hello everybody thanks for joining us myname is Vivian Schiller I’m theexecutive director of Aspen digital weare a program of the Aspen Institute thepandemic has wrecked havoc on people’slives and livelihoods all over the worldalmost every industry is affected thenews industry is not immune in fact itwas a business model that was already indeep trouble we’re gonna talk about thata little bit later so the pandemic hasturned what was a crisis into what isnow pretty much a catastropheyes jobs are at stake tens of thousandsof journalists just since the pandemicbegan have been laid off furloughed orhad their salaries cut but it’s muchmore than thatevery one of those jobs represents arepresents a voice often in a newsdesert a voice that is providingcritical sometimes life-savinginformation to citizens around thecountry news to communities have hasnever been more important than it is nowbut the purpose of this hour is not todepress you but to look for solutionsand we are very lucky to be joined by ina really stellar panel all of them notjust journalists though they arejournalists but also leaders in thefields we will be joined by Elizabethgreen she’s the co-founder and CEO ofchalk beet and the co-founder and chairof the American journalism project withus also is Jack Wanda Johnson founderand publisher of Flint B in MichiganWendy Thomas editor of MLK 50 justicethrough journalism in Memphis and SteveWaldman who is president and co-founderof report for America in fact Steve isgoing to kick us off with some sort oflevel setting information to helpeverybody understand exactly what’sgoing on when it comes to journalismparticularly local journalism but butbefore I turn it over to Steve who’sgoing to join us in just about a secondI want to say a big thank you to the 9thdatian they are our co-presenters hereand they are of course as far as I’mconcerned the leading institution insupporting and advancing local news alittle bit of housekeeping before weagain before I turn it over to SteveSteve is going to give a littlepresentation and then we are going tohave a conversation among the panelistsand then a little bit later in the hourwe will be taking your questions if youlook down at the bottom of your screenyou will see a button that says QA soyou should click on that and then anytime starting right now you can drop inyour questions please add your name andyour affiliation if you are comfortabledoing so it gives some great context toto the conversation and also uhone last thing I want to apologize inadvance this is technology we are allcoming to you from our homes things gowrong things will go wrong so if we runinto any tech issues if there’s a freezeif somebody drops off just please hangin there with us and we will be backsoon so Steve let’s bring you onSteve Waldman coming to us from Brooklynthere he is just unmute ello Steve helloso so great I can’t wait to hear whatyou have to present so I’m gonna turn itover to you okay well this is Thank YouVivian for for hosting this this isreally well time because we are as yousaid in a in a deep crisis really anemergency and as you know two part ofthe problem is that the news industrywas already struggling mightily evenbefore kovat came along local newscoverage had been really decimated downby about half as you can see here thisis is this chart goes up to 2016 so itdoesn’t even really capture the last fewyears and doesn’t at all capture what’shappened in the last few months so youcan see the local reportstaffs have been cut dramatically in thelast decade and this is largely becausead revenue has been dropping soprecipitously that’s what that chart onthe left is it’s sometimes thought thatthe real crisis for local journalism hasbeen that readers have gone to theInternet that’s not really right thenews organizations are just as much onthe Internet as they are in printit’s that advertisers have gone to theinternet and specifically through theinternet platforms not through localmeet Organa media organizations so thathas just devastated the business modelsnews deserts as a result or spreadingthis is a term we didn’t use to hear weused to hear you know about the news orreporting not being adequate or missingneighborhoods or communities we’re nowhearing about entire communities andcounties not having any coverage at allthis image of the Denver Post newsroom Ithink is is probably one of the mostdramatic ones that was a photo that wastaken of them just in 2013 when they wonthe Pulitzer Prize for the coverage ofthe Aurora school shooting and the blacksilhouettes or everyone who has beenlaid off since then to give you a senseof what’s left in that newsroom some1,300 newspapers have been later beenclosed and in the last few years and 200counties have no newspaper at alla part of what this means is a hollowingout in the center of the country and aconcentration of the local media on thecoasts in New York DC and California soit’s really communities small mediumsized communities in the rest of thecountry that are are suffering as thenational media frankly is doing okay sowe were really just a breeze away fromthis this whole local news systemfalling down and we got a hurricaneinstead when Co good 19 hit now theirony here is that readership is up it’snot that people areturning to local news in this turretedquite the contrary readership andviewership is way up and that is provingthe value of local news and that youknow we always just to talk about theinformation health of communities sortof health as a metaphor like that youcan’t have a healthy community in aninformation sense if you didn’t havegood journalism and now we’re seeing ofcourse that it relates to the literalhealth of a community that you can’t getgood information about you know where toget groceries or we’re testing is or howstay at home orders are beingimplemented without local news and sothat’s why local news has beendramatically more important and yet atthe exact same time the business modelsof these local news organizations havegotten worseand it’s really just think about it allthe stories that you hear aboutbusinesses being closed or just seeingit on your own streets those businessesare also the advertisers for local newsorganizations and it’s not just thateven like nonprofit organizations aresuffering I’ll give you an example a lotof nonprofit local news organizationshad wisely said we need to be moreengaged in the community and they hadcounted on live events as an importantrevenue model and those live events haveall been cancelled so that’s hurt aswell so and it ripples through otherways to a lot of public radio stationsare part of universities that have beendevastated and have put in hiringfreezes philanthropic support is morefragile because they have so many otherthings to do and the stock market isdown so the the business models areacross the board and the generalthinking is that unlike an industry thatwas relatively healthy before thishappened and so it’s really harmful butit’ll bounce back that that the localnews industry is not in a position tobounce back I was already so weak in thefirst placeas maybeand said a total of 36 thousand workersat news companies have been laid offfurloughed or had their paved cutsanother thing that’s likely to happen asa result of this is more media