hello everybodymy name is vivian schiller and i’m theexecutive director of aspen digitalwhich is a programof the aspen institute welcome to thoseof you who are joining us on zoomand also to viewers who are watching uson c-spanthis is to say the least no ordinaryelection yearand october is already proving to be anadvent calendar of surprisesas a reminder that as we count down toelection daywe’re facing record levels of mail-invotingconcerns about the united states postalservice confusion about drop boxespolling places at limited capacity dueto the pandemicallegations about ballots being lost andstolenand as of last night questions aboutwhat happens if one or more candidatesis incapacitated but it’s important alsoto remember that only three days agothough too many of us it seems likemonths ago uh the presidentonce again alleged to a nationalaudience and with no evidencethat mail and voting leads to fraud healso refused to say that he will acceptthe results of the elections i think ispeak for a nation when i say we arebracing ourselvesfor what happens when the polls close onnovember thirdalthough it’s important to say and wewill say it often during the next nexthourthat that in and of itself does notindicatethat the results are illegitimate we maybe used to learning the resultshours after the polls close in alllikelihood that will not happenthis year and that’s okay so how doesthis all workexactly what is the law what does theconstitution say and where is theconstitution silent that’s what today isaboutwe are very lucky to have four expertswho will shine a light on what to expectand what to prepare for once the pollsclose on november thirdthe plan is we’re going to have fourbriefings and then we’re going to takequestions fromyou those of you who are watching uslive consumcan submit your questions anytimestarting even nowuh by clicking on the q a bottom buttonat the bottom of your screenuh if you are comfortable doing soplease includeyour name your affiliation and if you sodesire where you’rewhere you’re watching us from uh we willget to those questions later or we’llget toat least some of them as we usually havemany more questions than we can answerbut please anytime you’re welcome to doso soto kick things off we’re going to startas all things mustwith the constitution how does thisexactly workthese elections and determiningdeterminations of who is the nextpresidentuh nathaniel priscilli is the james bmcclatchy professor of law at stanfordlaw schoolhis scholarship and legal practicefocuses on american election drawlaw addressing issues like voting rightspolitical parties campaign financeredistricting and electionadministration he is alsoco-director of the stanford cyber policycenterstanford program on democracy and theinternet and socialscience one nate thanks for being withuswell thanks so much for having me and iand i should add uhto that long introduction one other uhproject which is the healthy electionsproject which we’ve now started with mitand you can uh get some our material athealthyelections.orgincluding some of the material that’srelevant to what we’ll be talking abouttodayi’m going to do a quick powerpointpresentation in my seven minutesum but as i as i make that transitionlet me just start byreflecting on the news of the last uh 12hours and how it has an impact onin thinking about um contested electionsand everything that we’re uh going to betalking about in this sessionwhich is that um in addition to all theother questions that we are nowgoing to uh deal with we also have totalk about what happens if a candidateneeds to be replaced whether it’spresident trump or presidentuh vice president biden uh and there areprocedures in place for thisuh in the event that there is a uma reason that a candidate even after theballots have been printed needs to bereplaced that thethe rnc and the dnc have procedures thatare in place to do thatum uh such that then uh when theelection happens that the votes will goto that replacement candidate uh inaddition if itif the replacement happens after thevote then the sort of constitutionalmachinery uh goes into operationand we have to deal with the question ofhow the state legislatures might directthe uh presidential electors uh for eachstateuh that has been an issue that peoplehave been thinking about already withrespect to this electionbut different states are more or less uhwell positioned to do thatuh because some of the the states havelaws that require the electors to votefor a particular candidateuh that was on the ballot uh or and thenreceive the votesuh and so there is some potential legalambiguity therehappy to talk more about that in the thequestion and answer but let me talkaboutthe the the way we thought about this asof at least 24 hours agouh and and um how to think about acontested electionin this environment so umlet’s start just a little bit with thecalendar and and howuh how we should think about each phaseof the dispute resolution process so wewill haveuh an election day on november 3rd butas you know the ballots have already uhvoting has already begun millions ofballots have already been castuh and so and we should expect roughlyhalf of the votes to becast before election day umbut between election nightand two weeks later there are variousdeadlines for the receipt of ballotsand the expiration of a cure period fordisputed ballots for example someand different states have very differentrules on this some states will not allowvoters to cure defects in a ballot forexample if a signature doesn’t misdoesn’t match with what’s on fileuh or if there are other technicalproblems with it and then other statesgive youuh several days to cure those defectsbut that all of thatwill happen in the first two weeks afterthe election followed by a period wherewe havecanvassing of the ballots andcertification rightum actually the canvassing begins eveneven earlier than november 17thum but that the deadlines uh to completethe actual count of the ballotsuh go into the end the beginning ofdecemberand the reason that we have to get itdone by approximately that date and iwant to put anasterisk on december 3rd because there’sthere’s somepossible uh wiggle in the joints hereis that the under the electoral countact which is theum statute that governs presidentialelections passed by congressuh there’s a safe harbor deadline ofdecember 8th that safe harbor deadlinewas quite importantin uh bush versus gore it doesn’t meanthat if theif the votes are not completely countedby that date that thenum a state will not have its electorsuh count but that is the the law says ifthey do have themuh uh counted by that date that that isthe presumptive slate of electors thatwill go to the electoral collegewhich meets on december 14th and then inthe period between decemberand 14th and january 6 umwe have sort of a presumptive list ofelectors from every stateum uh maybe one list maybe more than onelist depending on the controversies andthen thoseum uh certificates are opened on thehouse of representativesin january 6th so at each stage of thisprocessthere is the potential for litigationlet me justemphasize though and i will make theseslides publicly available on my twitterfeed at personallyum is that the nature of litigation inthis election post-election litigationwill be determined by several factorsum that the the as was true in the 2000electionum the margin of victory at any givenstage is the mostimportant question so although it ispossible that we will be going intoovertime in this election and we have toprepare for that possibilityum it’s certainly not guaranteed andthat there it is possible we will knowvery soon after the election uh who wonand who lost uh we againshould prepare ourselves and shouldprepare the public for a long countingperiodbut it is possible that we will know uhwho won and who lostuh soon after election night um thendepending