how would anyoneelse and then how do you even start toaddress those issues when there’s justabsolutely no transparency about howit works i mean it’s just like ii i am i’m i have to say that i was likea little bit flabbergasted like i’msorry who does whatwhere okay wait how does this work youknow it’s all very it’s likeit’s like that internally and externallylikehow long does it i mean how many timesdo i have to explain what a literaryagent actually doesright and then there are multiple waysthat literary agents approachthe business so it is it is very verynon-transparenti mean i tell you i’m like flabber ijust i’m speechless at justhow little i actually know and how hardit is to figure outyou know what like and it’s not becausepeople don’t want to tell you it’s notthat kind of thing it’s justit’s just very complex and there’snothing that you canread or download that’s going to be likeoh cool got it got it got it this isexactly how this work and these are thejobs and this iswhat needs to happen i think there anderrol made this point earlier that weneed toto really do a job of talking about whatour industry actually is yeahfor not just ourselves not just forfuture staff but just so that peopleknow how books are made they are tooimportant you know it’s like you knowdancelike dance organizations have classes inschools to explain what dances are thepeople imagineimagine if dance was like oh we’re likebooks and every childneeds us to learn how to readyou know we have such access this issuch a big part of everyone’s life andthe fact that theytruly are like these magical objectsthat we don’t really understand howthey’re made or where they come fromis really concerning and i think thatthatyou know that this but even withinpeople wanting to workbut even within the publishing industrywhen you if you were to ask fivedifferenteditors how do you do how do you build abookyou’re gonna get five different answersabsolutely i mean absolutely just inworking for different places i meanyeah design but some things are justfundamental that i think even that isreally challenging and i think that likewhy would you ever want to grow up andbe a book jacket designer if you don’tknowhow that works or that those jobs existyou know it’s difficult it sounds likewe should be inviting any of the bigfive publishers who are watching to umto support uh the reinvigoration ofhoward’s programwould be helpful all right um let meread another questionmichael julius e idani who’s an authorwhat can be done to make public pursuingpublishing careers accessible topassionateand talented first generation collegegraduates and those from working classbackgrounds who may also have tocontribute to supporting their familiesand it’sfrom he’s from the iowa white writersworkshop[Laughter]um i think that umthe industry is is going to be changingdramatically as a result of covet 19.i think it’s going to change in waysthat we can’t evenimagine i think working at home is goingto becomeprevalent for certain functions and ithinkthat might open the doorto some constituencies thatheretofore have not felt publishing tobe attractiveso um i don’t know thatdefinitive pronouncements can be maderight now abouthow to bring people in but i know i doknow that the industryis changing dramatically and peopleshould keep their eyes outkeep their eyes open for opportunityand in fact um because the pandemici have um a fellow who’s working infrom belgium and i also have someonewho’s in washington dcand i also have an agent right now who’sin um san diegoso i know that from an aging perspectivethere is definitely going to be muchmore openness to peopleworking remote and i’minternally building a system so that ican educatepeople about the agenting business andhow to become an agenteven if they’re not on siteyeah that that is great i feel like thisumyou know what we’ve learned from thissituation that we’re all figuring outhow to work in inother places than new york and lessexpensive places than new yorkum the final question is solong and very complicated and i i’vebeen reading it and still haven’t quitefound the questionso i think i’m going to go back tosomething that we talked about a littlebit yesterday which has to dowith language and the languagesurroundingsome of our goals of the goals inpublishing to be more inclusive and lisayou talked a little bit about it butbut a bit about the language ofsupremacy but about how tohow to make things more inclusive onthat particular levelis that something you’d want to speak imean i think it’s just like rightyou know lately i’ve been reading a lotabout the changing of the guard forobvious reasonsand you know and people talking aboutwhat we need to do in publishing andand um and and the wii that they areusing is not the way that it includes meyeah you know and i think that that islike i think that when we talk aboutyou know if we’re talking aboutamerica’s literatureright the world’s literature right andso when we are sayingus and them you know it’s up to us to dothis to make sure theyfeel this way this is there’s no thech we failed it’s over it’s like we’restill we still haven’t started theconversationyeah and i think that we have to learnhow to you knowon that level talk in language thatactuallyacknowledges that the table is shared asopposed to i’m going to give you a seatat my tableright