mergerswhich was already a really worrisometrend even before Kovac came along so wereally need to be thinking indramatically different ways new businessmodels new government policy and reallyjust a new mindset mostly going to focuson the models and I put business modelsin quotes because people tend to thinkof that as meaning commercial mediacoming up with a new way of generatingmoney but it’s really broader than thatit also involves nonprofit newsorganizations coming up with models forsustainability well let’s start with thecommercial folks there had already beenbefore Co vid a shift among commercialmedia away from relying as much onadvertising and toward relying more onreaders to subscriptions that’s thesmart way to go and that is going tohave to continue as they also get morefacile with digital technology on thenonprofit side I want to spend a littlemore time on that we’re lucky enough tohave three of the stars of what is areally exciting new universe that someof you may not be aware of in the lastcouple years hundreds of new nonprofitlocal news websites have been born theyhave been created out of a sense fromjournalists and citizens in thecommunity that the traditional media wasnot covering important topics oftenbecause of the the cuts that hadhappened and it’s a really excitingdevelopment we need hundreds more andtheir organizations like Americanjournalism project and others that arehelping to fuel it so I would say it’san incipient trend but it’s really animportant one to understand as part ofthis new landscape public radio alsowhich is not new but there are a lot ofpublic radio stations that are divingdeeper into local reportinga lot of them had already been doinglocal programming like talk shows andcommunity work but in the face of thechanges more of them are realizing thatthey need to do reporting and boots onthe groundso that this is all a really positivedevelopment but we’re gonna need toreally step up our game in order to makesure that these entities survive andwhen I say step we I mean communitiesphilanthropy and government and then thelast model I want to mention is hybridsand this can mean collaborations betweencommercial and nonprofit media it can bea case where you know a non-profitwebsite that has great journalism butmaybe not a lot of reach is teaming upwith a TV station it has a lot of reachbut a small reporting staff and ofcourse the my interrupt this objectivepresentation for a an ad for a reportfor America my organization but this isan example of a hybrid report forAmerica started a few years ago it’s aninitiative of the ground truth projectand it’s a national service program thatplaces journalists in to local newsrooms around the country it’s actuallywe work with almost half commercial anda half nonprofit RFA pays half thesalary and then works with the localnewsroom to help raise the rest of themoney so it’s grounded in the communityand we’re we just announced we’replacing 225 reporters in the field at162 newsrooms in a few weeks so the goalis a thousand reporters in 2024 finallyand very briefly just government policyreally has to change and improve we arewe are really at a moment when we haveto be thinking much more creatively forinstance the government already spends abillion dollars on advertising forcensus military recruitment so how aboutif we had a billion dollars more forpublicThad’s haven’t had half of that gothrough local news that would be not abailout it would be something thegovernment needs to do anyway but itwould really help the local news systemand then finally just to say that thisthese specific ideas kind of all comeunder the category of a new mindset ofreally thinking of local journalism as apublic service I think most journalistsgot into it with that mindset but thethe business model problems have kind ofcrushed it out of us and in order toregain trust of communities we asjournalists have to be thinking ofjournalism as a public service therethere are ways that the community anddonors can help obviously buyingsubscriptions to local newspapers thatreally helps but it’s beyond that italso means that it means supportingnonprofits through donations and itmeans in general viewing the health of acommunity news organization as acommunity responsibility just in thesame way that a community would thinkabout a library or the public schools orthe symphony or the hospital systemthat’s the simple reality that is whenyou get past all the the complicateddiscussions about business models andwhat’s going to work and what’s notgoing to work we got very used to asystem where advertiser who areessentially floating a local new systemand the reality now is the communityjournalism is only going to survive ifit has the support of the communitythank youthanks so much that was that was thatwas a great grounding for theconversation that we’re gonna have forthe rest of the hour and reallyinformative thank you you know you and II don’t even know if you remember thisbut you and I first met about 10 yearsago now when you were doing a projectfor the FCC which ended up turning intowhat a pretty seminal report that wasreleased in 2011 about the crisis inlocal news again almost 10 years ago itwas called information needs ofcommunities looking back at what youexaminedand what you what you anticipated howhave things how have things played outthat surprised you well I would say wewere pretty alarmist in that in thatpublication and we were really I thinkthe first ones to say everyone wasworried about national media at thatpoint and our our big message wasactually the problem is gonna be on inlocal media local journalism and I’d saythings have gotten worse than expecteddespite the alarmism of that becauseeven back then there was a little bit ofsense of like okay things are bad butsome new models gonna come along somenew app is gonna be invented we can’tpredict the future of Technology somenew technological solution is gonnahappen and it hasn’t in fact thetechnology has worked in the otherdirection the more digital technology isimproved the more it is made it easierfor advertisers to not advertise inlocal media and so we are faced withwith a crisis that really requires us tothink in radically different ways thanwe were before yeah yeah it’s so true itand and and while we bring on the otherswe’re gonna bring everybody else on youknow to interesting comments about whatyou just said one is first of all hopingfor a miracle is not a great businessmodel it doesn’t work out very well butalso it’s interesting that at the timewe were so worried about national newsnational news actually right now isthriving the New York Times TheWashington Post The Wall Street JournalThe Guardian are all doing actuallyreally well as is television news andand and national radio so that’s kind ofinteresting welcome to our otherpanelists I’m so glad that you’re heredying to hear from you I’m going tointroduce each of you with with aquestion I’m interested to hear youranswer to a chat window we’re gonnastart with you you’re going to callJohnson with Flint beats um tell usabout your you have a very interestingmodel kind of a hybrid model at Flint betell us a little bit more about that areyou speaking to us being both– model while being for profit yes andalso all of the different ways thatyou’re