on the nature of the disputethe litigation will take different formsso whether it is a dispute over absenteeballots or provisional ballots orrecounts like we saw in the floridaelection i’ve got the palm beachbutterfly ballot behind me heredepending on the nature of the disputedifferent sort of uh triggers will bepulledum then there are the sort ofnon-traditional things that i think wehave to advert to these risks and someof the other speakers today we’ll we’lldiscuss themthings like what happens if there’sviolence in polling places if there’ssome unprecedented use of federalauthorityif there are real uh serious problemswith the post office that make ituh uh make them unable to deliver themail deliver the umuh ballots right depending on the natureof disputeand depending on the nature of the forumthe different deadlines maymay be uh shifted and by forum i meanare we talking about a dispute that isresolved in state courtuh and or federal court is it throughthe administrative process you may beremembering in the florida recount rightthere was a lot of administrativeuh work you remember secretary of statecatherine harris was in charge of thatum but obviously there’s a lot of workthat’s happeningat the local canvassing boards and thenas it proceeds through thestate system and different actors uhbecomemore or less important at differentstages of thisand so let me uh justjust run through quickly and i knowthere’s a lot of texts but like i saidi’ll make these available to people whowho request themum we need to understand there’s a lotof litigation alreadyright there are over 300 cases that havebeen uhfiled in this election already and andthey’re going touh set the tone for what comes uhafterwards and so i’m paying particularattention to this pennsylvania caseuh that is now potentially on its way tothe supreme court and how that mightuh lay the groundwork for laterlitigation if you’re interested we havea litigation tracker athealthyelections.orgwhich uh shows all the cases and howthey’re progressing through the courtsso on election day we will have lawsuitsandfor that matter even while the voting isuh occurring in thein the in the few days before well in inthe weeks beforeum and and we should not be surprised ifthere’s litigation overover polling place dysfunction or uhpotentially violence we’ve seen somestuff with respect topoll watchers and the like um but thenin the immediate aftermathas i said it depends on who is ahead andby how much and what the nature of thedispute isum we have but i want to emphasize thatyou know although we will have a floodof absentee ballots in this electionum states have rules to adjudicateand and evaluate these these ballots andwe just need to let the state processesuh work themselves out uh and so most ofthe action will start in the stateum and then local canvassing boardsright and then potentiallyuh end up in state court and the like umit is possible though of course thatthere that because depending on thenature of disputeyou could have federal court action toprotect the right to vote allegationsthat theelection has been you know marred byfraud would likeum in those in that week or two after uhthe electionright we will see the processing as isaid of the mail ballots some of theseuh issues regarding the curing ofabsentee ballots could be litigatedum and as we saw in bush versus goreitselflitigation over the rules that wouldapply in perhapsthe counting period um but thenif it remains close and that is ofcourse a big ifthen as we approach the safe harbordeadline it becomes extremely importantright that the recountor the the actual count be completed uhso that then the electors can meet inthe electoral collegenow we assume because we went throughbush versus gore not that long agoalthough for my students uh many of themwere not even born yetum so uh that would that would followa bush versus gore path right that thisu.s supreme court would get involvedthat there would be it would be veryjudicializedprocess and that is possible right it ispossible that we’llhave litigation that would end up in thesupreme court and they might beactively involved of course with thedeath of justice ginsburg thingsbecome a little bit more complicateddepending on if you havefour four uh splits at the courthousebut there are alsoother paths which then take advantage ofother aspects of the constitutionalmachinerysuch as the state legislatures steppingin to appoint electorsnow there is a a considerabledispute i would say over whether statelegislatures can ignore the will of thevoters if the voters expresstheir preferences um on election day andit’s clear who theyvoted for but under a scenario in whichas we could think you know thecandidates are arguing about fraudand they sort of try to say that there’sa cloud over the resultsit is possible that you could seedifferent slates of electors coming fromthe state legislature and the governorof each state that then would have to beresolvedon the floor of the house ofrepresentatives i want to emphasizethoughif a a state legislature somehowsubverted the willof the voters right that would raise allkinds of other constitutional problemswith respect to violating uh the rightto votebut we’ve never really been in thatsituationand with the possibility of candidatereplacement you could easily see uh somestate legislatures uh exercising thatrightuh i’ll this end with what would whatthen happensuh uh in in the succeeding periodby january 6 there’s the counting on thefloor of the house representativesuh and um and then january 20th is whenthe new presidentis sworn in and if no president has beenchosen by that point then um the thesuccession act uh kicks into place asdoes the 20th amendmentand the speaker of the house ofrepresentatives becomes presidenti will end it there and turn it over tomy other colleaguesnate thank you so much first of all toeverybodywe’ve seen some questions saying can youshare the presentation we realized itmight have been a little hard toread it was showing up in present reviewwe willuh share the slides nate will share iton his twitter feed we will ataspen digital on our twitter feed andwe’ll also email it to youso uh yes the answer is yes i’m surethere’s a lot of questions for nate wewill get to those but we felt it wasimportant to start withwhat does the constitution say what isknown what is unknown so thank youuh for that nate um we’re now going toturn ohturn it over to talking about how thatwhat the how the newsmedia works in these instances as areminder the news media does not call anelection they project an election eventhough sometimesum there’s a little sometimes thewording in some news organizations theyplayed a little fast and looseuh it is really just a norm andsomething we’re used touh we’re used to knowing because theelect the results have been so clearit’s possible that won’t be the casethis year and which is why it was soimportant to start withuh with everything that nate just talkedabout but let’s turn it over to the newsmedia because that’s generally how wefind out what’s happeningin the world which is a good thing um uhhere to tell us how it works issally busby she is the senior vp andexecutiveeditor of the associated press sheoversees global newsoperations and news content uh fromjournalists based in 250 locationsaround the worldshe led ap’s coverage of the 2016presidential campaignelections including polling and coverageof the white housecongress and the pentagon uhsally over to you thank you for joiningus thanks so muchand welcome everyone so what i’m goingto do is indeed talk about how newsorganizations fit into thatstructure that constitutional structurethat nate just laid outincluding our key role in projectingelectionsand counting the vote on election nightso first it’s sort of important toremember that the u.selection system is very decentralizedthere is no federal agency