right it is the table and we mustspeak about it as suchand then i think secondarily i thinkthat weindustry-wide because there isyou know a majority and a very smallminorityyou know that majority talks aboutbooks by the other you know as though itis the otherhow can you sell that how can you umyou’re not selling to another communitywe are all one communityand i just don’t understand you knowsome of the words that i hear or read inthe newspaper or that people say to mein discussions on panels and howothered i feel not because that myfeelings are hurt my feelings aren’thurt i’ve been called worseworse things have been said to me worsethings have been done to mebut because it just seems that the pointhas not been takenthis very loud very moral very clearpoint that has been made over and overand over and over againfor decades and the fact that we withour language betray that we still don’tunderstand the very fundamentalsof working in an us and them environmentmeans that you stillbelieve yourself to be supreme which youare in factnot yeah yeah i thinkwe have to appreciate this how the verylanguageof diversity and inclusion is itselfproblematic because it is it is a masternarrativeright who is doing the diversifying andwho is doing the including and for whatyeahbut what is more often left out of thatlanguageis one word which is equity okaydiversity inclusion and equityand publishers have had a hard time withthat e-wordyes absolutely i can’t find the lieas they say well i thinkthat is a wonderful note toend the questions on i think vivian isgoing to becoming back in um it’sfour o’clock but i want to thank you allso muchfor participating for lending yourvoices for being a part of thisdiscussionand um it’s been it’s been reallywonderfuland educational and helpful thank youthanks for having me thank you forhaving usthank you everyone that was such anincredibly powerful umconversation so uh lisa errol reginaand nicole thank you so much adrian andaspen wordsso grateful for your moderating i alsowant to thank dominique harrisonwho has designed these uhthis entire series about looking atmedia through the lens of race and ourproducer beth semelthe video we posted uh either latertonight or tomorrow you can find it onaspen at aspen digital we’ll have thelink on our our twitter accountand uh for those of you that registeredwe’ll also email it to youthank you so much everybody and we’llsee you next timeyou
Going off the New York Times best sellers list today, it’s obvious that fiction and nonfiction by Black authors are in demand. So why is the world of publishing so reluctant to offer Black writers the same major book deals typically offered to white writers? There are few people of color who serve as publishing staff or literary agents, and even fewer who operate at decision-making levels. The recent Twitter protest #PublishingPaidMe exposed the major pay disparities in the industry between Black and non-Black authors. As a result, Black writers struggle to receive the same marketing exposure, even as readers continue to find and demonstrate their enthusiasm for the titles that do get published.
How might the book publishing industry use this moment to bring more racial diversity to the field? As part two of our Changing the Narrative series, this program explores these challenges, as well as new possibilities for employing, and publishing more books by, people of color.
Speakers
Regina Brooks, Founder & President, Serendipity Literary Agency
Nicole Dennis-Benn, Award Winning Novelist, Author of Patsy
Lisa Lucas, Incoming Senior Vice President & Publisher, Pantheon and Schocken Books
Erroll McDonald, Vice President and Executive Editor, Knopf Doubleday Division, Penguin Random House
Adrienne Brodeur, Executive Director, Aspen Words, & Author of Wild Game
This is the second of three programs in our Changing the Narrative series, which looks at the construction and representation of race in journalism, book publishing, and entertainment. The first installment was Changing the Narrative: How News Media Covers Race in America.
{"includes":[{"object":"taxonomy","value":"135"}],"excludes":[{"object":"page","value":"145182"},{"object":"type","value":"callout"},{"object":"type","value":"form"},{"object":"type","value":"page"},{"object":"type","value":"article"},{"object":"type","value":"company"},{"object":"type","value":"person"},{"object":"type","value":"press"},{"object":"type","value":"report"},{"object":"type","value":"workstream"}],"order":[],"meta":"","rules":[],"property":"","details":["title"],"title":"Browse More Events","description":"","columns":2,"total":4,"filters":[],"filtering":[],"abilities":[],"action":"swipe","buttons":[],"pagination":[],"search":"","className":"random","sorts":[]}
Join us for the WIN Summit on October 22nd where private-sector leaders, investors, and philanthropic organizations and funders will gather to talk about the future of the workplace.
Join us for the AIDE Summit 2026 on September 9th where practitioners and leaders across state and local government, technology, private sector, civil society, volunteer organizations, community groups, and academia will gather to discuss the future of AI and emergency management.
September 9, 2026
THE BEST OF ASPEN DIGITAL, RIGHT IN YOUR INBOX.
Sign up for our email list to stay current on our work.