looking to engage with your usersand tell us a little bit about what SlimPete is as well for people that don’tknow okay hi everyone my name is JeffWanda Johnson I’m founded on publisherof Flint B we started in 2017 March of2017 and our goal is to fill coveragegaps in the city that we cover whichFlint is an underserved and marginalizedcommunity this year we decided therewere focus specifically on public healthsolutions journalism and localgovernment and accountability whilestill doing those things like coveringneighborhoods artisan culture andeconomic development in the city ofFlint we are a for-profit but we do workunder a non profit model we do get grantfunding and we also we have a diverserevenue program or a building ourmembership as you talk you heard Stevetalked about community support until wedo things like we’re building on amembership program we also are workingon what do we just add revenue look likefor an agency that has been focused onNews being a public service versus usgetting ad dollars from businesses andwhatnot and so we’re looking at all ofthese different things in how they playa role in our sustainability in othernews rooms also for the future yeahthat’s great and you a lot on onpartnership I know in terms of trying toextend your reach and your ability toprovide more services to the communitywe do we’re a small newsroom actuallyfor a couple years it was really just meand everyone snow while we may have astringer come along so I wear multiplehats where I was publisher I was editorI was a journalist you know grant writernewspaper delivery girl you know all ofthese things and so this year we havemore capacity and are more able to coverthe community better but with that beingsaid we do collaborate we’ve worked withthe trace org on things we’ve partneredthem worth with Sarah Alvarez fromoutlier media you have Wendy Thomas whois on this panel also wendy has helpedus behind the scenes so far asestablishing what a budget should looklike and things that we should ask forfor our newsroom to be able to functiona run where a report for America thisyear so we’re proud and an honor to bepart of that program you know so we wehad to reach out to these differentorganizations and agencies andfoundations in order to build capacityin it to able us so we could better pullthis off in Flint and produce thecontent that the humanity needs that’sgreat I want to come back and ask youmore about that but thanks Jack Wandayou teed up Wendy and Wendy talk to us alittle bit about your news organizationand okay 50 justice through journalismyou have an interesting model in partbecause you serve a very specificpurpose in your coverage so talk to us alittle bit about what you’re doing rightso my k-50 is a three year old newsroomin Memphis Tennessee and we were foundedinitially to report on what Memphis haddone with dr. King’s sacrifice in thelead-up to the 50th anniversary of hisassassination and so today we are weremain in solidarity with the peoplethat dr. King would be in solidaritywith where he’s still alive and so thoseare workers and low-income people in thecity of Memphis one for residents livebelow the poverty line there so we knowthat there are information needs forthose communities and also we wantexists to amplify their voices you knowif we think about what stories will betold about Memphis in 50 years whenpeople are doing their dissertation onworkers in Memphis we want to be able toprovide information thatthat is relevant and important andcaptures their stories in the marginnarrative of Memphis and I know yourbusiness model is philanthropy you arenot for profit but also reader revenuesupport from the community tell us howthat’s going particularly during thepandemic yeah so you know this is a poorcommunity and so are raising the amountof dollars to sustain in you know fairpay for our contributors and writers andeditors is always a challenge and sowe’ve relied primarily on nationalfunders so we get support from theAmerican journalism project we to have areport for America fellow the borealisracial equity and journalism fund hasbeen a huge help to us and that’stargeting specifically minoritypublishers I definitely have to shoutout Tracy Powell for her work on thatthe serta foundation was a very earlysupporter of ours and consistent and sowe’re relying on those dollars as we’rebuilding a membership model that we hopeto launch later this year and justrelying on a lot of small individualdonors right so the path tosustainability is around building thatthat reader base who will support you asin a low well community which I thinkpresents particular challenges Iunderstood um Elizabeth green um youhave a very unique model in chalk beatthis the the that’s now being adopted byothers which is really interesting whichis a local a central hub with localoutreach so talk to us a little bitabout how chalk beat works and then Iwant to ask you about AJP as well sureso we are looking at kind of thisbusiness model problem was the originalfounding idea right how could we createa business model that was inlineactually with the mission of journalismit was pretty clear when we started thisjourney which was in 2008 already it wasclear that the business model did notline up with the mission and wasn’tgoing to sustain the work for the longhaul and in fact I think if you look atwhat’s happened in local newsused to have a model that was multiplestopics single place and that bundledapproach meant that advertisers whowanted to sell a car to anyone in youknow Memphis or any city in America orwanted to sell jewelry or wanted to selltheir clothes they could do a one-stopshopping by advertising that localnewspaper which again bundled manytopics that I covered serving onegeography what’s happened with the riseof the internet in addition to thetrends in digital advertising is contenthas become unbundled and so some localnews actually is continuing to thriveand that is the part of the bundle thatalways was commercial so that’s if youthink about the eater website whichcovers food all across the country onesingle brand or kerbs which covers realestate or services like Craigslist whichtakes classified ads and puts them allacross the country same for movielistings whether this is how theeconomics of the internet has turned ourlocal information sources into singletopic multi regional entities and sochalk beat is exactly that but for adifferent topic public education andpublic education like Public Health likeracial justice like economic justiceissues worker issues low income all thedifferent issues facing low-incomecommunities all of these issues are usedto be subsidized by the commercialissues right but we no longer are so wehave to find new ways to pay for thatcoverage we pay for it in you know whenwe started chalk beat this was the bigquestion what’s our business model gonnabe what is the business model we knowthe coverage that’s needed we know whatthe community needs to understand aboutpublic education we know what publicofficials need to be held accountablefor but how do we pay for it and earlyon I remember one of our supporterssaying well why don’t we just do thecontent and then somebody else willfigure out the business model and oncethey do we’ll just take that businessmodel and snap it on to what we’re