that overseesvotingthe states each control how theirelections are runand in practice that has led to a widevariety of practicesand different levels of skill at runningelectionsso on election night states report tothe public their election results asthose results come inwhat my organization the ap and otherorganizations dois to tabulate all those results gatherthem from each of the 50 states and putthem togethercleanly so that the public can see thewhole picture on election night theelectoral college does not meet for avery longtime as nate laid out um and then basedon thatas the vote comes in we say who is goingto winthese elections we realize we are notthe official word as vivian saidin the country but what we do is that wedoa very strong mathematical calculationbased on the vote countand when a trailing candidate has nopath to catch upor to win mathematically we tell thepublic that that person has wonthat race or that state or somethinglike thatthe networks also all do this each of usdoes it independentlyand for the record our methodology fordoing that is laid out in fulltransparency on our website at ap.orgso back to how the system works as weknow as they laid out the presidentis not decided by popular vote theelectoral college the race to 270electoral college votes is how thepresidency is decidedso this in fact is why newsorganizations focus on battlegroundstates somestates under this system that thefounding fathers set upare in fact more critical and others areless criticalsome people’s votes do have more impactat the margin than others that’s justthe way the system is set up whether welike it or notso for example if a candidate beatsanother candidate by 100 votes in thestate of floridathey get all of florida’s electoralvotes and that is one of the mostcritical things to keep in mind whenwe’re looking at news coverage onelection nightso thirdly and very importantly absenteeearly and mail-in voting has beengrowing strongly in the united statesfor years a full 42 percent of americanswho voted in 2016 in the presidentialracedid so by either voting early or votingby mailthey did not show up at the polls onelection day um and that was before thepandemicand the vast majority of that as we knowhappened without any fraudso obviously this year because of thepandemic more people want to vote bymailor early states are having to ramp upquickly to prepare for thatsome are ready others are still tryingto get ready i willsay that as a news organization we foundthat states got better at handlingmail-in ballots as the primaries went onthe springsummer and fall so there is evidencethey are getting on top of itmeanwhile as nate said there’s already alot of court fights being wagedlegislatures making last-minute changesover the rulesthings like how long after election dayshould a mainland ballot be countedmuch of that is the subject of intensepolitical battlesone thing that’s very important to keepin mind is that in general most statesnot all but most tend to count mail-inballots lastsometimes that can be days afterelection day this has happened routinelyover the last few years it is notsomethingnew and why am i going through all thisthe reason is to point out that a lackof speed on election nightin news organizations calling racesdoes not mean that something bad ishappening it does not equal corruptionor problems necessarily it might in factjust mean that a state is being carefulto count all its mail-in ballotsand maybe it’s struggling a little bitwith more of them than they’ve had inthe pastbut that doesn’t mean that they won’teventually accurately count all of thoseand report themwe and a lot of other news organizationshave done a lot of fact checks aboutwhat the president has said on mail-inballotingbecause it really does not track withthe reality and the accuracy of what wesee that has happenedso from a race calling perspective as isaid but what the news organizations doon election nightwe cannot project winners call racesuntil we know for sure that someone hasactually mathematically wonor that they know they have no path tovictorysome states have automatic recounts soeven if someone’s aheadif an automatic recount is triggered ata certain levelwe’re not going to call that racebecause we know there’s an automaticrecount that’s going to happenso if stake are going slower than normalaccounting ballotsbecause they’re trying to you knowgrapple with this new worldthat will in fact likely impact how fastrace calling by the networks and by theassociated pressgoes on election night we do intend tobe transparent on election night that’sone of the things that i think is mostimportant if we have said that you knowa state is not we have not called a raceor we have not projected a winner in astatewe we will go on air we will go um youknow toour the people who we give our reportingto to our customersto the public and explain why that is sowe will tell the public what is going onin real timeif there is this vacuum where a race youknow a winner is not clearso that’s one big chunk of the situationthis year that’s kind of in some waysthe most important thingbut at the same time we are doing a lotof other things umyou know uh this story is sort ofchanging every daywe know through empirical facts a lot ofpeople have requested ballotsif they get nervous about sending themin and then decide to show up at thepolls anyway there’s some indication inthe last few days that some people aredoing thatum then of course there might be a lotbigger crowds at the polls than wethought ofum so there’s just a lot moreuncertainty about not who people willvote for butthe the actual physical ways they willvote than there has been in the past andall of that could affect race callingthat of course is just one element weare also ramped up on election night forwhat everyone else on this call is goingto talk aboutpossible intimidation of voters or othertypes of conflict or unrest on electionnightwe’ll have to be able to cover that inreal time to show the world and thepublic what’s going onand then of course we are completelyramped up for either real timeor next day legal battles we assume thatmany of those will emanate from thestatesum and that they will be hard fought inmost casesso that’s just sort of a very quickoverview ofum the role of the press on electionnightum and also i think um you know some ofthe things that most news organizationsare trying to prepare themselves foruh in case there is a contested electionwe obviouslyum had a lot of experience from 2000 ofsomething going to the supreme courtwe have thankfully reporters in everystate who can follow all of these localum uh you know lawsuits as they play outbut i think the most important thingthat we think we need to dosally i think we might have lost youraudio there for a second but uh you werejust wrapping up so we’ll umwe’ll keep it there hopefully everybodycan hear me i assume somebody will tellme if you can’tum so sally thank you so much uh forthat uh really uh terrificum context um we againuh i want to just a reminder toeverybody if you have questionsclick on the q a button don’t put it inthe chat um please click on the qa button add your name your affiliationand your location if you’re comfortabledoing so and then your question is in assuccinct a manner as possible umwe’re now uh uh in terms of our nextspeaker just just days ago we learnedthat trump’suh president trump’s 2016 campaignuh was accused of actively trying todeter uh three and a half million blackamericans in battleground states fromvoting they did so but withuh targeting them with negative uhhillary clinton ads specificallytowards those uh individuals on facebookthis is uh sadly not the sole instanceof attempts to suppresscitizens of color from voting to talkaboutthat and more we are really pleased tohave cherylin eiffel she is thepresidentand director counsel of the naacp legaldefenseand education fund the nation’s premiercivil rights law organizationfighting for racial justice and equalitya position she has held since 2013previously she was with the aclu whereshe litigatedvoting rights cases and taught civilprocedureand constitutional law at uh universityof maryland’sschool of law for almost 20 years so uhshe is uh we’re so thrilled to haveum yet another wonderful expert on thesetopics and cheryl and i turn it over toyouterrific thank you vivian and thank youall for joining thisimportant convening uh so we heardearlier that there will be litigationaround this uh this election and i canassure you that there will beum let me just give a lens into the waywe’re looking at this in terms of theafrican-american community and ithink that might be of interest to youum so we have a number of concernstwo of them are really top of mind atthis momentthe first one is around intimidationitself the issue of potential violencethe issue of you know individuals andgroups intimidating black voters at thepolls i think a lot of what we’ve heardover the last two weeks suggests thatthis is notum an irrational uh concern and fear forus to haveuh and so we can expect that there aregoing to be a number of concernsabout whether there has been votersuppression that happens in real time atthe polls in front and franklyas we’ve already started to see earlyvoting is in play for this as wellthis may mean that there are realconcerns on the back end of whetherall voters in particular polling placeswere able to participate equally in thepolitical processuh the issue of militias and so forthwill be taken up by one of oursubsequent speakers but they all fallinto this bailiwick ofintimidation we should remember thatintimidation is not just aboutindependent militia groupswe also have concerns frankly aboutstate actors umyou heard the president talk aboutbringing out sheriffs and so forthuh we’re also on the lookout for thatthere are a number of civil rightsstatutes that will help us on the backend 42 usc 1983uh 42 usc 1985 that prevents againstconspiracies to interfere with the rightto votebut those are those are back-endlitigation that will be available to usand that might form the basis for beingable to challengeuh election results that come in toparticular polling placesso it’s critical to be aware of that thesecond big uhbailiwick is around absentee voting andthat’s because during this covet 19pandemicmany civil rights organizations havepushed to try to expand absentee votingopportunitiesuh for black voters uh the blackcommunity has been very hard hit as youknow the black and latino community bythe covet 19 pandemicand so a number of us inc including thelegal defense fundhave really uh honed in on some of theonerous absentee voter requirerequirements in some stateswe just uh recently won our litigationin louisianauh three days ago we received afavorable decisionin alabama which relaxes absentee votingvoter restrictions and what this meansis that we are going to see something wegenerallydon’t see so african-american voters areless likely traditionally to voteabsenteeafrican-american voters often havemistrusted the absenteeprocess want to vote in person it ispart of a kind of aan acknowledgement of history uh and sotraditionallywe have not wanted to vote absentee it’salso truethat the votes of african americans whocast absentee votesare more often not countedthan those of white voters because oferrorsin how the absentee vote was returned tothe pollsbut i think this year we’re going to seesomething quite different because wehave beenencouraging uh particularly elderlyafrican americans who are more likely tocome out to the polls traditionally tovote absenteeto protect against covet 19 pandemicwhat that means then is that there’salso the obligation on the back end tocount all of those absentee votesand so election night is one issue butthe week after electionis going to be critical to count thosevotes particularly in places whereuh african-american turnout isparticularly important to thepresidential electionto senate elections and to other downballot raceswe expect and fear frankly that theremay be intimidation of vote countersuh many of us are old enough to rememberthe brooks brothers riot in 2000uh during the uh bush versus goreum uh election uh you know our fear thisyear is that rather than wearing khakisthey will be strapped with ar-15sand so it’s critical that to engage withattorney generals with governors toprepareto protect the election counters theweek after the electionso that we can ensure that all absenteevotes are counted to the extent thereare problems on election day and therealways areand this we expect to be an incredibleturnout on election daythere will be more provisional ballotscast than usualthese are the ballots that are cast whenyou come up to the table and you knowthis is your polling placebut somehow your name is not on thebooks you’re placed on an inactive listor there are other issuesassociated with your ballot you may bepermitted to vote provisionallythe provisional ballots are not countedon election night the following week youhave to come back into the board ofelectionsto cure the provisional ballot toexplain why you should have been allowedto vote at that polling placenow many years this is not a big dealbecause the elections are not that closebut in a number of states andjurisdictions where the elections may becloseeven the provisional ballots will becritically importantand once again to the extent that wehave seen massivevoter purges at targeted targeted at theafrican-american communitypolling place changes targeted at theafrican-american community and othervoter suppression activitieswe should expect the disproportionatenumber of people who will be castingprovisionalballots will be black voters and so onceagainwe will be pressing to make sure that uhafrican-american voters who votedprovisionally will have an opportunityto cure those ballots on the back end sowe’ve got the issue of intimidationwe’ve got the issue of absentee voteswe’ve got the issue of provisional votevotesi should also mention that the issue ofthe polling place itself on election dayand the need to extend polling placehours is likely to be the subject oflitigationin a number of jurisdictions we’re goingto have very long linesuh especially to the extent that we haveuh problems that exist with machines andwe have seen this in 2018 and 2016machines that mysteriously uh switch thevotefrom one party to another uh they haveto bringout then uh technicians to to calibratethe machinesuh in gwinnett county georgia you mayrecall in 2018 the polling place is openfour hours late becausefor some reason the power cords uh werenot in the polling placewe typically go into court then onelection day to seek an extension of thehours we saw this in the primaryelection this yearthe last vote in the primary in nevadauh just uh this summer was cast at 1 amso there’s going to be litigation thatday to try to extend the hours of thepolling placeand that too may be the cause of some ofthe delay in being able to callelectionsbut also some of the confusion that mayhappen at the pollsand we fear intimidation that may happenat the polls particularly ifuh the president frankly uh you knowuses social media to suggest thatpeople vote the traditional time ofsomehow regular illegal or evidence offraudi want to add one thing on the countthat hasn’t been discussed and that maynot be discussed todayand this is about what happens onjanuary 6thyou will recall that during uh bushversus gore on january 6 when theelectors were all to now be accepted uhby the congressit was the members of the black caucuswho stood and opposedthe acceptance of the 25 electors fromfloridathey were acting in accordance withthree usc section 15in which they were raising an objectionunder that statute that objection canonly be receivedif