doingactually our journey led us to a prettysimple conclusion the business model isto be a non-profitnonprofits are entities that havemultiple revenue streams supporting workin the public good some of those revenuestreams are philanthropy some arecorporate sponsorships some are you knowmembership contributions some are paidservices and some often are governmentsupport and so all of those thingsshould be in the mix supportingjournalism and that’s that’s what ourmodel is yeah and it’s a governmentsupport which is what we have to getwell we’re gonna talk about governmentsupport because that’s a that’s a that’sa tricky issue but before we do you youwear two hats you basically have twofull-time jobs in addition to having asmall child you are the co-founder andchair of the board of something calledthe American journalism project so righttell us what that is and what kind ofsolutions ajp is bringing to local newsso if the if the solution to local newsis to create new nonprofit institutionswhose sole mission is news gathering andinforming communities then we need newsources of capital to support socialentrepreneur of ected lis socialentrepreneurs like Wendy like Jaquan deand to do that we need to raise largeamounts of capital and invest them andstrong leaders and the scaling of theirinstitutions whether that meansdeepening and creating sustainablebusiness model in Memphis or whether itmeans Flint be covering all communitiesin Michigan so that’s that’s what a JPwas founded to do we have nearly closedour first fund where we raised 46million dollars to to reinvest we’realso supported the borealis fund andwe’re excited to continue working towith both connecting philanthropiccapital to the journalists leaders whoare going to build the future yeah and Iwant to make a nod right now again toour co-presenter the knight Foundationwhich funds the borealis fund that’sbeen referred to the American journalismproject and report for America and byextension also to jawanda and Wendy’snewsrooms andmany others I do want to talk aboutgovernment funding because that isprobably one of the most controversialfunding sources before I do a reminderto everybody that is watching the Q&Abutton at the bottom of your screenwe’ve had a lot of questions come in butplease add add yours we are going to getto your questions in a little bit so youknow Elizabeth you talked about yourbusiness model and I think it’s true formany not-for-profit news organizationsthat it is a hybrid model that it’s nota lot not reliant on the traditional tworevenue streams so traditionallynewspapers have relied on on two revenuestreams advertising and circulationtelevision cable television has reliedon two revenue streams advertising andcable fees but not for profit for a longtime has had to rely on a diversity ofrevenue streamsI was the president and CEO of NPR aboutten years ago and I inherited thatdiversified revenue stream and saw thewisdom and having many different sourcesof income which you which can protectyou and in a in a downturn to a certainextent as some things go up and somethings go down so those revenue streamsoften include advertising or sponsorshipevents contributions other forms ofrevenue and for many it includes fundsthat come from the federal governmentsome journalists many journalists Iwould say and I wouldn’t put myself inthat same category are a littlesqueamish about taking money fromgovernments because the hallmark ofjournalism is independence independencefrom the point of view of advertiserscertainly independence from anygovernment factors whether it be federalstate or local so I’d like to ask eachof the panelists to talk a little bitabout their their point of view and andthen we’ll get to and I’m sure there’llbe other questions about taking federalfunding Steve I’m going to comeback to you because you mentioned it inyour presentation but your idea is notdirect funding it is via avenues likeadvertising and sort of indirectsubsidies is that right yeah I thinkit’s important to distinguish betweengovernment policy and government fundingthere may be some types of directgovernment funding that makes sense toobut what I mean by that is there are allsorts of ways that the government makesdecisions that affect in positive andnegative ways how these models developedfor instance the IRS for years have givehas given very mixed signals as towhether or not they even consideredjournalism to be a legitimate publicmission for the purposes of establishingnon-profit organizations so a lot ofnonprofit news organization so you usedto be the case they would have to dotheir lawyers or tell them to delete theword journalism from their applicationsfor a non-profit tax-exempt statusthey’d have to be done no we really justwe’re really an educational institutionand so there’s a number of things thatcould be cleared up but like forinstance making it easier for nonprofitsto have earned revenue streams likesubscriptions and like sponsorshipswithout being deemed at losing theirtheir tax-exempt status or for instancethis is getting a little more in thedirection of spending but the governmentalready spends about a billion dollarson advertising for everything frommilitary recruitment to census adsPublic Health ads these are this is nota subsidy these are things they’re youknow they’re they’re putting out therein order to achieve certain missionsmost of it goes to network TV so asimple change that would have a hugeeffect would be to say actually whydon’t we have at least half of that goto local news organizations now when youget to the point of a more directsubsidy and that is where you get Ithink to the the really trickier case isthe history has been there have beensubsidies for media over the centurieslike the postal subsidy but they’vetended to be very Universal and veryindirect so when you get down to agovernment agesee you know writing a check to anewsroom based on you know the qualityof their journalism or the ideas thatthey have that gets to be much trickierand I think we should be talking aboutthat actually because the crisis is sosevere now that I don’t think even thatreally can be off the table anymore andwe need to be looking for approachesthat have really really good firewallsto prevent the kind of politicalmanipulation that could come from thatright and there are mechanisms right nowfor indirect federal funding that arefirewalls but highly imperfect Wendy uhdo you get any funding from anygovernment agency whether it’s the cityof Memphis or anyplace elsewell we are running actually right nowsome sponsored content from theTennessee Department of Health aroundthe coronavirus who they’re reaching outto minority community so we’re we aredoing that actually just earlier thisweek our lawyer Emily fifties lawyerthrough the reporters committee freedomof the press has sent letters to afederal judge in connection with thecity of Memphis ‘as unequal treatment ofMIP 50m they’ve refused to add us tomedia advisory lists this has been goingon for months and so when I heardiscussion about government support oflocal media on the whole I can see thevalue of that in Memphis it is hard tofathom how a local government thatrefused to acknowledge that all wouldhave any interest in funding any sort ofjournalism if it meant that a dime wentto MLK 50 and so