it is also signed by at least onemember of the senateno member of the senate was willing injanuary 2001to sign that objection raised by membersof the congressional black caucusbut this year given all that we havetalked about and thevery many legitimate reasons why peoplemay have concernsabout the votes that were cast and votersuppression in a number of stateswe should keep in mind that the newsenate is seated on january3rd and that this meeting does nothappen untiljanuary 6 there may be a senator whois willing to sign on with theobjections maderaised by members of the houseparticularly members of thecongressional black caucusif they believe that racial votersuppression happened in eitherthe uh casting or counting of ballotsthis is one of the reasons why thesenate races are so importantand so as we think about calling theelection and what’s going to happen inthe countwe should remember alabama whichnormally is written off in thepresidential election as a red stateum we should think about georgia weshould think about south carolina theseare places in which there are closesenate races and obviouslyarizona and colorado more traditionallyuh looked at asas potential battleground states ldfworks principally in the south uh we arefocused onthose states uh we are a nonpartisanorganizationbut we believe it’s critical that everyvote is countedum and so i would just draw yourattention to the fact that we reallyhave to take this all the way to january6and that potential statutory challengethat may be received quite differentlyuh in 2021 than it was received in 2001.i’ll stop there and happen to takequestions latercherylin thank you so much there arejust so many uhvariables and i’m so grateful to the uhto all of the panelists for sheddinglight onon on all of them um in the debate theother day you may recall that thepresident told the white supremacistgroup proud boys to quote standback and stand by and while there aredifferent interpretations as to what hemeant there isevidence that far-right and neo-fascistgroups are preparing to actthere have already been signs ofintimidation at polling places earlyvoting uh polling placesuh and in uh in the event of uhdemonstrationsuh by supporters of vice president uh inthe event of intimidation at the pollingplaces what does the constitution sayabout armed militia and demonstratorsuh to shed light on that topic we arepleased to have mary mccordlegal director at the institute forconstitutional advocacy and protectionand visiting professor of lawat georgetown university law centerpreviously mary wasacting assistant attorney general fornational security the department ofjusticeprincipal deputy assistant attorneygeneral for the national securitydivisionand was with the u.s attorney’s officefor the district of columbiauh mary thanks for joining us and overto youthank you so much for having me espenand to all of themy fellow uh panelists so i know ourfocus here is on the day afterbut um in light of vivian’s comments andin light of what we all heard on tuesdaynight during the presidential debatei think it’s worth talking also a littlebit about umthe prospect of armed groupsintimidating voters at the pollsuh you know the president the othernight was unwilling touh denounce the possibility of civilunrest following the electionhe was uh urging his supporters togo to the polls to pole watch and he wasof coursereaching out to the proud boys to standby this is really a dog whistle for farright armed groups in the country who haoperate wholly outside of governmentalauthority and have shown themselveshistorically and particularly in thislast year and particularly since thepandemic startedand george floyd was killed have reallyshown themselves to be coming out inpublic much more frequentlyand certainly in response to things thatthe president saysand that is both in opposition togovernment such as what we saw earlierthis springwhen groups of armed individuals stormedstate houses and governors mansions inlansing michigan and inlouisville kentucky and elsewhere inopposition topublic health safety orders shutdownorders and stay-at-home ordersuh and more recently in response toanti-masking or mask orders that they’reopposed towe’ve also seen arms groups deploying inwhat is more of aaugment so purported to be anaugmentation of governmental authorityand that is usually in response toracial justice protests where theyuh ostensibly deployed to downtownstreets duringdemonstrations and peaceful marches inorder toprotect property often in response tofalse rumors of violent anarchistscoming into those communitiesthis is as tr has had tragic results aswe’ve seen in kenoshaalbuquerque and other places with peoplebeing shot wounded and of course killedin kenosha two peoplekilled um these armed groups as imentioned they have a historyof responding to the president’sstatements not just recentlybut over the last several years soseveral groups responded to thesouthwest border after the presidentcomplained about the migrant caravanthreatening the usthey of course have no authority theyweren’t called into action byany governmental authority but decampedto the southwest borderand took uh migrants into custody andheld themfor customs and border patrol we sawthem deployedwe’ve seen them deployed at pro-trumprallies ostensibly to protectrally goalers and we’ve seen them umuh call out over social mediaa willingness to come to the president’said back during the impeachmentproceedingsshould if in the event that thepresident should have been impeached andremoved from officenow of course we have the daily dose ofdisinformationabout mainland balloting beingsusceptible to fraudand about any delay in the tabulationbeing the result of a rigged electionum and so based on the past we canexpect that that really will be sort ofa call for some of these armedorganizationsto self-deploy to the polls to protectthe vote uh protect against fraud andthen post-election to protect thethe counting of the vote and if theresults don’t go their waythere is already talk on social mediaaboutcivil unrest um so what i want to makesure is if you take only three thingsaway from what i have to say today it’sfirst that armed groups of individualshave no authority under federal or statelaw that’s constitutional or statutorylawto call themselves into service as amilitiasecondly the second amendment theindividual right to bear armsdoes not protect paramilitary activityor militia activity by unauthorizedarmed individuals and it does notpreventstates from prohibiting it third all 50states prohibit itso let me unpack that a little bit foryou groups will often refer to the useof the termsmilitia in the us constitution and instate constitutions to saythat’s us we have authority under theconstitutionto exist to muster and to self-deploywhen we think there’sthat it’s necessary but militiahistorically in the states back even tobefore independence here in the usrefers to all able-bodied residentsbetweencertain ages who are available for thegovernmentto call forth into active service indefense of the statethere is no authority in federal orstate lawfor armed groups of individuals toself-activate or call themselvesforth and call themselves fourth andit’sin fact every state has a verycomprehensive schemeby which the governor in times of needcan call forth able-bodied individualsonce he does so and this would be toaugment the national guards whichalready exist in all 50 statesif he does so they then becomesubordinate to and must report upthrough the civilian governmentin fact 48 stage states have baked intotheir constitutionsthe requirement that in all cases themilitary be subordinate to the civiliangovernmentsecond for all the areas uh of grayin the second amendment this is not oneof them the supreme court in 1886upheld wherein right post uh civil warreconstruction upheld a law thatstill exists to this day in 29 