I’m looking forward toseeing how other news outlets sort thisout when they are especially whenthey’re forming a very strongaccountability role with localgovernment I think sometimes you seekind of a mirroring of the attitudeswith local officials that you may seefrom the white house in terms of anadversarial role with the media and sothe old-schoolJoan newspaper journalists and me kindof cringes but I am confident thatpeople like Steve and people like Simongalperin and New Jersey who’s workingwe’re on the idea of in boat districtsI’m gonna let them chart that path we’reall looking for a way that it can bethat government we can take governmentfunding without it being without beingcompromised ajik Wanda what about youFlint be any any funding coming ineither indirectly like it is with Wendyvia sponsored content or directly nocurrently we’re not receiving anygovernment funding and we but we areworking with a local organization as tohow to tap into ad dollars or money forad dollars that are for my nightminority businesses and so here in thiscounty we’re working to get ourcertification as a minority businesswhere black owned female owned more than50% and can we get mass transportationdepartment to use those monies toadvertise with us because what we’regetting is that they’re not findingthese minority-owned news agencies wherethey can take that money and give it tous so it’s just sitting in a pot whenyou’re waiting to be spent and so we’relooking at it that way no officialsponsorships we’re not getting any addollars from the city of FlintTiana’s you know Wendy didn’t makemention of how the city of Memphis isdoing their News Agency they kind ofglances over even with Census dollarslike we were put to the table to help ona committee but not put to the table forthose monies and because of the newsthat we cover I get it they decided toput monies and other news agencies thatfocus more on what they considerpositive news and not necessarily thosenews agencies is going to they may takecritical eye and look at what they’redoing in a community and it could belooked at negatively right and so we gotlooked over and I and I get it you knowso I’m like Wendy when it comes togetting government funding as ajournalist it kind of makes me a littlesick as a publisher and a founder I haveto be open to getting dollars forsustainability for the publicationfuture so what does that look like I’msitting back and I’m letting you allfigure it out come to the meetingwell you’re both illustrating thechallenge of when that governmentfunding even if it’s in the form ofadvertising is discretionary and newsorganizations can either be punished orrewarded for their coverage which is nota very good scenario for independentjournalism Elizabeth you you are you area believer in in government funding fornot-for-profit journalism how do you seethat playing out and do you do youaccept or have you accepted are youapplying for any funding particularlynow during the pandemic so I guess Ithink you know no unfortunately I wishit weren’t the case the no fundingsource is pure and we need money to dothe work and so the question is what isthe the best source of money to do thework and the answer to me is diversifiedmoney because if any single source everasks us to change a story or threatensus because you know you if you writethis we won’t give you that then we haveto be able to walk away immediately andthat’s what we’ve doneoh you know in a chocolate becauseunfortunately that does happen we’redoing accountability journalism we’recausing some people to be upset as isappropriate and some of those peopleoften have big pockets and so they’regoing to try to to punish us or to getto use their their wealth to change theway we operate and so I think that theonly protects the best protection forindependence is multiplicity diversityso that no one personon the news and no uninstallation yourquiver in your boots to imagine as ajournalist who covers governmentinstitutions and that often are shuttingus out or getting upset at us orblocking us like when do you describefrom releases that we absolutely shouldbe participating in and receiving whywould we ask that exact same governmentfor support but actually really we’reholding all of us here are holdingentire power structures accountable andthose power structures have are thesources of philanthropic money – and soI believe as a taxpayer in that role notonly as a publisher not only as ajournalist but also as a taxpayer like Iwould like for my some of my tax dollarsto go towards independent news and Ibelieve that you know we still are areall stakeholders in this country I thinkand so if we decide collectively likethat’s something that we believe is apublic good that we want our tax dollarsto support we have to be able to figuresome way out to do it yeah and we’re nottaking any we applied for the PPPpaycheck protection program at choc begiven the financial uncertainty we’refacing and we were very fortunate to getthat in our bank account but that’s thefirst that to my knowledge that’s thefirst a certain infers major governmentsupport right well we direct supportwe’re gonna move off of this topic eventhough we could spend the next hour aretalking about it but I think what I’mhearing from a leave the crux is ifthere is a mechanism whereby taxpayermoney can be distributed in newsorganizations independent of anythingthat news organization covers that wouldbe welcome the current CPP Corporationfor Public Broadcasting that supportspublic media is in my personal view notindependent and so it’s it’s animperfect model and they’re there doesneed to be a better system fordistributing those funds you were gonnasay did you want to add something tothat Elizabeth OHsorry I just read the QA and I saw someof the questions oh okay we’re donereacting to live sorry okay all rightwell you have a very expressive faceokay we’re your questions and we’vegotten just amazing questions we haveunfortunately so much more that we couldpossibly get to so apologies for thatI’m gonna take this question this isfrom David Boardman who is the head ofTemple University’s journalism schooland it’s also served as a chair of a lotof amazing institutions including Lenfest which is another funder tojournalism in the Philadelphia area hisquestion he raises a good point he saidone gap in this conversation and so manyothers in local news is a discussionaround local television which is stillthe biggest source of news in mostcities although much of that news isderivative weirdest local commercial TVfit into this puzzle I’m gonna throwthat one to you Steve because you youknow you have a your background fromyour FCC work what it what have you seentoday and and over the years of wherethey fit into the information needs ofcommunities well local TV news is doinga bit better financially than newspapersin large part because of politicaladvertising often goes to local TVstations the one disappointing thing Iwould say to me in the last 10 years isthat you could have had a situationwhere a local TV responded to thecollapse of newspapers by themselvesinvesting in local reporting in a in adeep way that hasn’t really happenedwhich is unfortunateI think the encouraging the mostexciting thing that I would encourage atthis point is more collaborationsbetween nonprofit news organizations andlocal TV local TV the dirty littlesecret has always been that local TVoften would rely on newspapers as theirfirst source Circle Porter notexclusively there are some TV stationsthat do great original reporting but interms of really in-depth and enterprisestories a lot of it was coming fromnewspapers so when newspapers drawbut doesn’t just hurt newspaper readersit hurts the whole ecosystem of local TVstations and local radio stations andthings like that now you do now havethese nonprofits that a pop up doinggreat journalism and often times withouta lot of reach so the the naturalmarrying there would be for the for thenonprofit’s to team up with the TVstations and have better reporting withmore distribution so this question nextquestion is specifically for Wendy andJack Wanda this is from Candice Fortmanof outlier media Detroit her question isas founders and publishers that servemajority-black cities what strategieshave you found useful in reintroducingvaluable journalism to those communitiesand rebuilding trust with residentsjaquandae you have your your yourunmuted so I’ll let you go first so Iguess I’m first for me it’s a littledifferent I grew up in Flintso I’m a flint girl and I’m a product ofthis community that I cover because oneof the things I noticed is that thetrust level in these communitiessometimes is hard to break in tocommunities like Flint and they don’ttrust they didn’t trust the media thatwas already in place because of thecoverage I am that person that I’m atevents all the time whether I’m workingan event or I am at the event with myfamily so I made sure that I’m known inthe community I engage them on any plantin any and every platform so whetherit’s my website whether it’s FacebookInstagram I’m thereI also found that simply just answeringtheir questions I had a residentyesterday asked me something aboutelections I just answered it you knowand making sure that my team thatthey’re available to answer some ofthose little questions that they mayhave that you’re not dealing the answersto from wherever and connecting them topeople who can give them those answersso like I’m well trusted in thiscommunity andto pride in it where I do find that itcould be an obstacle is when we’relooking for funding so we’ve hadopportunities to potentially get fundingfrom local foundations that are notnecessarily trusted in the city becausepast practices in history and somesystemic oppression and so we have tofind that balance but as it stands rightnow I just do those good old things andand I show up and I’m there and I keepmy word and I don’t over promise when itcomes to what we what we do and I’m verytransparent so I’m the person that’ll goon Facebook and say hey yeah you knowyou all wanted us to cover XY and Z butdo you realize it’s just me you know orit’s just two of us trying to cover thiscommunity you know I’m very verytransparent about those things in theFlint community they seem to understandwhen I do that and about my journey toget me here because this year I’mpublisher but before we receive fundingfrom borealis because we receivedfunding for 40 hours this year over allthose hats you know and so just beingreally honest transparent abouteverything as it pertains to Flint Petehas really helped us in this communityreally fast so in I’m surprised becauseyou just us being honest it was managedto work out for us and also being ableto identify their needs so in Flintabout 30 to 40 percent of the householdsdon’t have internet and so when it cameto a really big election here is arecall election in a big city councilrace with pretty rotors guides and wedistribute them all throughout thecounty like I literally had those thingsin the back of my truck trouble aroundthe city of flint two public spaces thelibrary City Hall senior centers andthings like that because I can identifythat because I haven’t because I’m partof this community and I’m payingattention and I’m listening we do thatwith our news also we talk to thecommunity about stories that they’veread what do they like what did they buythey like to see we had a woman thatgave us a thumbs down yesterday on ourfundraiser which is fine we posted itsomewhere she didn’t agree and I shother a message and said hey what can wedo in the future to gain your supportwhat are we missing here what would youlike to see from us and so we have thoseconversations and not in a way where wehave eaten many right into a room andignore it in a way where we’re reallyactive and engaged with the communitylike we want them to be active andengaged with us so they tell ussomething we hear it a lot of times wewill implement it and to be honest itworks really what they want to seethat’s what the best local newsorganizations do so you’re living byexample Jaquan de because we have somany questions actually Wendy I’m goingto point a different direction to youinstead of asking you the same questionbut I think you’ll like this one it isfrom Bob Easter who is an angel investorwho asks beyond Kumud how do we bestsupport local news by subscribing todigital to print how angel investorwants to know how we can support you I’mgonna get that name out of the cut outthe donation link for Duke Wanda yeah soI think you know the early money for alot of us younger organizations theearly money to give us some breathingroom and sizeable amounts goes a longway you know I won’t speak for Shaquandabut I too was wearing a million hats andhelping us ramp up more quickly tocapacity I think is is very helpful youknow investing in the talent and thepeople and trusting them to to chart theway supporting collaborations like theones you’re seeing with ADP in borealisor really doing a lot of learninginternally with those those grantees forother people who are you knowangel investors or donors maybe on thesmaller level you know five figure levelfour figure level you know I know for usit’s really important important thatrecurring donations I mean like can wecount on money coming in month aftermonth after after month what that’sdoing a membership program or justsimply making a recurring donation andif you have expertise in a particulararea even as an annual investor not justthe money right so can you connect us toresource that they can help withmarketing or product development orthose sorts of things I think all ofthat is is very helpful thank you thankyou this next question is from ColleenMcCarthy with retro report she’s askingif you’ve seen good examples of newsorganizations partnering orcollaborating with local University Jschools journalism schools to supportlocal community needs for informationbeyond the student body Elizabeth I’mgoing to throw that one to you to any ofyour because you have there are chalkbeats in various parts of the countryare they collaborating any of them withjournalism schools are you collaboratingwith journalism schools to extend thatreach definitely journalism schools inprobably every single one of ourlocations we have some kind ofrelationship with whether it’s a feederfor interns internships or finding waysto deploy reporters CUNY j-school hasdone that with our team and others in inNew York City over the years indifferent ways so we definitely have tothink expansively about you know how weget more boots on the ground and