statesthat prohibits bodies of menfrom associating together as militaryunitsor parading or drilling in public withfirearms the supreme court upheld thatstatute againstconstitutional uh challenge in 1886saying that it was without question thatstates had to have the abilityto prevent such private paramilitaryorganizationsin order to protect peace and good orderin 2008the supreme court in district ofcolumbia versus hellerwhen holding for the first time in thatcasethat the second amendment protects anindividual right to bear arms for one’sownindividual self-protection pointedlycontrasted thatwith um its statements in 1886 andreaffirmed that the second amendmentdoes not prevent statesfrom banning private paramilitaryorganizationsand of course the third point is all 50states toowhether it’s through the constitutionalprovisions i mentionedwhether it’s through the anti-militiastatutes which are criminal statutes in29 statesor whether it’s throughanti-paramilitary activity statuteswhich exist in 25 stateswhich bar training instructingdemonstrating or practicingin the use of firearms or techniquescapable of causing injury or deathduring a civil disorderor whether it’s through statutes thatbar the false assumptionof the duties and functions of lawenforcement there is no state thatauthorizes this type of private armedactivitythere is no state um that doesn’tprohibit itexplicitly in its laws so it’s incu it’sa comment about i don’t think going intothis electionpre during and post we can necessarilyrely on the federal government toprotect voter safety and public safetythis is going to fall on state and localofficialsto know these laws to make publicstatements right nowabout the the the importance of votersbeing able to feel safe at the pollsthe importance for public safety afterthe electionboth while we’re tabulating the votesand after a winner is declaredand the fact that the laws do not permitthis type ofself-help this vigilante uh activity byprivate armed organizationsthey can be investigating now they canbe issuingcivil orders they could be doing evencriminal prosecutions where necessaryand it really should stretch acrossacrossthe ideological political divide icommend uh the republican commissionerof elections in philadelphia yesterdayfor coming out strongly against voterintimidationand that’s the kind of thing that weneed to see let’s bothyou know support the validity of theelection there’s no reason to believethat there uh is going to be any type ofmassive fraudno reason to believe the disinformationthat is circulating on social mediaand cut and urge peace calm and and umand the peaceful transition of powershould that bethe result of the election marythank you so much so muchmisunderstanding about those points andi really appreciate your last comment infact all of our panelists have been soclear that whileuh we all must remain vigilant we do notwant to undermineconfidence in systems that are in placeandthat work we’re going to jump right intouhin our remaining minutes we’re going tojump right into the questionsnate this first one is for you and itcomes from adam wasserman in new yorkfor states like pennsylvania which ofcourse is a swing statewith a republican-controlled legislatureunder what circumstances can thatlegislator decideon its electors rather than uh theelectors that were voted inby majority what are the standards forthis happening wellunder pennsylvania law it and let meemphasize that this varies state bystateso so uh what i’ll say aboutpennsylvania does necessarily applyeverywhereum but under pennsylvania law it has tobe the choice of electors actually hasto be part of a normal law makingprocess which involves the governorright and so there are several levels atwhich this question is being asked andthe firstquestion is suppose there is you know aclear winner inin the in the popular vote in uhpennsylvania and then the statelegislature wants toessentially overturn that election canit do that and the short answer is notunder pennsylvania lawbut then you get into an interestingdebate under the u.s constitutionbecause article 2of the u.s constitution says each stateshall determine in a manner determinedby the legislature thereofa number of electors and so you do havethe possibilityuh that state legislatures could makethe argument that they haveindependent authority to chooseelectoral states now i want to emphasizethat that’snot the end of the story even therebecause you knowwe have a robust uh jurisprudence now onvoting rights so that if you overturna a popular election that that thecourts will have something to say aboutitum i do want to emphasize one thing justbecause i may have spoken an error in mypresentationand i’m glad that cherylin mentionedthis which is that umthe the the adjudication of the finalcertificates for the electoral collegeis done bycongress as sharon mentioned it would beboth the senate and the housethat would do it it’s actually openedthe certificates are opened on the floorof the house of representatives but thedispute isuh done by both houses of congressthank you uh thanks nate um the nextquestion sally we’re gonna direct thisone to you it comes from david boardmanum in pennsylvania who is of course uhor is a legendary um editor andjournalistuh the question is uh sally has therebeen any discussionamong the major news players ap otherwire services the new york timeswashington post and the networksabout working together on ground rulesfor winter projections this yeargiven the unique circumstancesi assume you mean around race callingand and other thingsi mean uh that’s a great question ithink that’s sort of a double-edgedswordi i think that there has been someum i mean i’ve thought of that questionand things like that i thinkthat the media is very um worried aboutlike if i went to other newsorganizations and said hey here’s howwe’re going to doelection night i think that we could beopen tosome you know people in this countryperhaps saying that the media wascolluding or something like that sothere has been i think someyou know no i mean we all have ourethical standards umother news organizations that you knoware fact-faced and credibleand that have high standards we consultwith regularly just to make sure thatyou know we knowum like are we doing things the rightway is there some better way we can dosomething or something like thatso there hasn’t been actually but we’vebeen participating i wouldanswer the question another way we havebeen participating in every panel likethis we can ever find so that we canthrow out what we doin the most transparent way as possiblelike i said how we call races is on ourwebsiteso we’re doing that so that the publicand certainly other news organizationshas the right to you know contact us sayhey we don’t agree with this wecriticize this or whatever i meanthe level of transparency that we aretrying tohave this year i would say is incrediblyhigher than any past yearand you know i know a fair amount i meanthere’s sort ofyou know everyone race callsindependently okay or everyone projectsraces to use you know the independentlybut you know it’s a small world and weall know what each other’s standards arei fundamentally think that that group ofpeople um including the peopleyou know at fox there was a really superinteresting ben smith column the otherdayabout the race calling operation at foxwhich is a verygood operation by the way um and veryindependent from itsyou know sort of um talking head peopleum you know i think everyone is tryingto do the right thing sodavid we’ve sort of talked about some ofthat but i do thinki’m a little leery of the idea that allthe news organizations in americaare you know getting together anddeciding what to do and so what we’retrying to dois stick to our standards be transparentabout our standardsand then in real time be transparentabout our standards which isyou know the kind