Jschools are our one great way Steve areyou a report for America working withjournalism schools well we have some wehave we have some partners who areworking with journalism schools we workwith journalism schools to recruit greatcandidates but for instance I know theMacon Telegraph and in Georgia wasworking with Mercer University I thinkdown there to create some reallyinteresting collaborations but I thinkthere’s a lot more that could bedown there you know I’m gonna this nextquestion is for you Steve this is fromMaggie Farley who is a journalist andnow with Google’s global news initiativeshe asks you if the feet can the FCCallocate money to support localjournalism from spectrum sales yes it’sa it’s a it’s a public policy decisionthat Congress and the FCC could make andthe case for doing that is that thisspectrum at least some of the spectrumwas given to the public was given toeducational institutions communityinstitutions for the purpose of doingpublic broadcasting so and also when itwas given to private institutions therewas an assumption that they would have apublic interest obligation to supportnewsso that thing of incredible value thisthat that amorphous thing of spectrumwas something that always was supposedto have a public purpose to it and so itwould make sense to have some of thatmoney be set aside to help local newsthere’s a number we have so many morequestions that we could answer which isjust killing me but there’s a number ofquestions that are related to to thisone which is from Tim car at Free Presshe asks do you think certain types ofnews media are suffering worse thanothers under Kovan 19 for example ourlocal newspapers being harder hit thanlocal TV news there are also a number ofother questions that I’m seeing and itmay be a little bit of a confusionaround terminology when we saynewspapers do we really mean printnewspapers versus legacy priests printnewspapers who are largely particularlyduring the pandemic reaching peopleonline so the question is who’s beinghit the hardest I think we’ve alreadyheard that local news from a commercialperspective is doing okay any thoughtsabout legacy newspapers meaning and itused to be a print newspaper now onlineversus a startup that was born and onlyexisted as a digital platform which bothElizabeth and Jack Wanda andand Wendy represents I’ll give you aweird data point on that report forAmerica just as I mentioned announced225 new reporters and 162 newsroomsright at the very end as we were aboutto announced these kovat hit and we hadsome newsrooms pull out and then we hadother newsrooms raised their hand to toask for more corps members what wasreally interesting to me was that mostof the ones that pulled out wherenewspapers and some public radiostations none of the nonprofit newsorganizations the local nonprofit newsorganizations we’ve been talking aboutpulled out in fact they often asked formore and so this so we tend to think ofthem as being frail little fragilenonprofits but in at least in thiscontext they have turned out to be moredurable because they’re less dependenton advertising which is really what’sgotten walloped yeah well there arethere are a lot of questions that we’renot going to have time to get into thatbring us back into the governmentfunding a domain including from thepresident and publisher ProPublica dicktoefl who is questioning whether federalgovernment funding can be done in a waythat is not accompanied by pressureunfortunately we don’t have time forthat even though it’s an it is still anexcellent questionI want to close by asking each of ourpanelists to very briefly please wereally don’t have time as corny as itsounds I promise at the top of this itwouldn’t just be about problems we wouldoffer solutions in hope so I want to askeach of you to just briefly say whatwhat it is what is there anything that’scoming out of this pandemic and thissituation as relates to thesustainability of local news that givesyou hope Elizabeth let’s start with youI’m just hopeful that we can all learn abig lesson here and accelerate what wasalready in progress and the lesson isthat this local news has is an essentialpublic service in our democracy thatcannot be supported commercially we areseeing that happen right before our eyesright now and we have an opportunity towork together in new ways and gatherunprecedented level of diverse resourcesto support that core institution yeahthat makes me hopeful yeah Wendy yeah Ithink I’m encouraged by all the localcollaboration I see going on not just inMemphis but enough other communities wehave the alternative news weekly acouple other digital sites collaboratingright now on an SMS system that you knowmirrors what outlier media has beendoing and so I’m encouraged by that andthe conversations we’re having aboutshared revenue streams that we canexplore Shaquanda that’s makes it I’mreally encouraged with the grassrootscoverage for a lot of the independentnews organizations I know people like tothink it from the bottom up but I thinkit from the top down when you’re in acommunity and you’re able to cover themin how they’re responding to a pandemicto help each other and use really reallygreat ways that the communities arelooking at to navigate the pandemic tosustain themselves I think that isreally beautiful and also thewillingness from other news agencies toshare information as Wendy mentionedabout revenue like how can we cover thisand cover our expenses in pain reportersand build capacity just to handle thepandemic alone and how much informationthat we’re sharing across the boardwithout fear of competition so it seemslike we’re all passionate about whatwe’re doing in working hard to make surethat we all can do it the best way wecan and I think that that is reallywonderful as we navigate this thingcollaboration Steve I think before thisthere had been this among generalaudience not people like us who spendall day thinking about this of a realpuzzlement when we talked about therebeing a shortage of news like it doesn’tseem like there’s a shortage of anythinganyinformation we’re deluge dwith it and wekept saying no no no it’s localreporting is is where the shortage isand I think this has shown a really bigspotlight on it and in general peoplehave seen the value of local reportingyeah great so there is hope to come outof this people collaboration greaterconnection to the communities at agrassroots level greater appreciationfor the need for local news particularlyat a time when when so much is at stakeI want to thank all the panelists I wantto close on a very happy note which isthe angel investor wants to be connectedto all of you so we will make thathappen and thank you everybody we willpost a recording of this later on atAspen digital our Twitter stream and Ijust want to thank everybody for yourgreat questions in the panelists forjoining us thank you bye-bye
Local news, in crisis before the pandemic, is now facing a cataclysm. Advertising has plummeted. Print has no market. And consolidation has driven record cuts. At stake is not just jobs, but the access to critical trustworthy information for millions of Americans — just when they need it most. In this program, co-hosted with the Knight Foundation, we examine potential solutions to serve a country in dire need of independent news.
Wendi C. Thomas, Editor, MLK50: Justice Through Journalism
Steven Waldman, President & Co-founder, Report for America
Vivian Schiller, Executive Director, Aspen Digital
Elizabeth Green
Co-founder & CEO, Chalkbeat
Elizabeth Green is the CEO and co-founder of Chalkbeat, the nonprofit news organization dedicated to improving educational equity through local, independent, high-impact journalism. Since launching in 2014, Chalkbeat’s reporting has spurred changes in education funding, legislation, policy, and practice and is regularly cited or republished in dozens of publications, including The New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, the Atlantic, Vox, and more. Elizabeth is also the cofounder and board chair of the American Journalism Project, the first venture philanthropy firm dedicated to local news. Her book Building a Better Teacher was a New York Times bestseller and notable book of 2014. She has also written about education issues for The New York Times Magazine, U.S. News & World Report, and other publications. Elizabeth has been a Spencer Fellow in education journalism at Columbia University and an Abe Journalism Fellow studying education in Japan.
Jiquanda Johnson
Founder & Publisher, Flint Beat
Jiquanda Johnson, Flint Beat‘s founder and publisher, is a Flint-area native with more than 16 years of experience in journalism including print, television and digital media. She has worked for The Detroit News, NBC25, Fox and MLive Media Group/The Flint Journal, where she covered the city of Flint. As a reporter covering Flint for MLive, Jiquanda discovered that the community needed a news publication focused only on Flint, Mich. Flint Beat was launched on March 13, 2017 to fill that need.
Wendi C. Thomas
Editor, MLK50: Justice Through Journalism
Wendi C. Thomas is the editor and publisher of MLK50: Justice Through Journalism, a nonprofit newsroom in Memphis focused on poverty, power and public policy. Previously she was metro columnist and assistant managing editor at The (Memphis) Commercial Appeal. She’s also worked for The Charlotte Observer, The (Nashville) Tennessean and The Indianapolis Star. Thomas was a 2016 fellow at the Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard University. She is the 2020 Selden Ring Award winner for investigative reporting and won first place in the Association of Health Care Journalists’ 2019 awards for business reporting. Her “Profiting from the Poor” investigation tied for first place in the Investigative Reporters & Editors 2019 awards in the print/online division 1. In 2019, Thomas received the National Association of Black Journalists’ Best Practices award. In 2018, she was named Journalist of the Year by Journalism and Women Symposium. She was inducted into the Scripps Hall of Fame for commentary in 2008. She’s a graduate of Butler University and a proud product of public schools.
Steven Waldman
President & Co-founder, Report for America
Steven Waldman is the President and Co-Founder of Report for America, an initiative of the GroundTruth Project. He crafted the plan for it after authoring the Federal Communications Commission landmark report “Information Needs of Communities,” which NPR described as “one of the most comprehensive overviews of the U.S. media ever produced.” An experienced entrepreneur, he co-founded the multi-faith religion website Beliefnet.com, which won the National Magazine Award, and LifePosts.com, a platform for online memorials. Earlier, he was National Editor of U.S. News & World Report and National Correspondent for Newsweek. He was Senior Advisor to the CEO of the Corporation for National Service and wrote a book on the creation of AmeriCorps called “The Bill.” He’s also the author of the national bestseller, “Founding Faith.”
Vivian Schiller
Executive Director, Aspen Digital
Vivian Schiller is Executive Director of Aspen Digital. Over the last 30 years, Vivian has held executive roles at some of the most respected media organization in the world. Those include: President and CEO of NPR; Global Chair of News at Twitter; General Manager of NYTimes.com; Chief Digital Office of NBC News; chief of the Discovery Times Channel, a joint venture of The New York Times and Discovery Communications; and head of CNN documentary and long form divisions. Documentaries and series produced under her auspices earned multiple honors, including three Peabody Awards, four Alfred I. DuPont-Columbia University Awards, and dozens of Emmys. Schiller is a member of the Council on Foreign Relations; and a Director of the Scott Trust, which owns The Guardian. She is also strategic advisor to Craig Newmark Philanthropies.
{"includes":[{"object":"taxonomy","value":"133"}],"excludes":[{"object":"page","value":"134801"},{"object":"type","value":"callout"},{"object":"type","value":"form"},{"object":"type","value":"page"},{"object":"type","value":"article"},{"object":"type","value":"company"},{"object":"type","value":"person"},{"object":"type","value":"press"},{"object":"type","value":"report"},{"object":"type","value":"workstream"}],"order":[],"meta":"","rules":[],"property":"","details":["title"],"title":"Browse More Events","description":"","columns":2,"total":4,"filters":[],"filtering":[],"abilities":[],"action":"swipe","buttons":[],"pagination":[],"search":"","className":"random","sorts":[]}
The threats posed by mis- and disinformation loomed large ahead of 2022. What are the risks that faced the elections and what can we do to counter them?