of the thing for us todo that we didn’t always do historicallyin the pastbut we are willing you know any panellike this that is talking to the publicabout what the media is doing i amwilling to show up atand we are willing to lay everything outthere beforeelection day anything that anyone hasany ideas about ways toopen up the books of the news media weare open to that ideathanks sally so much um the nextquestion comes from catherine voylesuh she writes hello from washingtonstate something i’ve heardour secretary of state say and by theway the secretary of state iskim wyman a republican and washingtonstatehas been this is my editorial uhaddition to the uh for the for theaudience that washington state has haddecades of experience with mail andvotinguh something i’ve heard our secretary ofstate say is that a job of an electionadministratoris to convince the loser that they didin factlose i would be very interested to hearany or all of the panelists talk on thisissue um sherilyn would you like to takethat onewell first of all i’m not sure thatthat’s the job of an electionadministratorum and i especially think that manycandidates will be imperviousto that uh this year uh people havewhole teamsthat they are using to advise them onthe count and as isuggested i think these exogenousfactorsthat we’ve all been talking about arevery much going to influencewhether candidates are willing to acceptthe count so yes on one hand i think theelection administratorswant to be able to do their job and thisis one of the reasons why i thinkthe uh potential intimidation of of ofcounters after the electionis so harmful obviously it would be aterrible thing but it also will increasethe likelihood that candidates will notaccept uh the resultif they feel pressure has been broughtto bear on those counting theballots and it will undermine uhconfidence in you know what electionadministrators sayis the outcome so it’s very importantthat the countingthat there be a wide birth around thecounting so that peoplecan feel confident in that subsequentweek that the ballots are in fact beingcountedwithout intimidation without electionadministrators being doxedwithout some of the other things that wefear may happen that willundermine the ability of people tobelieve uh that they should haveconfidence in the countand may in fact undermine the theconfidence in the countand and just while i have the mike uhvivian i just want to point out just forthe last questionabout you know whether news media havecome together so we should remember alsosocial media and facebook has announcedthat it will not allow postsby campaigns or the candidates callingthe electionuntil reuters and ap have called theelectionso there is um you know i’ve been inmany conversations with the facebookteamabout our fears about some of some ofhow facebook will be usedone thing they have agreed to do is thatis that they will not allowthe platform to be used for candidatesin their campaigns to so-calledcall the election on and they arerelying on reuters and facebookexcuse me reuters and ap as their kindof official sourcesand they will not allow it until thoseuh races have been called bythose two platforms great thanks that’sa reallyimportant addition uh the next questioncomes from sonya jarviswith brook uh college at cuny should webe worried that the president couldorder the us attorney general to impoundvoting boxes in keyswing states under the voting rights actor if there are civil unrest on electionday could the presidentinvoke the insurance insurrection actum mary i don’t know if you want to takethat oneum if not we can give it over to natewell i will take the second piece ofthat and i’ll letnate or sherilyn uh take the first pieceof that on the impoundment of theof the ballot boxes but when it comes tothe insurrection act the president doeshave some authority to call forth statemilitias and by state militias thatmeansofficial militias the national guardthose are who are reporting up throughstate authority and he has the authorityto to do that in certain circumstancesincluding insurrection or the inabilitytoum really you know protect uh federaland state law to enforce and protectfederal and state lawso the question there then is you knowhe can also ask voluntarilyfor states to send their militias so forexample what we saw in washington dcon may 30th 31st june 1st right aftergeorgefloyd was killed when we saw thepresident asking for state nationalguards to send theirum units to dc to quell the civil unrestthat was actually not a use of theinsurrection act that was a request forthem to voluntarily comeand and a number of states said yes buta number of statesuh governor said no to that request sothe insurrection actyou know is not just a request it’s ait’s a demand and it’s in certaincircumstances and sothe the question there would be are thecircumstances of insurrection orrebellionor the you know the predicates in thestatute actually met based on what’sgoing onnow i think it would be a misuse of thatauthorityfor the president to suggest for examplethat he didn’t think the outcome wasfairhe didn’t think it was right and toprotect against uma civil unrest he would invoke theinsurrection act because ifif there is no reason to believe thatthe election is unfairthat that seems that would be an abuseof that authority that saidum you know we have an attorney generalwho is a verymuch a believer in um the unitaryexecutiveauthority which with a great deal ofauthority in the presidentand so it would remain to be seen whatsort of uhlegal advice or legal arguments theattorney general would make i think thisis another areawhere potentially we could seelitigation if this authorityis misused thanks marion and sheldon doyou want to just quickly take the firstpart of that question she’ll be worriedthat the president could orderthe attorney general to impound votingboxes in key swing stateswell we know the president can order theattorney general to do anything thequestion of course is whether theattorney generaldo it and um with this attorney generalsadlyuh this is the you know the randomfactor uhwhether he could lawfully do it i iwould of course say nouh but unfortunately this attorneygeneral has uhtaken positions that many of us thoughtare quite alarmingparticularly in relation to state powerand and state authorityuh this is one of the things i think wehave to keep top of mindalmost all the things i mentionedearlier as potential bases forchallenging elections or for beingconcerned about what happens on electionday and during the countare matters that we would normally reachout to the department of justiceto assist us with or the local u.sattorneys to assist us withand i will say that this year uh in inmany states uh we don’t feel that wayand certainly in terms of what theattorney general is likely to do thereis really no confidencein the civil rights community that theattorney general would be protecting theballotfor voters uh rather than for thepresident at this momentcarolyn um thank you for that and i’mreally sorry to say that we are out oftime because there are so many othergreat questions or a lot of questions inparticular about the specific impacton president trump’s illness and thevarious scenarios there thank you fortouching on that a bit nate i’m sorry wecouldn’t get to them um but thank youfor being with us we will post thisuh a recording of this session uh on uhaspen digital uh uh twitter uhhandle we uh also will this will bebroadcast on cnbci wanna thank all of our speakers andour participants and umit’s gonna be an interesting fall andglad you could all be with usthanks very much
Journalists, civic organizations, policymakers, and technology executives are rightly focused on protecting the integrity of the elections. With so much at stake, concerns about disinformation, voter intimidation, and the voting process itself are top of mind.
When the polls close on November 3rd, however, democracy may face a new set of challenges. With record levels of mail-in voting, counting could last days or—in some jurisdictions—weeks after election day, leaving a void for speculation about ballot-rigging or other improprieties, even if there’s no evidence of wrongdoing and counts are performing as intended.
Fueling the flames of any controversy or question about the legitimacy of the election will be heightened rhetoric among supporters of the candidates, amplified by social media. This has the makings for an unprecedented constitutional crisis that could dwarf what we saw in 2000 with the Bush v. Gore legal fight. How can we be ready?
Sally Buzbee, Senior VP & Executive Editor, The Associated Press
Sherrilyn Ifill, President and Director-Counsel of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Inc.
Mary McCord, Legal Director, Institute for Constitutional Advocacy and Protection, Georgetown Law
Nathaniel Persily, James B. McClatchy Professor of Law, Stanford Law School
Vivian Schiller, Executive Director, Aspen Digital
Sally Buzbee
Senior VP & Executive Editor, The Associated Press
Sally Buzbee is the Senior Vice President and Executive Editor of The Associated Press. She oversees global news operations and news content in text, photos and video from journalists based in 250 locations worldwide. Previously Buzbee served as Washington bureau chief for six years, where she led AP’s coverage of the 2016 U.S. presidential campaign and election of Donald Trump and the 2012 election, including oversight of polling and investigative units, as well as coverage of institutions such as the White House, Congress and the Pentagon. Buzbee joined AP in 1988 as a reporter in Kansas and also worked as a reporter in Los Angeles and Washington. In 1996 she became assistant bureau chief for news in Washington where she ran spot news coverage and oversaw in-depth foreign affairs and national security coverage. For five years beginning in November 2004, Buzbee served as AP’s Middle East regional editor based in Cairo. In that position she led AP’s news coverage across media formats during the Iraq war, and managed personnel, logistics, budgets and security for AP’s Middle East region. Buzbee holds a journalism degree from the University of Kansas and a Master of Business Administration from Georgetown University. She has two daughters, Emma and Margaret.
Sherrilyn Ifill
President and Director-Counsel of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Inc.
Sherrilyn Ifill is the President and Director-Counsel of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Inc. (LDF), the nation’s premier civil rights law organization fighting for racial justice and equality, a position she has held since 2013. Ifill began her career as a Fellow at the American Civil Liberties Union, before joining the staff of the LDF as an Assistant Counsel in 1988, where she litigated voting rights cases for five years. She taught civil procedure and constitutional law at the University of Maryland School of Law for almost 20 years. She serves on the board of the Learning Policy Institute and on the Advisory Board for the Profiles in Courage Award.
Mary McCord
Legal Director, Institute for Constitutional Advocacy and Protection, Georgetown Law
Mary McCord serves as Legal Director at the Institute for Constitutional Advocacy and Protection (ICAP) and Visiting Professor of Law at Georgetown University Law Center. McCord was the Acting Assistant Attorney General for National Security at the U.S. Department of Justice from 2016 to 2017 and Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General for the National Security Division from 2014 to 2016. Previously, McCord was an Assistant U.S. Attorney for nearly 20 years at the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Columbia. McCord graduated from Georgetown University Law School and served as a law clerk for Judge Thomas Hogan of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.
Nathaniel Persily
James B. McClatchy Professor of Law, Stanford Law School
Nathaniel Persily is the James B. McClatchy Professor of Law at Stanford Law School. Professor Persily’s scholarship and legal practice focus on American election law or what is sometimes called the “law of democracy,” which addresses issues such as voting rights, political parties, campaign finance, redistricting, and election administration. He is codirector of the Stanford Cyber Policy Center, Stanford Program on Democracy and the Internet, and Social Science One, a project to make available to the world’s research community privacy-protected Facebook data to study the impact of social media on democracy. He is also a member of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. Prior to joining Stanford, Professor Persily taught at Columbia and the University of Pennsylvania Law School, and as a visiting professor at Harvard, NYU, Princeton, the University of Amsterdam, and the University of Melbourne.
Vivian Schiller
Executive Director, Aspen Digital
Vivian Schiller is the Executive Director of Aspen Digital. A longtime executive at the intersection of journalism, media and technology, Schiller has held executive roles at some of the most respected media organizations in the world. Those include: President and CEO of NPR; Global Chair of News at Twitter; General Manager of NYTimes.com; Chief Digital Officer of NBC News; Chief of the Discovery Times Channel, a joint venture of The New York Times and Discovery Communications; and Head of CNN documentary and long form divisions. Documentaries and series produced under her auspices earned multiple honors, including three Peabody Awards, four Alfred I. DuPont-Columbia University Awards, and dozens of Emmys. Schiller is a member of the Council on Foreign Relations; and a Director of the Scott Trust, which owns The Guardian.
{"includes":[{"object":"taxonomy","value":"133"}],"excludes":[{"object":"page","value":"148446"},{"object":"type","value":"callout"},{"object":"type","value":"form"},{"object":"type","value":"page"},{"object":"type","value":"article"},{"object":"type","value":"company"},{"object":"type","value":"person"},{"object":"type","value":"press"},{"object":"type","value":"report"},{"object":"type","value":"workstream"}],"order":[],"meta":"","rules":[],"property":"","details":["title"],"title":"Browse More Events","description":"","columns":2,"total":4,"filters":[],"filtering":[],"abilities":[],"action":"swipe","buttons":[],"pagination":[],"search":"","className":"random","sorts":[]}
The threats posed by mis- and disinformation loomed large ahead of 2022. What are the risks that faced the elections and what can we do to counter them?